AITA for Saying My Mom’s Dating Past Affects Our Family Now?

Imagine a childhood where every new face at the dinner table might be your “new daddy,” only to vanish weeks later. For one Reddit user, this was reality, as their single mother’s whirlwind of boyfriends left a lasting mark. Now, as wedding plans spark a heated clash, the daughter pushes back against her mom’s demand to embrace her stepfather as family, revealing old wounds from an unstable past.

This story dives into the messy ripple effects of a parent’s choices on their child’s heart. The daughter’s blunt honesty about her mom’s dating history and its consequences stirs a family feud, leaving readers to ponder: was she wrong to call out the past, or is her mother refusing to face the truth? It’s a tale of boundaries, love, and lingering scars.

‘AITA for Saying My Mom’s Dating Past Affects Our Family Now?’

My mom was a single mom from before I was born. I know of my biological father and his family. I know who they are and even confirmed at 19 through Ancestry that they were my biological relatives but they don't want me and I don't want them. From a very young age I knew my mom dated a lot. She introduced me to almost every guy she was with.

Some I would see twice at most and would hear from her that she loved them and wanted us to be a family and then they'd be gone. Others stuck around a little longer and a few of those were better to me than she was. They were kind, accepting of me being there and would make me smile.

While mom always put the weight of her relationships on my shoulders and would tell me how I needed to behave and make a good impression and accept that I was getting a new daddy. It was not a very stable time for me. I struggled a lot. Some of her boyfriends I bonded really well with and was sad when they were gone, others I was glad to never see again and some I was truly indifferent toward.

By the time I was 12 I was just over it and decided to just exist when she'd bring me around guys and think of other stuff and make plans with friends. Then when I was 15 she met the guy she married and married him after six months.

By the time I met him I had a whole range of experiences with her guys and honestly, he was nowhere near the best.  So I'm indifferent to him and I have no special bond with him. I don't consider him my father figure or parent. If I cut my mom out tomorrow or if she died, he would no longer be part of my life.

My mom has had this expectation for me to accept him as my dad and embrace him into my life and it has been a problem for her that I was closer to some of her ex's than her husband. It first really came up when I graduated high school and only listed her as a parent in the pamphlet thing they made and distributed to all the guests with our names and who our parents were.

She brought it up a lot after that and then went on to complain when she found out I had one of her ex's on my FB, who I reached out to to thank in my early 20s for being so good to me and we're still friendly. When I told her recently I was getting married we argued. She told me how she couldn't wait to see me on her husband's arm, going down the aisle and I told her it wouldn't happen.

ADVERTISEMENT

We argued. She brought up yet again the fact there are ex's of hers, that would have gotten the position (and that's really a maybe because IDK for sure). I told her she cannot make me feel a certain way about her husband and she has to accept that by dating around so much and introducing me to so many guys, etc,

had consequences and that one of those is some of them I liked more than her husband and by the time he came around I was already tired and not as open as before and that I had many people I could compare him against. She argued that I was being SO unfair to her and had no idea how hard being a single parent is.. AITA?

ADVERTISEMENT

Navigating family ties after a childhood of instability is no small feat. The Reddit user’s refusal to embrace their stepfather as a parental figure stems from years of being introduced to fleeting “dads,” a pattern that eroded trust. The mother’s insistence on forcing this bond ignores the daughter’s emotional reality, shaped by an unpredictable past.

Dr. Lisa Damour, a clinical psychologist, notes, “Children need stability to form secure attachments. Frequent changes in parental figures can disrupt emotional development” (Psychology Today). The OP’s experience reflects this, as their mother’s rapid partner turnover left them guarded by adolescence. A 2018 study from the American Psychological Association found that children exposed to multiple parental partners often face trust issues in adulthood.

ADVERTISEMENT

The mother’s perspective, shaped by the challenges of single parenting, clashes with the daughter’s need for autonomy. Her expectation that the OP bond with her husband overlooks the emotional toll of past instability. Dr. Damour’s insight suggests the mother’s actions, while not malicious, prioritized her needs over her child’s sense of security.

For solutions, open communication could help. The mother might benefit from acknowledging the OP’s feelings, perhaps through family therapy. The OP could set clear boundaries, like choosing who walks them down the aisle, while inviting the mother to share in wedding joy without forcing roles.

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit weighed in with a mix of empathy and fire, serving up takes as spicy as a family reunion gone wrong. Here’s what the community had to say, with a pinch of humor to keep it light!

LaetiHelianthus - NTA her expectations are unrealistic. Humans need to make emotional bonds, they don’t just “become family”

ADVERTISEMENT

diminishingpatience - NTA. It's ridiculous of her to imagine that, after all of that, you would immediately think of her most recent partner as your father. You sound as if you have dealt very well with a difficult situation when growing up. She now needs to accept that it's time for you to make your choices, just as she did.

This_Miaou - Absolutely NTA.. Exposing children to a succession of potential step-parents is traumatizing to the children, for the reasons you already stated. You are a grown adult and don't need anyone to give you away. In a lot of ways, you raised yourself.

You can invite whomever you like to give you away, if you want. Other relatives, even your mother. Your maid of honor. Your favorite of your mom's boyfriends. Anyone! The choice has to be meaningful to you, your mom doesn't get to dictate anything.

ADVERTISEMENT

stonecloakwand - NTA: So it WASNT unfair to you while you were growing up that your mother kept trying to fill the hole of a 'fatherly figure' in your life and finally you just got sick of it and just played along? No one blames you for that. She's trying to guilt trip you into doing something you dont want to do or have the emotional capacity to deal with.

You don't have a relationship with this man and its completely reasonable that you dont want him in your wedding. Hell, as a ***courtesy*** he can be your mom's plus one but thats it.You don't even have to extend an invitation to him as far as im concerned.

She shouldn't have treated her home as a revolving door of men. It's careless and even I know some guys that REFUSE to bring women home to meet their kids until a certain amount of time has passed to avoid situations like these. Your mother was very careless in this fact and shes the A H in this situation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Marie0492 - NTA - Your mom did what everyone tells single parents not to do, you do not introduce your children right away to someone. I didn't meet my husband's children for months, which gave us both time to decide if this was a relationship we wanted long term.

They had been told about me a few months in, and then I met them after 6 months of us talking, 4 months of actually dating. Honestly she could google what she did and probably find every parenting book under the sun saying what she did is not recommended. I'm glad you were able to stay in touch with some of the men who were good people in your life when you needed it, and have continued to be.

LovelyReaper7779 - Oh, OP. I am so sorry. Your mom did what I, a single parent, never wanted to do. I personally made horrible choices when looking for/being in relationships. After my second failed ltr I decided that: 1. I wanted to get to the root of *my* issues and why I kept choosing bad guys. 2. I was absolutely terrified my kids would get abused.

ADVERTISEMENT

You will never be an AH for telling someone they do not get to make you feel a way you don't want to feel or tell you that you can't feel a certain way. Idk if you've considered counseling (it literally changed my life). I never would've survived to my age without it.. Congratulations on your wedding!

TrayMc666 - NTA The plain fact is, he is not your father, he’s never been your father figure and he never will be. You do not have to include him just because your mom is demanding it. Bringing lots of different men home and introducing them as new dad wasn’t your moms best move either.

I’m not surprised you emotionally cut off from that eventually. Your mom caused this problem. This man is just your mom’s husband, that does not make him your dad. Your mom needs to accept this. I’m not convinced she will though.

ADVERTISEMENT

BeastOGevaudan - NTA - She could have dated without hyping each one up to be your next daddy. Parents shouldn't introduce their kids to their partners for several months for good reason!

sofiesophie - nta. while being a single parent is hard, she clearly didn't think about how that all affected you. as much of a hardship she went through, so did you, if not more than her as you were so young and didn't have much a stable environment in that sense

Rude_Vermicelli2268 - NTA. She doesn’t get to decide who walks you down the aisle. She also needs to understand that just because she loves her husband it does not mean you do too. It’s hard being a single parent but it’s also hard being a kid with random people flitting into and out of your life with no say.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit reactions are a rollercoaster of support and shade, but do they capture the whole story? Is the mother clueless, or is the daughter holding too tight to the past?

This family saga leaves us wondering how past choices shape present bonds. The daughter’s stand against her mother’s expectations is a bold claim for her own narrative, but it risks deepening their rift. When does honesty about old wounds heal, and when does it hurt? Have you ever had to confront a parent’s past decisions? Share your stories and insights below—let’s unpack this together!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *