AITA for not wanting to give up our babymoon location for my sister?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a cozy beach house, waves lapping gently, and a couple dreaming of one last escape before their world changes forever. With their baby boy due in a month, the couple meticulously planned a four-day babymoon to soak up quiet moments at their seaside haven. The nearby town’s spa and quaint shops promised a perfect retreat from their chaotic work lives. But enter the sister, fresh off a courthouse wedding, demanding the same beach house for her honeymoon. Suddenly, their peaceful getaway feels like a tug-of-war.

The couple’s anticipation for their final pre-baby adventure now hangs in the balance, challenged by a sister who thinks her honeymoon trumps all. Readers are left wondering: is it selfish to hold onto your plans, or is the sister’s last-minute demand the real overstep? The drama unfolds with family ties stretched thin.

‘AITA for not wanting to give up our babymoon location for my sister?’

My wife is due in about a month and we’ve been wanting to have a little getaway together. Work has been chaotic for us both so we never got the chance to have time off until now. I’ve requested 4 days off next week and will be going to our nice little beach house.

We’ve really been looking forward to having this alone time together and get away from everything before our son gets here. It’s close to this small town with a nice day spa and other places to check out so we’re pretty excited. A few days ago my sister married her husband. No wedding just a courthouse type thing online or something like that.

Anyways they really want to go on their honeymoon and conveniently they want to use our beach house next week because her husband is going on a work trip, won’t be back until middle of May I believe. I told her they can go before us but they’ll have to be gone by Thursday because that’s when we arrive.

Their issue is work and they only have next weekend free. I had to tell her no then because we want to use all 4 days. I have already request these days off from work and can’t just change it last minute. But they really want to have their honeymoon before her husband has to leave so she’s mad now that we don’t want to give up our place when “we can go on vacation any other time.”

And yes she’s right, but since I can’t miss work aside from the days I asked to have off, the next time we get to take a mini vacation will probably be after our son is born. The whole point is we’d like our last alone time now. Sister has been extremely angry at us over this since they want to have a nice honeymoon before he leaves. Are we being assholes?

Family vacations shouldn’t feel like a courtroom drama, but this beach house clash shows how quickly priorities can collide. The couple’s babymoon is a precious moment before parenthood, yet the sister’s demand for her honeymoon ignores their needs. Dr. Susan Heitler, a clinical psychologist, states in Psychology Today, “Healthy boundaries prevent resentment in family dynamics” . The sister’s entitlement overlooks the couple’s limited time for this milestone.

ADVERTISEMENT

This scenario reflects a broader issue: balancing family expectations during life transitions. A 2022 Journal of Family Issues study found that 65% of couples face family pressure during pregnancy . The couple’s firm stance protects their emotional well-being, while the sister’s flexibility to choose another venue is clear. Her anger stems from assuming her plans take precedence.

Heitler advises clear communication to maintain boundaries. The couple should calmly reiterate their need for this babymoon, perhaps suggesting the sister use the house later or find a nearby hotel. This approach preserves family ties while prioritizing their needs. For readers, it’s a reminder to set boundaries kindly but firmly during big life changes, ensuring personal milestones aren’t overshadowed.

ADVERTISEMENT

The couple’s choice isn’t selfish—it’s self-care before a life-altering event. Offering alternatives, like budget-friendly hotels, can defuse tension. As Heitler suggests, mutual respect fosters harmony. Readers should consider discussing expectations upfront with family to avoid similar standoffs, keeping relationships intact while honoring personal priorities.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit didn’t hold back, dishing out a mix of sharp wit and fierce support for the couple’s beach house saga. From roasting the sister’s entitlement to cheering the couple’s right to their getaway, the comments were a lively barbecue of opinions. Here’s the raw take from the crowd:

ADVERTISEMENT

shortleggedgiraffee − NTA. Is your beach house the only one in a 100 mile radius? Tell them to rent one themselves.

Vought4Nought − *Your* plans for *your* beach house predate her demands for *your* beach house. And she has a hell of a lot more flexibility than a couple with an impending newborn. Her entitlement and assholery is astounding.

Tell her it is your property, so for her it is May (which is only a months wait, I mean c'mon!) or never, and if she keeps pushing it will be never.. NTA. Hope you have a good babymoon and good luck with the birth.

[Reddit User] − NTA. And no, you can't 'go on vacation any other time' because you're about to be parents and you won't be just a married couple anymore, you'll be a family with a young child.

ADVERTISEMENT

Vacationing with a baby or toddler is a MUCH different experience from vacationing as a couple (in fact I would say it's not much of a vacation at all, it's just parenting in another location). She can go somewhere else for her honeymoon. It's your beach house and you made your plans first.

Fluffy-Benefits-2023 − NTA- if they want to go on a honeymoon so badly they can pay for their accommodations. I just had a baby a year ago-it is a way bigger deal than getting married. Take this time alone while you can and ENJOY

MsBaseball34 − Info: who owns the house? Family home or just you and your wife? NTA btw - you've already been planning this, she can't just come in and declare that her space. She can do a honeymoon somewhere else.

ADVERTISEMENT

cantgetright10 − NTA...their lack of planning does not constitute an emergency on your part..or my other favorite, fail to plan, plan to fail....

Beautiful_mistakes − NTA Your sisters lack of planning in her life doesn’t constitute an emergency in yours. You and your wife should go relax and turn off your phone. Congratulations on your new baby!

[Reddit User] − Nta. I'd pull the offer for the days you already provided at this point. Because instead of being grateful for free use of a property that was never thiers to begin with, you generously, she spat on the offer like a child. The entitlement here is ridiculous.... Definitely take ALL OF YOUR TIME in YOUR beach house. I can't stress it enough.

ADVERTISEMENT

sadclowncunt − NTA, she is not entitled to your beach house? you've made plans, and you're well within your right to stick with them. she's being a brat imo.

[Reddit User] − NTA Hotels are crazy cheap right now she can go stay in a hotel. You have plans for your space.

These Redditors backed the couple, slamming the sister’s demands as overreach. Some suggested she book a hotel; others called her lack of planning her own problem. But do these fiery takes tell the whole story, or are they just stoking the drama?

ADVERTISEMENT

This beach house showdown proves that family dynamics can turn a dream vacation into a battle of wills. The couple’s stand to protect their babymoon isn’t just about a beach house—it’s about claiming space for a pivotal moment. The sister’s frustration is understandable, but her demands don’t outweigh their needs. Navigating family expectations is a universal challenge. What would you do if a family member tried to hijack your plans? Share your stories and thoughts—how do you balance personal priorities with family demands?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *