AITA for choosing my niece over my brother after we all learned she wasn’t his?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a quiet suburban home, a man sits torn between loyalty to his niece and the fury of his family. The air feels heavy with unspoken tension, as years of love for a little girl clash with a brother’s lingering pain. When the truth about his niece’s paternity shattered their family, one uncle refused to abandon the child he’s cherished since her first giggle. Now, with her mother’s time running short, his decision to step up as her guardian has ignited a firestorm of family drama.

This Reddit tale unravels a heart-wrenching dilemma: choosing between a beloved niece and a brother’s demand for distance. Readers can’t help but feel the weight of this choice, wondering where duty lies when love and betrayal collide. The story pulls us into a world of fractured bonds, asking how far one should go to protect an innocent child.

‘AITA for choosing my niece over my brother after we all learned she wasn’t his?’

Over a year ago my brother found out my niece -who was 6 at the time- was not his biological daughter. Something his b*tch of an ex girlfriend had lied to him about. After finding out he basically cut of all contact with his ex and my niece. Moved out of their shared apartment and refused to have anything else to do with them.

ADVERTISEMENT

I (30m) have mixed feelings about that but I wasn’t the one cheated on or lied to so I can’t say I understand his complicated emotions. The rest of my family (like my parents and other siblings) also cut off all contact. So basically the only family my niece knew her entire life were not involved anymore. It didn’t feel right for me to do that too.

I’ve loved my niece since the day she was born. I’m her godfather and everything, even if we’re not biologically related the idea of not being in her life anymore hurt. So I stuck around. My brother was always against me still being involved but in the end it became one of those things we don’t have a problem with as long as we don’t talk about it.

Even if i hated having to interact with her mom, I still got to spend time with my niece and take her out. Before all this happened, my niece’s mom has been struggling with health problems and now we’re learning that her time is limited. She herself has no other family so she’s asking if I’d take over as my niece’s legal guardian once she’s not here anymore.

We haven’t started the legal process yet but I’ve already agreed I’ll take care of her. My parents are completely against this since it means my niece will be in my life permanently and I’d be an awful person for putting my brother in that kind of position.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’d never force them to meet but it does mean from now on I’d have to keep distance from him since he still wants nothing to do with her. My brother found out about this too and he’s furious. I’ve gotten an earful from him about how I’m the worst brother ever.

And a selfish s**t for taking in the one person he wants no involvement with. Honestly I knew this would not make him happy at all, but the level of hate I’m getting from my family is not what I expected. I really can’t see myself not taking her in because it’s either me or foster care.

So when he gave me that ultimatum, him or her, I ended up going for her. Still haven’t heard the end of it from everyone else for betraying my brother again like his ex did. It’s getting harder and harder to not feel like a total a**hole for doing this and not sure anymore. AITA

ADVERTISEMENT

Edit: since I’ve seen this asked more than once. We already know who the biological father is and he’s aware too. However he is the last person that should ever have custody of a child and even if he was interested in being involved, that would not be a safe environment for my niece nor would he have any lucky getting a court to go through with that given his history.

This family’s saga is a gut-punch, highlighting the messy intersection of loyalty and loss. The uncle’s choice to prioritize his niece over his brother’s feelings stirs a classic debate: does family obligation trump personal pain? The brother’s reaction, while raw, reflects a wound that’s yet to heal, but abandoning a child he raised for six years raises eyebrows. The uncle, meanwhile, embodies a selfless love that refuses to waver, even under family pressure.

ADVERTISEMENT

This situation mirrors broader issues of non-biological parenting. According to a 2019 study by the U.S. Census Bureau, about 2.5% of U.S. children live with non-biological guardians, often facing complex family dynamics. These bonds, built on choice rather than blood, can be just as profound but often face societal skepticism.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Family is not just about biology; it’s about the commitment to show up, especially in tough times”. Applying this to the uncle’s choice, his commitment to his niece reflects a deep emotional bond, prioritizing her stability over family harmony. Gottman’s perspective underscores that love, not lineage, defines family.

ADVERTISEMENT

For the uncle, moving forward means setting boundaries with his family while ensuring his niece feels secure. Therapy could help navigate these tensions, offering a space for the brother to process his grief without punishing the child. Open communication, though tough, might bridge the gap, ensuring the niece grows up surrounded by love, not resentment.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s takes on this tale are as fiery as a summer barbecue! Here’s a glimpse into the community’s candid, often humorous, reactions to the uncle’s stand:

ADVERTISEMENT

PolyesterAtrocity − NTA. That little girl needs one adult who loves her unconditionally, and that's you. Anyone who chooses to send you hate over this loving choice can go pound salt. You made the best choice you possibly could, and you can cut anyone out of your life who doesn't support you.. Good on ya, OP. Well done you.

BackroadAdventure − NTA at all. You are putting a child's needs first. And whether related or not, you have a bond with the child. It's understandable that your brother is having a hard time with all of it, and by proxy that your family is too. But how could they all so quickly and easily turn their back on a child they had presumably treated like family for 6 years?!.

ADVERTISEMENT

Is your brother named on the birth certificate? Was a DNA test done to confirm he's not the father? Either way, if your family wants you to pick sides, it sounds like your niece is going to have an amazing guardian who doesn't have to deal with extended family anymore.

SlipperySlope80 − NTA Everyone's anger here is misplaced but yours. I understand your brother having complicated feelings about this but his daughter, this child he raised for 6 years he abandoned. Your parents abandoned their grandchild. What her mother did was inexcusable but her daughter is paying the price and that is not fair, she is literally a child.

ADVERTISEMENT

Again, I understand your families complicated feelings however they need to get over themselves. There was a time that they loved this child and this child was their family. How dare they be upset with you for not turning your back on her and for being there for her when she needs it. They'd rather she go into foster care because they are mad at her mother. They need to grow up. Family isn't just blood.

ChickenNApathy − NAH. You are doing a good thing, but that doesn't negate the fact that this is probably the most painful thing that has ever happened to your brother in his life, probably fucked him up long term, and he can't be completely free of this in order to move on because of you.

ADVERTISEMENT

l3rambi − NTA. Blood or not, your brother abandoned this girl. He's the father she knew and I guarantee he hurt her more than his ex hurt him. And I don't get how he could just 'turn off' his love for her, anyway. Honestly, that's alarming. I'm so grateful to hear she'll have you.

Thank you for being the parent she does deserve, but I'm sorry you're getting such heat for it. So grateful to know you're gonna do right by her anyway. God, if you listened to your brother, he'd have her abandoned twice. First by him, then given to foster care. That's just so heartless.

ADVERTISEMENT

MeanSeaworthiness995 − NTA. And I’m going to be honest here, the fact that your brother raised this child for six years as his own daughter and now wants her to go into the foster care system just to preserve his own feelings and pride makes me think that he’s not a great person TBQH.

Terrible things happen to children in foster care. Terrible. I know this firsthand. I would not wish that on ANYONE for any reason. I certainly wouldn’t inflict it on a child I’d known since she was born just because her parent had cheated on me. How selfish is he?

[Reddit User] − NAH Obviously the little girl is innocent but that doesn’t mean your brother can ever feel the same about her again. Every time he looks at her he will see the biggest betrayal of his life. She’s not his daughter. But at the same time he shouldn’t be mad at you for stepping up. Although I understand why he wishes he could just pretend like this never happened and not have to see her ever again.

Lastaction_Zero − Info: so where is the bio dad? Wouldn’t he be next of kin?

ADVERTISEMENT

nim08 − I would go with the unpopular NAH... What you are trying to do by giving your niece a home is absolutely wonderful but.. I do get where your brother is coming from because depending on how he expresses his grief over this situation he is some what pinning that on the child. Is it right? No. But are his feelings of hurt and betrayal valid?

Yes. I would suggest having a very open conversation with your brother and family but separately.. see if there is any middle ground/therapy and also if it has been a few years why is this still bothering him or is he past the cheating. It's very easy to cut off people but takes a lot to maintain relationships. See if there's anything left to save before going NC.

ADVERTISEMENT

HowardProject − NTA - he was the only father this child had ever known and while I can't fault him for being angry over having been deceived, he's a grown man and shouldn't be taking his anger out on the CHILD. No one's even asking him to step up and be her father again - but he's trying to make sure she's left alone in the world and put in foster care?!?. That's evil.

These Reddit hot takes range from heartfelt support to nuanced empathy for the brother’s pain. But do they capture the full complexity of choosing a child over family ties?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story leaves us pondering the true meaning of family. The uncle’s choice to stand by his niece, despite the cost, sparks admiration but also debate. Should he have prioritized his brother’s healing, or is protecting an innocent child the ultimate duty? Readers, what would you do if faced with this heart-wrenching choice? Share your thoughts and experiences—let’s keep this conversation going!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *