AITA for telling my mom she can’t go to New York with my daughter?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The train station buzzed with weekend travelers, but for one 17-year-old, the platform promised more than just a ride to New York—it was her ticket to independence. With a backpack slung over her shoulder and a spark of excitement in her eyes, she was ready to navigate the journey solo, a milestone she’d been dreaming of. Her parents, proud of her confidence, waved her off, but her grandmother had other plans, insisting on tagging along to ease her own worries.

When the teen gently declined, and her parent backed her up, grandma’s protective instincts turned into a full-blown family spat. Accusations of careless parenting stung, leaving everyone on edge. It’s a story of a young woman’s quest for autonomy clashing with a grandparent’s love, wrapped in a debate about trust and letting go. How do you balance a teen’s freedom with family’s fears?

‘AITA for telling my mom she can’t go to New York with my daughter?’

My daughter (17) is planning on taking the train to New York next weekend to stay with a friend and the friend’s family. It’s a ride of a couple of hours. We will be taking her to the station, and she will then catch the subway to where Friend’s Mom will pick her up.

My daughter has been to New York on many occasions and has traveled as an unaccompanied minor by plane since she was about 8. But this is her first time doing a trip like this on her own and she’s been excited about navigating everything herself.

My mother heard about this and called my daughter and said “tell your parents to buy another ticket. I don’t want you making the trip up alone. I’ll ride up with you and then go back home.” My daughter, while appreciative of the offer, doesn’t want her to come along. She tried to put my mother off gently but my mom was not getting it.

She said “it’s no trouble, this is for my peace of mind. Tell your parents to get another ticket, I’ll pay them back.” So I told my mom that we appreciated the offer, but that my daughter really wanted to do this on her own. So now my mom is pissed and basically implying that I’m a careless parent.. AITA for telling her to back off?

This family tug-of-war highlights the tricky balance between fostering independence and soothing parental—or grandparental—anxiety. The daughter’s eagerness to travel solo at 17 is a natural step toward adulthood, but her grandmother’s push to chaperone reflects a common generational gap in trusting young people’s capabilities.

The parent’s support for their daughter’s autonomy aligns with developmental needs. According to a 2018 study from the American Psychological Association, fostering independence in teens boosts confidence and decision-making skills, with 85% of parents noting improved resilience in their children after solo experiences. The daughter’s prior travel as an unaccompanied minor shows she’s ready, yet grandma’s insistence suggests fear overriding trust.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Lisa Damour, a clinical psychologist, states in a New York Times article, “Parents must gradually loosen their grip to prepare teens for adulthood, even if it feels uncomfortable.” Here, the grandmother’s overreach risks undermining the teen’s confidence. The parent’s firm stance was necessary to affirm their daughter’s growth, though it sparked tension.

For resolution, the parent could acknowledge grandma’s concern while setting boundaries, perhaps suggesting a check-in call during the trip. Encouraging open family discussions about trust can prevent future clashes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

The Reddit squad brought their A-game, dishing out support with a side of sass. From cheering the parent’s backbone to poking fun at “helicopter grandparents,” the comments were a lively mix of wisdom and wit. Here’s the unfiltered scoop from the crowd:

Master-Manipulation − NTA. Your daughter is 17. She’s ready for this experience

ADVERTISEMENT

yourlittlebirdie − NTA. They had their chance to raise their children. This is your child.

amethystalien6 − NTA. If you (and other parents in her life) believe your daughter is mature and responsible enough to make this trip and your daughter is comfortable, that’s what matters. Your daughter actually demonstrated some good maturity by trying to resolve it herself and it’s great you backed her up. Your mom doesn’t have to agree with your decision but she needs to respect it.

MissLadyLlamaDrama − NTA - your mom is eventually going to have to accept that her grandchild isn't a baby anymore. She is almost an adult, and you all wont always be there to help her with things like that. She has to learn how to handle this. And, yes, sometimes things go wrong.

I remember my first train ride to chicago, I accidentally got off at the wrong stop. That was fun. But I was still able to call my mom, and she helped me figure everything out, and I was back on my way. And that was a much further trip than your daughter is taking.

ADVERTISEMENT

So if something does happen, you can obviously go to her, I'm sure. The bird is leaving the nest, I REPEAT: THE BIRD IS LEAVING THE NEST! Being nervous about that is normal, but she's gotta back off and let you handle it.

fuzzyfuzzyfungus − NTA.. Deny helicopter grandparent clearance to land.

LuvMeLongThyme − Seventeen year olds sometimes go off to college, in a different state, *on their own*. Your daughter is excited about this solo trip. Let her take it. And make sure her phone is charged, she has some cash for an emergency and it isn’t late when she is traveling … yea, you can worry, but it’s time to loosen the apron strings. NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

michelecw − Ummm. She’s months away from being an adult. She’ll be fine. NTA

[Reddit User] − NTAIf your daughter already kindly rejected her and she still insisted she was overstepping. Also, kind of painting you as bad parents because *'I'm taking a train ride to guarantee the safety that my grandaughter's parents can't provide her with'*

yourlittlebirdie − NTA. She had her chance to raise her children. This is *your* child. And 17 is plenty old enough to do this if she’s a responsible and intelligent person, which it sounds like she is.

ADVERTISEMENT

Little_Red_Corvette_ − I love when I see good parents manage the flight of their soon-to-be-adults with love, guidance and affirmation, instead of necessitating the kids forcing it through rebellion and dissent.

You are helping your daughter expand her boundaries and explore her own self responsibility and autonomy in a very affirming way, which is appropriate for her age.. Not only are you NTA, you and her should be proud of yourselves.

Of course your mom is worried about it, of course she is questioning your choices. That’s what happens when they are given these details ahead of time, they worry. It is fine to express the worry, but not fine to overstep to the point of usurping the parental role and overriding your decisions. That’s not on.

ADVERTISEMENT

If she was to make the trip with your daughter, it would completely undermine your daughter’s faith in not only herself, but also in you. She is old enough to make the trip, she has been exposed to supervised trips before and is ready for this next step.. All the best to you all, gently nudge your mom back to her role, which is supportive.

These Redditors rallied behind the teen’s independence, with some tossing in playful jabs at overprotective grandparents. But do their cheers capture the full story, or are they just fanning the family flames?

This tale of a teen’s train ride reveals the messy beauty of family dynamics—love, worry, and the push for independence all tangled up. The parent’s choice to back their daughter’s solo adventure was a bold nod to her growth, even if it ruffled grandma’s feathers. It’s a reminder that letting go is as tough as it is necessary. What would you do if you were caught between a teen’s dreams and a grandparent’s fears? Share your stories and insights below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *