AITA: My boyfriend made me dinner and I added toppings condiments to my dish. Is that rude?

Charlotte Morse Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a cozy dinner at home, the aroma of salmon and rice filling the air, only for a dash of chili oil to unleash a storm. A woman, savoring her boyfriend’s home-cooked meal, adds her favorite toppings—only to watch him spiral into a rage, snatching her plate and tossing it in the trash. What started as a simple act of personal taste became a battleground of control and hurt feelings.

This Reddit tale, simmering with tension, captures a relationship moment gone wildly awry. The woman’s confusion and her boyfriend’s explosive reaction raise red flags about respect and boundaries. Was her sprinkle of furikake a culinary crime, or was his outburst a sign of deeper issues? Let’s dig into this spicy drama and see where the fault lies.

‘AITA: My boyfriend made me dinner and I added toppings condiments to my dish. Is that rude?’

So basically what the title says. He made salmon, rice and veggies for dinner. When it was time to eat, I made sure to taste everything how it came out. Complimented him and then added chili oil and furikake to my rice.

It’s a habit to add toppings and I usually add these to whenever I make salmon dinner. He got upset and said it’s as if I didn’t like how it originally tasted and he was offended. I was confused and I explained it’s like adding hoisin and sriracha to pho or asking for hot sauce at a diner.

I brushed it off and that made him apparently super pissed so he picked up my plate while I was eating and demanded I stop giving off an attitude and apologize. Obviously I was shocked and pissed when he did that. At the end he threw the food in the trash and now we’re just in separate rooms fuming. AITA?

This dinner debacle is less about condiments and more about control. The woman’s choice to add chili oil and furikake—a common way to tailor a meal—triggered an outsized reaction from her boyfriend, who took it as a personal slight. His extreme response, from snatching her plate to trashing her food, crosses into controlling behavior that’s hard to ignore.

Personalizing food is a universal habit. A 2021 survey by the Food Network found that 70% of diners regularly adjust dishes with condiments to suit their tastes. The boyfriend’s reaction, however, suggests deeper issues of insecurity or need for control, especially given his demand for an apology.

Psychologist Dr. John Gottman, an expert on relationships, notes, “Controlling behaviors, like punishing a partner for small choices, can erode trust and signal deeper relational issues”. Here, the boyfriend’s actions—taking her food and escalating to silent treatment—mirror tactics that can escalate over time. The woman’s confusion reflects a healthy pushback against being manipulated.

ADVERTISEMENT

This story taps into broader issues of autonomy in relationships. Couples can navigate such conflicts by discussing preferences openly, perhaps agreeing on boundaries around shared meals. For the woman, reflecting on this red flag and seeking support from trusted friends could clarify next steps.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit’s take on this condiment catastrophe is as hot as a splash of sriracha! From calling out the boyfriend’s “red flag” behavior to urging the woman to rethink the relationship, the community’s reactions are a fiery blend of support and alarm.

ADVERTISEMENT

jackie0h_ − NTA I will never understand people who don’t let people make their food more to their taste. I’d also say he overreacted and taking your food away and throwing it away is immature if not abusive. It’s a bit troublesome to say the least.

Expat_89 − NTA. Adding things to food is normal. Your bf is reacting dramatically to a benign situation.. The extreme overreaction has some big 🚩🚩🚩. Removing your dinner, trashing it, and silent treatment screams abusive personality.

ADVERTISEMENT

I would quietly pack a bag, and spend the next couple nights with a friend or family while you figure out what to do. His anger and aggression could easily have been directed to you/your body rather than a plate of food

Forsaken-Knowledge12 − NTA. What he did was abusive and a HUGE red flag that you should not be with him.. - He was controlling in every way possible. - telling you how to eat. - gaslighting you and demand an apology. - you didn’t so he punished you by throwing away your dinner.. He needs to pack his s**t be be gone.

zepuzzler − NTA. It’s perfectly reasonable to add toppings or condiments to your rice…and to anything on the plate. It’s really inappropriate for him to try to control that, and to get so angry about it, and for him to actually take away your food and then throw it out is way over the line.

This is the kind of behavior that, if you stay with him, can lead to you being more and more submissive, backing down or preemptively not bringing things up because you know he’ll react like this. It’s a really bad sign. I bet this is not the only thing in your relationship that happens this way with him.

ADVERTISEMENT

If this is the first time anything like this is happened, keep a close eye out for anything else like this. Manipulative or controlling people will try it once and see how you react, and if they got any satisfaction out of it they’ll try it some more.

Another sign to look for is whether you have a lot of arguments that leave you just bewildered and confused, like what were we arguing about? Why was he mad at me for that? To some extent, he’s already changing how you view things, because here you are trying to explain that putting condiments on rice is OK, right?

As though you’ve already somehow agree that putting condiments on the rest of the food would’ve been inappropriate and not OK. That’s already not true, not necessary, and a sign that he is framing the discussion so that you’re on the defensive.

ADVERTISEMENT

My ex did things just like this all the time. I would find myself having these ridiculous arguments with him where I was defending myself for getting a little water on the floor and wiping it up, things that are just part of being a human.

After we broke up, it was more than a year before I stopped hearing his voice in my head criticizing me anytime I dropped something or put something away crooked or a shirt fell off a hanger onto the floor.

X_rileyfox − NTA.. Also big red flags and maturity issues.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bailey_Hollow − NTA. Run fuckiiiin run that is a big ass red flag. I know there are some weirdos that don't like you seasoning your own meal but to then get so angry about it that they take the food away is really on a whole other level of s**tty human being and not partner worthy.

Ropya − NTA.. I came here wondering if you'd done at the minimum of what I'd expect. At least taste it first.. And you did that. So, after that, do as you will with it. Everyone has their own palet.. Also, I think there's other issues going on here.

That was an extreme reaction of is. I'm not real sure how I'd react to having my dinner taken away and thrown in the trash. But it would at the least, make me think long and hard about the relationship. And if it was worth having.

ADVERTISEMENT

InterplanetaryJanet − NTA. I cook all the time for people and would never be upset if they added something to it, salt, hot sauce, whatever. People like to adjust things to their own tastes. Who cares! Controlling people, that's who. I would see this as a huge red flag.

CatteHerder − Holy screaming sirens going off amongst a sea of red flags. NTA - it's time to f**king dump him and move on. This brand of controlling will bring you nothing but harm as your relationship progresses.

Cbarnes95 − Life is too short, OP. Get a new boyfriend.

ADVERTISEMENT

These opinions highlight the line between quirky preferences and controlling actions, but do they capture the full flavor of this couple’s dynamic?

This spicy saga proves that even a sprinkle of chili oil can stir up a relationship storm. The woman’s innocent topping choice met an alarming overreaction, raising questions about respect and control. With Reddit waving red flags and her boyfriend fuming, it’s a reminder to trust your instincts. Have you ever faced a partner’s outburst over a small choice? What would you do with a plate-tossing partner? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *