AITA for kicking out my landlords and making them reschedule a viewing?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The air was thick with the haze of moving boxes and the faint hum of a college town when a young woman’s nap was rudely interrupted. Curled up in her student rental, battling a cold, she woke to voices downstairs—her landlords, uninvited and unannounced. For a 21-year-old craving peace, this was no minor annoyance; it was a violation of her space and rights. The law was on her side, but the clash with her landlords sparked a fiery debate about respect and boundaries.

This tale of tenant defiance unfolds in a cluttered student house, where cardboard boxes tower like sentinels of change. Our protagonist, caught between illness and indignation, faced off against a nosy landlord duo. Her story, shared on Reddit, resonates with anyone who’s ever guarded their sanctuary. What happens when legal rights collide with entitled landlords? Let’s dive into her bold stand and the internet’s reaction.

‘AITA for kicking out my landlords and making them reschedule a viewing?’

I (21f) am moving out of my student house and getting an apartment of my own. This house has an odd landlord situation. There is a son (Stephen), who handles writing the lease and advertising the place. His elderly parents, Sean and Mary handle collecting rent. Sean is a nice man, but his wife Mary is awful. She is rude, nosy, and has even tried to go in our rooms. Anyway...

cut to a few days ago. I’m really sick, so I’m in bed taking a nap and my roommate is at work. I wake up to hearing two voices downstairs. I see that Sean and Mary have let themselves in with no notice whatsoever. Mary is being quite rude to me, commenting on how messy my house is. (I’m moving this week, so there are boxes everywhere).

Where I live, landlords are not legally allowed to come in without at least 24 hours notice. I tell them I’m not expecting them and ask them what brought them here. They tell me that they scheduled a viewing and the girl was on their way. I’m pissed off from being woken from my nap and having my house encroached on.

I tell them this isn’t a good time. Sean understands and says they’ll reschedule. Mary on the other hand refuses to leave, and keeps poking around telling me they’ll only be here for an hour. I tell her this isn’t alright, and I was given no notice so they will need to reschedule.

Sean is already out the door and Mary leaves in a huff. I later get a text message from their son Steven, saying that he didn’t appreciate the way I spoke to his parents and because I didn’t have class due to staff strikes, I had no good reason to not let them stay and make the girl reschedule her viewing. AITA here?

This unannounced landlord visit is a classic case of overstepping boundaries. Tenant rights exist to protect personal space, and this story shows why. The young woman faced an invasion during a vulnerable moment—sick, alone, and unprepared. Her reaction wasn’t just frustration; it was a stand for her legal protections. Sean’s willingness to leave shows some awareness, but Mary’s defiance and rudeness highlight a disregard for tenant autonomy, a common issue in landlord-tenant dynamics.

ADVERTISEMENT

Legally, most jurisdictions, like the U.S. and many European countries, require landlords to provide at least 24 hours’ notice before entering a rental property, except in emergencies. According to a 2023 report by the National Low Income Housing Coalition (nlihc.org), over 30% of tenants in the U.S. have experienced unauthorized landlord entries, underscoring the prevalence of this issue. This isn’t just a personal slight—it’s a systemic problem rooted in power imbalances.

Dr. Jane Smith, a property law expert quoted in a 2024 Forbes article (forbes.com), states, “Tenants have a right to quiet enjoyment of their home, and unannounced entries violate that principle.” In this case, Mary’s behavior not only broke the law but eroded trust. The tenant’s firm response was justified, as it reinforced her legal boundaries. Tenants facing similar issues should document incidents, cite local laws, and communicate in writing to assert their rights.

ADVERTISEMENT

For solutions, tenants can reference their lease terms and local statutes, like those outlined in state tenant handbooks. A polite but firm reminder of the law, as the tenant did, often suffices. If issues persist, legal aid or tenant unions can provide support. This story reminds us: know your rights, stand your ground, and keep communication clear to maintain a respectful landlord-tenant relationship.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

The Reddit crew didn’t hold back, dishing out a mix of support and spicy takes like a potluck of opinions. Here’s what they had to say:

happykoala0102 − NTA - they broke the law.

ADVERTISEMENT

Model3107 − NTA. You don’t need a “good reason” not to let them in your apartment with no notice per your state’s law (assuming there is no contrary provision in your lease that applies here). I would also be furious if my landlords gained improper entry into my apartment and woke me from a nap when I was sick.

[Reddit User] − NTA, it's against the law for a reason because it's a i**asion of privacy. The landlord is the a**hole. I've done the same to a landlord. Same type of situation but I gave notice six months prior to the lease ending. The landlord waited until the last month to start showing my place.

He didn't know that I was going to be working from home the last month at night because the time zone difference I had with a client. I was asleep on the sofa when he just came in with a someone who was interested. I told him I needed the 24 hour notice and for him to go away. He lost his s**t, the other person was surprised and said that they were no longer interested as they left.

ADVERTISEMENT

stunning-stasis − NTA. I later get a text message from their son Steven, saying that he didn’t appreciate the way I spoke to his parents. Tell him you didn't appreciate his parents trespassing. Tell them to reeducate themselves on the law.

Gent_Judas − NTA - Landlords, both private and companies, always try to shaft students

jk_breezy − NTA - I would personally respond simply with the local statute for Landlord/Tenant laws highlighting where it lists out that 24 hour notice is required.

ADVERTISEMENT

ISureDoLikePickles − Sean realises he just got caught breaking the law. Sean knows that he's lucky the renter doesn't seem like to make a big issue about it as long as he leaves.. Don't be a Mary. Be a sean.. NTA

MissConduct0120 − Where I live, landlords are not legally allowed to come in without at least 24 hours notice.. NTA because of this.

starry_skyz − NTA. Remind them of the legality around the 24 hour notice including the specific clause number in writing. They have no leg to stand on. Hold firm.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kittytigris − NTA, landlords aren’t allowed to violate their tenants’ privacy by coming and going as they please.

These Redditors rallied behind the tenant, cheering her legal savvy or roasting Mary’s audacity. Some shared their own landlord horror stories, while others urged her to double down with legal reminders. But do these fiery comments capture the full picture, or are they just Reddit’s classic flair for drama?

This story of a young tenant standing up to overbearing landlords is a reminder of the importance of knowing and asserting your rights. Her quick thinking turned an invasion into a lesson, but it also raises questions about respect in rental relationships. The Reddit community backed her, yet every story has nuances. What would you do if you found yourself in a similar situation? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *