WIBTA If I don’t share my rather large (to me at least) inheritance with my aunt and 3 cousins?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a quaint tract house, its garden blooming with care, where an unassuming 90-year-old man quietly amassed a fortune. When he passed, his grandson, the sole heir, discovered a life-changing $1 million estate. But the joy of this windfall was quickly overshadowed. An estranged aunt and cousins, absent from the grandfather’s life and funeral, emerged with outstretched hands, demanding a share. Caught between loyalty to his grandfather’s wishes and family pressure, the heir faces a moral tug-of-war.

This isn’t just about money—it’s about bonds, choices, and what’s fair. The grandson, who cherished his grandfather’s woodworking tales, now wrestles with guilt and resolve. Should he honor the will or cave to demands from relatives who barely knew the man? Reddit’s AITA community dives into this sticky saga, and we’re unpacking it with a twist of humor and heart.

‘WIBTA If I don’t share my rather large (to me at least) inheritance with my aunt and 3 cousins?’

Some background: My grandfather just passed away at the end of January. He was closing in on 90 and lived a very full life and died very peacefully in his home which is exactly where he wanted to be. This is where the story gets very sticky, my grandfather lived in a cheap tract house and was very frugal.

ADVERTISEMENT

His only passions in life were woodworking and his garden. But to my huge surprised I was named as his sole heir with life changing money. With the house, everything in it and cash his estate was valued at a little over a million dollars. Here's where it gets even stickier. My mom passed away 6 years ago.

She had one sister who I was fairly close to and from her I have 3 cousins. I don't know the full details of why my aunt was estranged from my grandpa, in fact all my mom ever told me was 'it's between the two of them.' I have mixed relationship with my cousins and because their mom was estranged from my grandpa, they never had a nice word to say about him and I don't know if they ever met him.

To be fair, they probably never had the chance to get to know him like I did. Cousins and aunt did not attend the very small funeral I set up for my grandpa either. Now she and my cousins have been basically calling me nonstop somewhere between begging me and demanding of me that I split the estate 5 ways..

This is what both of my attorneys have essentially advised: No matter what I shouldn't split the estate 5 ways. If I do decide to be incredibly generous, it should be split 50/50 and my aunt and cousins can divide their half however they like. Both attorneys have advised against this period, as it's not in my best interest.

ADVERTISEMENT

I can write 4 $5000 checks out of the estate to get them to go away. $5000 in our state's probate system is generally seen as 'enough' of an inheritance to be essentially be uncontestable and my aunt and cousins will have no further claim on my grandpas estate, or none that a judge would be willing to hear.

The first attorney strongly advised I do this. I do nothing. I am carrying out my grandpa's wishes to the letter and that is my responsibility and also my benefit for staying close to him in his lifetime. This is my second attorney's preferred course of action.

But this is not about the legality of the situation. This is about what SHOULD I do and would I be the a**hole if I keep the entire estate for myself. Just over a million dollars is enough money for me to finally fund a retirement account, have a down payment on a decent house and actually save some money.

ADVERTISEMENT

I have no designs on a big blow out but maybe updating my car would be nice. I could do all of that with $500k, but that number sure looks different that $1 million.. Basically, WIBTA if I don't share this inheritance like my aunt and cousins are asking of me?

Inheritance disputes can turn family ties into a tangled mess. Here, the heir’s grandfather chose them alone, likely reflecting their close bond. Yet, the aunt and cousins, distant from the grandfather, demand a cut, creating tension. The heir’s hesitation is understandable—why share with those who showed no connection?

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Pauline Boss, an expert on family dynamics, says, “Family estrangement often stems from unresolved conflicts” (Family Therapy). The aunt’s rift with the grandfather, though unclear, likely shaped her children’s distance. The cousins’ demands may reflect entitlement or regret, but their absence at the funeral suggests little emotional stake.

Inheritance disputes are common; a 2021 survey by Ameriprise Financial found 34% of families face conflicts over estates (Ameriprise Financial). Legally, the heir owes nothing, but morally, it’s trickier. A $5,000 payment per relative, as one attorney suggested, could deter lawsuits while honoring the grandfather’s intent.

ADVERTISEMENT

The heir might consider small gestures, like sharing sentimental items, to ease tensions without compromising the estate. Consulting a financial advisor for long-term planning can secure their future, as advised by estate planning resources (Forbes). Reflect on what feels right—balancing respect for the grandfather’s wishes with family harmony.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit rolled in like a family reunion with extra spice, dishing out support and snark for the heir’s plight. It’s a lively mix of cheers and jeers, served raw.

ADVERTISEMENT

Feroc − NTA. It was the last will of your grandpa, he decided that you should get everything and I don't think you have any moral obligation to share against his will. So I'd either go with the $5000 checks (to avoid legal troubles) or just give them nothing. That's something your attorneys should figure out.

xgingersouls − NTA. Why should they benefit from the inheritance when they seem to have made no effort with him whilst he was alive?? Really winds me up when people think they’re entitled like this, they couldn’t even attend his funeral so why should you give them anything?!. Sorry to hear about your grandfather.

ADVERTISEMENT

milee30 − NTA. Your grandfather's wishes were for you to have the money; you're following his wishes. But I would strongly recommend you follow the attorney's advice and write the four $5000 checks. $20k is a small price to pay to avoid the inevitable litigation you'll face when the aunt and cousins sue. Just defending their suit will cost you that.

MfknHoHo − NTA. I’m an estates and trust attorney, but I’ll try to keep that out of it, since you already have legal advice. You should do whatever allows you to sleep well at night. If that’s giving them 50%, fine. If it’s giving them $5000 each, fine. If it’s not giving them a nickel, fine. You are not an a**hole no matter what you do here. Good luck, OP!

ADVERTISEMENT

slightlyabrasive − NTA. Your Grandfather wrote his will for a reason even if it is unbeknownst to you. Your Aunt on the other hand ITA if she wouldn’t even come to the funeral but still expects money from his passing.

Allesmoeglichee − If your grandfather wanted other arrangements, he would have written a will. NTA for following through what he wanted.

ADVERTISEMENT

Virulencer − NTA. I cannot comment on the legal side but your grandfather wanted you to have everything. Your aunt and cousins will try to paint you like an a**hole but you shouldn't let them. They can't claim an inheritance that isn't theirs.

Kylar420 − NTA. They should have taken the time to see him.

ADVERTISEMENT

Thegreatsnook − NTA- However, Grandpa would not be upset if you spent 20K to quiet them. He wouldn't want you to suffer this way.

Allthethrowingknives − if they have the audacity not to attend the funeral, they shouldn't inherit anything. NTA.

These Redditors mostly back the heir, slamming the relatives’ audacity. But do their fiery takes miss the nuances of family loyalty?

This tale shows money can’t buy family peace. The heir’s loyalty to their grandfather’s wishes clashes with relatives’ bold demands, leaving a bittersweet choice. Keeping the estate respects a bond built over years, but a small gesture might quiet the storm. What would you do with a surprise fortune and a family feud? Share your thoughts—let’s stir the pot!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *