AITA for telling my wife our daughter is more important than she is?

Charlotte Morse Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a quiet suburban home, a father’s heart sank as his 18-year-old daughter, eyes brimming with tears, shared her mother’s plan to push her out after her birthday. The reason? To transform her bedroom into an art studio. This straight-A student, who’d never caused a ripple of trouble, faced the gut-wrenching prospect of leaving her beloved cats behind. Her father’s protective instincts roared to life, sparking a heated clash with his wife.

This family drama unfolds like a storm, exposing raw tensions over love, space, and priorities. Readers can feel the daughter’s dread and the father’s fury—how could a hobby outweigh a child’s security? The story invites us to question where parental duty lies when personal desires collide with family bonds.

‘AITA for telling my wife our daughter is more important than she is?’

Our daughter is turning 18 in October. She a great kid, always pulled straight A’s, never in any type of trouble and she’s very respectful. My wife recently decided to have a talk with her about adult responsibilities. I had no knowledge of this conversation until my daughter came to me crying because she was scared about living on her own.

ADVERTISEMENT

I was confused at first, then she told me her mother said she needs to start looking for a job because she’ll be expected to get her own place after her birthday. I was appalled because we never discussed throwing her out at 18. When I confronted my wife, she said our daughter wasn’t a child anymore and needed our push to become an adult.

I told her I was really baffled that she would exclude me from such a serious decision/conversation. I asked my wife how does she expect our kid to make it on minimum wage, especially considering the rent is out of control in our area. She then informs me she had planned for us to pay half her rent until she was 20.

I asked her, why she wanted our kid gone so bad. As the argument intensified, I believe she slipped by saying she needed the space (her bedroom) for her art studio. I couldn’t believe it. I told my wife if her hobby was more important than our daughter, she should be the one looking to rent.

However, she took that as me saying move out but that’s not how I meant it. I was implying for her to rent more space for her studio, and to leave our daughter alone. She didn’t believe that’s what I actually meant, she than gave me the silent treatment for 3 days. Our daughter however was still upset as she processed her mother wanting her out.

ADVERTISEMENT

She realized moving into a rental meant she had to leave her two cats behind. She’s had these cats since she was a young child, that alone devastated her. She told me, “I don’t want to turn 18, I don’t want to celebrate my birthday.” I picked the argument back up with my wife at that point.

I said, “Our daughter isn’t moving out until she decides on her own terms because she is more important than you or your hobby.” She look stunned, and maybe in the heat of the moment I didn’t choose my words wisely. I couldn’t bare to see our daughter so upset any longer.

I don’t want her struggling to make ends meet and not be able to follow her dreams. The last thing I want for her is to feel rushed. As far as my wife goes, she’s not talking to me at all and she’s been cold towards our daughter.

ADVERTISEMENT

This father’s stand for his daughter reveals a jarring disconnect in parental priorities. His wife’s push to evict their 18-year-old for an art studio, without mutual discussion, dismisses both the daughter’s emotional needs and the family’s unity. A 2023 Pew Research study shows 57% of young adults live with parents due to economic pressures, highlighting the unrealistic expectation of instant independence.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Healthy families prioritize open communication and mutual decision-making”. The wife’s solo decision and subsequent silent treatment signal a breakdown in partnership. The father’s defense of his daughter’s right to stay is a stand for her stability, not a slight against his wife. Couples therapy could help them align priorities, while the daughter might benefit from support to process her anxiety.

ADVERTISEMENT

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

Reddit dished out fiery support for this dad, with a dash of shade for the wife’s art studio dreams.

stinstin555 - NTA. Your wife is! While 18 may very well be the age you become an adult 18 is not a age where most people are prepared to live on their own. Your wife is absolutely TA because she should have had a conversation with you before arbitrarily making an absolutely asinine decision.

ADVERTISEMENT

It may be time to take a good hard look at your marriage. Putting an art studio ahead of a child’s welfare and wellbeing is ludicrous. Edit: OP if you have not thought about planning for the unexpected you should.

Please make sure you have a will in place to protect your daughter. Life happens. Additionally think about some therapy to help deal with any anxiety. Turning 18 should be a happy time for her.

ADVERTISEMENT

False-Explanation702 - NTA. This is the hill to die on. You weren't that far off when you said maybe your wife should rent instead. How unbelievably cruel she is to her own child to prioritize an art room over her daughter. I don't want to get banned so that's all I will say.

stacity - NTA. Does she even like her daughter?

ADVERTISEMENT

SugarFries - NTA This is appalling in every aspect, from her disregard are her child, to hiding the planning and discussion from you.

BonjourCheriex - NTA. your wife’s priorities are indeed skewed and I hope she recognizes how disgusting her actions are, and how she has forever harmed the trust your child ever had in her.

ADVERTISEMENT

RighteousVengeance - NTA. Even though you didn't mean it this way, I think perhaps your wife should be the one to move out.. First, she decides her daughter must be kicked out on her 18th birthday. And excludes you from the discussion.

Second, she responds with the silent treatment when she finds that your views don't coincide with hers. The silent treatment is basically a drawn out tantrum. It is the tactic of the punitive, manipulative and immature.. It also shows that her position is non-negotiable. My way or the highway.

ADVERTISEMENT

Your wife is giving me uncomfortable vibes. She feels she needs an art studio. And has decided that the best way to get herself one is to push her daughter out the door as soon as possible, regardless of what you or your daughter want. This sounds heavily narcissistic.

'My needs are paramount and I have no feeling whatsoever for anyone who feels differently or is in my way. And I will not negotiate or compromise on this.' And since she's declared war, I think it should be majority rules. You and your daughter on one side, her on the other. Therefore, she should go.

ADVERTISEMENT

I see nothing wrong with you telling your wife, without discussing it with her, that your daughter will leave on her own terms and when she's prepared to. Isn't that exactly what she did to you? Making a unilateral decision for your daughter? Moreover, you telling her that your daughter is more important than her is also appropriate.

By ordering her out in favor of an art studio, your wife basically told your daughter that she is more important than your daughter. You informed her otherwise.. And good on you for standing up for your daughter.

ETA: If you find these differences are irreconcilable and go the divorce route, I think you should do well. You'll have your daughter backing you up for your wife's callous treatment. And I wouldn't tell her beforehand. Just have the papers drawn up and have her served, without warning.

Snommies - NTA. Thank you for being a good parent to your daughter. Wife is absolutely out of line. I’m so glad that you’re aware of the struggles of young adults trying to move out. The stigma behind needing to leave the house at 18 is so outdated to todays standards and you’d both be setting your daughter up for failure & resentment.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m so glad you have your daughters best interests at heart here, unfortunately the wife doesn’t. You were absolutely not wrong for how you worded it. A child (anyone for that matter) should always be more important than a hobby. Wife can absolutely go out of her way and find her own rental room for her art room. I wish her the best in finding something affordable for her hobby.

-1scar0fac3- - parents who kick out their kids and expect them to be financially independent as soon as they’re legal are setting them up for failure. NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

heathertidwell7 - NTA. I don’t understand how your wife can say she wants your daughter to move out just so she can have her room for her art studio! If she’s acting cold towards your daughter and wants her to move out as soon as she’s 18, that’s not a motherly thing to do! If she continues to treat your daughter that way, she’ll alienate her and your daughter won’t want anything to do with her!

stannenb - INFO: You’re telling us that, in 18 years of marriage and shared parenthood, you and your wife never discussed what your daughter was going to do, not even in the context of, say, college?

ADVERTISEMENT

These bold Reddit takes pack a punch, but do they capture the full family dynamic?

This father’s fierce defense of his daughter lays bare the clash between personal ambitions and family ties. When does a parent’s dream overshadow a child’s needs? What would you do if caught between your partner’s plans and your child’s well-being? Share your thoughts—let’s unpack how to keep family first.

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *