AITA for ruining my sisters vacation?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The salty breeze of a dream beach vacation should’ve been soothing, but for one 22-year-old, it’s a cacophony of toddler tantrums and family tension. Picture this: a meticulously planned getaway, saved for over a year, now hijacked by an uninvited sister and her two young kids. The poster, an introvert craving quiet, finds themselves drowning in diaper duties and sibling squabbles.

What happens when your personal sanctuary becomes a family circus? The Reddit user’s plea for judgment reveals a tale of broken promises and clashing expectations, leaving readers wondering: who’s really ruining this vacation?

‘AITA for ruining my sisters vacation?’

I'm 22 years old. my sister is 26 and has 2 children a 2 month old and a 2 year old. I always thought she should not have gotten another could because she can barely take care of the other one and most of the time asks other people to take care of them because she can't do it alone.

Our mom is one of the people who goes and helps allot. Definitely now that the babys born. Now for the vacation part. I booked a vacation to the beach a year ago it was quite expensive. But this is something I really wanted so i saved up for it. I asked our mom if she wanted to go with me.

She said yes I booked and payed for 2 people. A month before we left for the vacation. My mom said my sister was also coming with us because her boyfriend was away that same week on a bike vacation. There wasn't really a question in it they just announced it.

Afterwards i went to our mom and said my concerns about how i was afraid i would have no time for myself and i would have to babysit all the time. ( Something about me I'm high sensitive and i get o**rwhelmed very quickly by constant loud noice and being an introvert being around people mentally drained me to the point i can't do anything anymore but just sleep.

They know this). Where now 4 days into the vacation. And everything i feared came true. I have to constantly keep my 2 year old busy while my mom and sister are on there phone or taking care of the baby. Even when I go somewhere else to be alone for a second like lay on my bed or something he follows and keeps asking to play.

I love him but it get to much for me. The only way they leave me alone is when Im sleeping so i have been doing that allot. With makes that i wasn't able to do anything that i wanted. My sisters told me today I'm Ruining her vacation because I make a long face all the time.

ADVERTISEMENT

I don't know if that's an English expression but in dutch it mean I'm not happy all the time. I was so annoyed i told her what do you mean ruining your vacation i paid for it. This is my vacation. She began yelling and said that just because i paid for everything doesn't mean I can sit here and ruin it for her.

I said you invited yourself i didn't ask you to be here. And said that they promised I would not have to babysit. She began yelling louder and said i haven't touched the baby while we where here (that's a lie i have given him his bottle a few times and held him while he slept and cried plenty of times.)

ADVERTISEMENT

I told her who has been keeping the 2 year old busy. She got more angry and said isn't that normal for you to want to play with the 2 year old as his aunt. Our mom was looking at me like I've kicked the children. Because how could I complain about playing with my own nephew.

They stormed out and yelled that there really something wrong with me and i should think about what i said. I've been crying non stop and have no clue what to do anymore. They don't talk to me. And I'm stuck here with them until Friday.. Am i the a**hole?

ADVERTISEMENT

This beachside blowup is a classic case of boundary violations dressed up as family bonding. The poster’s struggle highlights a common tension: balancing personal needs with family obligations. Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Healthy boundaries are the key to maintaining respect in any relationship”. Here, the sister’s assumption that the poster should naturally take on childcare duties dismisses their need for rest.

The poster, identifying as highly sensitive, faces sensory overload from the constant noise and demands. This isn’t just about babysitting; it’s about unspoken expectations. The sister and mother likely see childcare as a shared family role, while the poster views the vacation as a personal escape. This clash reflects a broader issue: family dynamics often blur individual boundaries, especially for younger siblings expected to “help out.”

Research from the American Psychological Association shows that 60% of adults report feeling overwhelmed by family responsibilities during vacations (APA, 2023). The poster’s experience mirrors this, as their sister’s self-invitation turned a retreat into a chore. Dr. Gottman’s advice—clear communication of needs—could help here. The poster tried expressing concerns, but the family’s dismissal escalated tensions.

For solutions, the poster should set firm boundaries now. Politely decline childcare duties and carve out solo time, perhaps by visiting a nearby café or beach. A calm conversation post-vacation could clarify expectations for future trips. The sister should also contribute financially, as adding three people to a pre-paid trip is no small burden.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit’s verdict? A resounding “Not the A**hole!” The community’s hot takes are as spicy as beachside tacos, with users urging the poster to reclaim their vacation.

pinkhazy − NTA Your sister sucks

Ill_Run_9956 − NTA - Your sister took advantage and your mum didn't give AF about you or your feelings. Go off on your own, enjoy the rest of your holiday! When you get back set boundaries and leave them to it! Your sisters kids are not your responsibility, next time go away on your own or go with a friend or a solo travelers group.

ADVERTISEMENT

Neither your mum or your sister have thought about you or your feelings, it's all about your sister, her needs and her kids. They'll probably call you an AH but they're so self-absorbed, your mum playing granny and reliving being a mum and your sister just being her by the sounds of it. Just keep your boundaries, they will run to you again eventually for help, so make sure you say no.

Kwen_Oellogg − Get the hell out of the room and go down to the beach. You don't have to take anyone with you.. Just go! and stop sitting in the hotel room.

Waste-Phase-2857 − NTA, your sister and mother are the ones that ruining the vacation. You made these plans with your mother and then your mother just added your sister and kids without really talking to you (and that would have been an unfair discussion because how could you say no without being looked upon as selfish?).

ADVERTISEMENT

The main thing is, you paid for this vacation and you should be able to spend it how you intented. Being the primary entertainer around the clock was not part of your plan. First of all your sister should pay half the cost for the vacation. She added three people and you should be compensated for it.

Second of all, you need to sit down with your mother and sister and talk to them, that this wasn't a part of the plans, you had things planned for this vacation and there's still time to do them. Even if you love your niblings that doesn't mean you want to spend every minute with them on your vacation.

So make a plan for the rest of the vacation, including a schedule for childcare and childfree-time. Like you said, your stuck there until friday but that also still leaves a couple of day of vacation if you plan them well. I've been both the childfree aunt that just gotten niblings pretty much dumped on me and now I have children of my own (which I DON'T just drop on someone else, they're after all MY responsible first).

ADVERTISEMENT

Also, when you come home from the vacation, have a separate conversation with your mother about how YOU need to be a priority when it's YOUR vacation. Make it clear to her that you understand that she want's to help your sister but that can't dictate every situation.. Good luck and I'll hope you can enjoy the last days of vacation.. EDIT: Added a missing word in the second to last paragraph so the sentence would make more sense.

CrunchyCookies51 − Oh my, Im a grandma to two small children who I love with all my heart. Do I want to take my daughter and children on holiday with me and look after the kids? Absolutely not! You booked your holiday for you to relax, not look after kids. Your sister is selfish AF and your mum is just as bad. Why doesnt your mum entertain the 2 year old since she was the one who invited them?

For the remainder of your holiday, get up on a morning and go somewhere for the day, a different beach, sightseeing, a museum, a water park. **Anything that you want to do!** You were initally going to go alone before asking your mum if she'd like to join you so just spend the rest of your time being on vacation and doing what you want.. NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

Mishy162 − NTA. Just get up each morning and leave them, find a nice cafe to have breakfast, go enjoy the beach or whatever other tourist activities you want. Buy a book to read relax somewhere reading it. If you don't want to be outside, go see a movie, just stay out all day. Do that each day until it's time to go home.

You do not have to entertain your nephew at all, your Mother and Sister are quite capable of doing that themselves. You are not ruining your sisters vacation, she is ruining yours. You paid for it, she invited herself along when she wasn't welcome.

GothPenguin − NTA-They’re using you to give themselves a vacation.

ADVERTISEMENT

MerlinBiggs − NTA. Your sister is a selfish one. Just go off and leave them. Do stuff on your own. Find somewhere else to stay if you can.

Schween64 − NTA, sounds like you’re being manipulated and taken advantage of in this situation. You f**ked up not standing up for yourself regarding the kids sooner tho

HoldFastO2 − NTA. There's a distinct difference between playing with your nephew and babysitting him, and it seems like they're selling you the latter as the former, which is not okay. This was supposed to be your and your mom's vacation, and your sister is the one ruining it for you.

ADVERTISEMENT

Go out. Find somewhere away from your family where you can spend a day or two alone with yourself - go to museums, or the beach, or the zoo, or just do some sightseeing. You're on vacation, and you deserve it. Pamper yourself.

There was a post on this sub a year or two ago by a woman who liked to take 'reading vacation'  she'd go to a city she'd never been to before, find a nice café, and sit there to read a good book. The very idea sounds so awesome, I'm sad I didn't have it myself. If that's something you'd like to do, why not try it? They're not talking to you, so leave them behind.

These opinions pack a punch, but do they hold up? Reddit’s all about siding with the underdog, yet real life might demand a bit more diplomacy.

ADVERTISEMENT

This vacation-turned-family-feud shows how quickly dreams of relaxation can sink under unspoken assumptions. The poster’s not wrong for wanting their hard-earned trip back, but navigating family ties is trickier than a toddler’s tantrum. What would you do if your getaway got gatecrashed? Share your thoughts—have you ever had to draw a line in the sand with family?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *