AITA For Not Begging Dad to Fund Sister’s Dream School, Staying Loyal?
Years after a messy divorce, a devoted dad pours his heart and resources into his daughter, the 18-year-old at the center of this tale, ensuring her comfort through tough times. When DNA tests at 14 revealed her and her twin sister weren’t his biologically, he still claimed them as his own, but the sister chose mom and bio dad, leaving him behind. He rebuilt, landing a stellar job, and padded his daughter’s college fund for their dream school—a pricey prize within reach.
Now, as college looms, mom calls, stunned by the plan, and demands dad boost the sister’s fund too, admitting she dipped into it. Sister and bio dad pile on, urging our heroine to sway dad or share her fund. Caught between loyalty to the dad who stood by her and a twin’s shared dream, she’s torn. Was standing firm a selfish move? Let’s unpack this family fray!
‘AITA For Not Begging Dad to Fund Sister’s Dream School, Staying Loyal?’
A divorce and DNA twist turned this family upside down, and now college plans fuel the fire. Our steadfast daughter stuck with the dad who raised her, weathering his struggles until his new job secured her dream school. Her twin sister, aligned with mom and bio dad, now faces a shortfall—mom used 10% of her fund and wants dad to bridge the gap. He refused, and the daughter’s caught in a tug-of-war, pressured to plead his case.
This echoes a broader issue: navigating family ties and fairness after betrayal. A 2020 U.S. Census report notes 10.6 million kids live in blended families, often facing uneven support. Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, wrote in a 2022 Psychology Today piece, “Post-divorce, loyalty binds kids to one parent, and financial splits get messy when trust’s broken.”
Dr. Papernow’s wisdom applies—dad’s bond with his daughter grew through loyalty; the sister’s choice to walk away shifted responsibilities. Mom and bio dad, not him, own her fund’s fate. A fair fix: sister explores scholarships, loans, or affordable schools. The daughter’s wise to avoid guilting dad—protecting their bond honors his sacrifice. She can support sister by sharing aid tips, keeping peace without betrayal.
Here’s the comments of Reddit users:
Reddit jumped in with bold, cheeky takes, and we’ve stacked the best for you—sharp and ready to slice through this family fuss! Here are the top community thoughts:
![[Reddit User] − NTA. Your sister made her choice.. There are consequences to actions and now she is reaping what was sown. You might be twins but IMO your dad is not her dad. She chose bio-dad and now wants your dad to be 'bank dad'. She didn't want to know, and I'm guessing she still doesn't want to know him just his bank account.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/279410c-05.png)
![[Reddit User] − NTA, frankly none of this is your business and shame on your mother for triangulating and dragging you into this.. She sounds like a real peach.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/279410c-20.png)
![[Reddit User] − NTA. You are wise in staying out of it. I'm sorry this has added a strain to your relationship to your sibling, but she has to realize that you can't cut people out of your life and then expect them to support you above and beyond what was intended.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/279410c-21.png)
These are fiery Reddit views, but do they nail the story? Is the daughter right to shield dad, or should she nudge him for sister’s sake? This drama’s thicker than a dorm mattress.
This college fund clash weaves a knot of loyalty, choices, and family fallout. Our daughter clings to the dad who weathered storms for her, while mom and sister lean hard, craving the same dream school shot. It’s a messy mix—dad’s not bound to fund a daughter who left, yet guilt stings. Clear talk might’ve eased this, but lines are drawn. What would you do if your twin pushed you to split your fund? Would you guard your dad’s gift or bend? Toss your thoughts, feelings, and family tales below—let’s untangle this together!
