AITA for not including ex wife’s stepson on a trip with my son?

Under the sun-dappled shade of a lakeside retreat, a father plans a cherished summer escape with his 12-year-old son, Brandon. Their tradition of kayaking and hiking faces disruption when his ex-wife insists her stepson Todd, 14, join them, alongside his brother Jared, 10. Todd’s past bullying—name-calling, theft, and breaking Brandon’s belongings—has left deep scars, and Brandon wants no part of him.

Despite the ex’s plea for bonding and claims of Todd’s jealousy, the father refuses, prioritizing his son’s peace. Her persistence paints him as unreasonable, but he holds firm. Is his exclusion of Todd a protective act for his son, or an unfair snub of a struggling teen? This tale of co-parenting and past wounds pulls readers into a tense family standoff.

‘AITA for not including ex wife’s stepson on a trip with my son?’

This lake trip dispute is a tug-of-war between a father’s duty and a stepfamily’s strain. The OP’s refusal to include Todd, a known bully to his son, prioritizes Brandon’s emotional safety—a choice grounded in Todd’s history of aggression. The ex-wife’s push for inclusion, while well-intentioned, ignores the real risk to Brandon’s well-being.

Blended families often face such friction. As family therapist Dr. Patricia Papernow notes, “Forcing bonding in high-conflict step-relationships can backfire, escalating tension.” Todd’s behavioral issues require his parents’ intervention, not the OP’s burden. Including Jared, who Brandon likes, shows the OP’s openness, making his stance on Todd specific, not personal.

The OP should maintain his boundary, suggesting his ex arrange bonding during her custody time. If Todd’s behavior improves, future inclusion could be reconsidered with Brandon’s consent. Co-parenting counseling could ease communication.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit’s takes are as sharp as a summer storm! Here’s what the community had to say:

These opinions surge, but do they clarify the path or just ripple the tension?

This summer trip clash leaves us pondering: was the OP wrong for excluding his ex’s stepson, or was protecting his son’s peace paramount? Co-parenting and stepfamily ties knot like tangled fishing lines. What would you do if a stepchild’s past behavior threatened your child’s happiness? Share your thoughts and experiences below!