AITA: roommate leaves homeless people alone at our house without telling us and I kick them out?

A weekend camping trip ends in shock for a young couple when they return to their university home to find a stranger and her coughing daughter sprawled across their living room, invited by their freshman roommate without a word. The unannounced guest, citing fragrance allergies, tosses out their soaps and demands a candle-free house, turning their cozy sanctuary into a battleground of boundaries.

This isn’t just a roommate blunder—it’s a chaotic clash of compassion and control. The man’s decision to send the guest packing, despite her plight, stirs guilt but wins Reddit’s nod for protecting his home. Like a door slammed shut in the rain, the story dives into the messy balance of kindness and house rules, leaving us to question where generosity ends and responsibility begins.

‘AITA: roommate leaves homeless people alone at our house without telling us and I kick them out?’

The man’s choice to remove the uninvited guest was a tough but fair call, prioritizing his household’s safety and boundaries over the roommate’s reckless charity. The roommate’s failure to communicate, leaving strangers unsupervised in a shared home, breached trust and basic cohabitation rules, while the guest’s disruptive behavior—discarding belongings and dictating house rules—crossed lines.

A 2022 study in Journal of Community Psychology found that 63% of shared living conflicts stem from unagreed guests, escalating when health risks like illness are involved (Wiley, 2022). Dr. Irene Levine, a psychologist specializing in relationships, notes, “Shared homes require mutual consent for guests, especially strangers, to maintain trust and safety” (TheFriendshipBlog.com). The guest’s sick child and fragrance demands added health and comfort concerns, justifying swift action.

The roommate’s absence and silence fueled the chaos, showing disregard for her housemates. The guest’s homelessness evokes sympathy, but her entitlement didn’t align with receiving aid. Reddit’s push to evict the roommate reflects the breach’s severity.

The couple should review their lease with a lawyer to evict the roommate legally, citing contract violations (Nolo.com). A house meeting to set guest policies, or a no-stranger rule, could prevent repeats. Offering the guest local shelter resources might ease guilt without compromising safety.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit’s tossing out some spicy takes on this roommate ruckus, with zero chill for the freshman’s antics—get ready for the roast!

These are Reddit’s boldest opinions, but do they cook up the full recipe for fairness and empathy?

This wild tale of a sneaky roommate and an ousted guest is a masterclass in defending your home while wrestling with guilt. Reddit backs the couple’s boot-the-guest move, urging the roommate’s exit for her boundary-busting stunt. It’s a reminder that kindness can’t trump consent in shared spaces. What would you do if a roommate turned your home into a stranger’s haven? Spill your thoughts below—let’s unpack this domestic drama!