AITA – My Kid Approached a strangers dog in our front yard?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A toddler’s chase for a tennis ball turned chaotic when a German Shepherd’s barks pierced the air. In a flash, a dad faced a stranger’s accusations of reckless parenting, his heart racing as he scooped up his 20-month-old son.

This Reddit drama unfolds on a suburban lawn, where parental instincts collide with pet ownership. With tensions flaring and no one backing down, the story stirs debate: who’s to blame when a child’s curiosity meets an unleashed dog?

‘AITA – My Kid Approached a strangers dog in our front yard?’

I've (35M) owned my house for 10 years and I've got a grass yard in my front yard. My 20 month old son loves to play outside.  We have a patio with a brick fence that leads to our yard.  I opened the door and and he bolts, like he does everyday, he looks for his tennis and golf balls in the grass.

I'm a few yards behind him and he turns the corner and briefly disappears behind the fence. As I get to the fence line, next thing I hear is barking and a lady is yelling at me to keep my son away from her what looked like a German Shepard to me. I chase down my son immediately as her dog is in my yard.

I tell her that this is my house and my yard, get your dog out of here. She starts telling me that I shouldn't let my son come toward her dog.  I tell this lady to get out of here. I tell her to never let her dog step foot on my property again.  She says I was an irresponsible parent.  AITA?

A toddler’s sprint toward a dog can turn a peaceful yard into a battleground. This Reddit saga highlights a classic standoff: a parent’s duty to supervise versus a pet owner’s responsibility to control their animal. Both sides have valid gripes, but the stakes—child safety and pet behavior—are sky-high.

The dad’s frustration is understandable; his son was on his own property. Yet, letting a 20-month-old “bolt” out of sight, even briefly, courts danger. The dog owner’s reaction, while heated, likely stemmed from fear of her pet’s instincts kicking in. As Dr. Stanley Coren, a renowned canine behavior expert, notes, “Dogs can perceive sudden movements from children as threats, triggering defensive reactions” (Psychology Today). This explains the German Shepherd’s barking and the owner’s panic.

This incident reflects a broader issue: the need for better pet and child safety awareness. According to the CDC, about 4.5 million dog bites occur annually in the U.S., with children being frequent victims (CDC Dog Bite Statistics). Both parties could benefit from proactive steps—leashing dogs and securing yards.

ADVERTISEMENT

For the dad, a gate or closer supervision could prevent future scares. For the owner, keeping the dog leashed avoids trespassing and liability. Open communication, not yelling, might turn neighbors into allies.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s verdict? A hearty “ESH” (Everyone Sucks Here), served with a side of tough love. Here’s a peek at the community’s candid, occasionally snarky takes:

ADVERTISEMENT

GuyFromLI747 − ESH .. yea I get it her dog was in your yard , but Your sons safety comes first.. hypothetical here , say one day you open the door and your son darts out in front of a car , or there’s a wild animal in your yard.. cuz these things happen all the time.. a fence isn’t keeping nature out .. it takes a second a blink of an eye.. she’s an irresponsible pet owner and you’re an irresponsible parent

fernswordgirl432 − ESH. Dude, you have a runner. You know this, yet you let him 'bolt' out of your eyesight on a daily basis. You are fortunate that this was the first incident and that it didn't turn out badly. I'd strongly suggest creating some sort of barrier to keep your son safe until you catch up with him, or you hold him while unlocking the gate and then go ahead of him to the front yard.

ADVERTISEMENT

She likely doesn't want her dog to be put down because it bit a child that ran forward and scared it. She's trying to protect your kid, too. If you don't want dogs in your yard, get a fence. Honestly, with littles, if you know that you aren't going to be 100% attentive, it's on you to create safety.

If you just yell at people, it doesn't really do anything to make the yard safer-- there will be other dogs, and sometimes, they won't be on a leash. (yes, they should be, but often people don't) Your kid- your responsibility to keep them safe. (edited for grammar)

LegitimatePoetry534 − INFO: was the dog on a leash and just walking on the edge of your grass? If this was the case and your son came unexpectedly running over and startled the dog but the lady kept the dog under control, YTA for letting a toddler go charging around out of your sight.

Small children can make animals nervous because of their sudden jerky movements, high pitched voices, and general lack of common sense. If your kid had ran out of your sight and then ran on the sidewalk in front of a cyclist and got hit, would you be blaming the cyclist?

ADVERTISEMENT

Ok-CANACHK − ESH.

Zestyclose_Gur_8889 − ESH. Your son did get away from you. What if he'd run in the street with a car coming? The dog shouldn't have been in your yard.

WitchBalls − Even if the dog were on the sidewalk, your child could reach out and get his hand bitten off. You need a fence, or to hold your child until you are fully off the porch and watching him 100%. Really, both, because there will be moments when you have to pull your eyes off him, even if just to blink.

ADVERTISEMENT

And if you think that there are no dangerous wild creatures where you are, every suburb has them. Some are very small but still hazardous. Check your local maps or neighborhood groups. There are dogs that get away from their owners, and irresponsible owners who don't tether their dogs.

Kids really do run into the street, and just because yours hasn't yet, doesn't mean he won't. Plus there are human predators, too.. Get a fence. It's a lot cheaper and easier than the aftermath of what could happen otherwise.. ESH, and if anything like this happens again, YTA.

TheFightingQuaker − YTA unless she was actually in your yard and not standing on the sidewalk with a dog on a 4 ft leash. You're being a little evasive about the details on that.

ADVERTISEMENT

radarsteddybear4077 − INFO was the dog on a leash? You cannot let your kid “bolt like he does every day.” There are so many reasons why. Your kid should also be taught not to run towards a dog. That’s on you. The person with the dog may have been startled to see a kid rushing towards their dog I would be.

My dog is always leashed, but a kid bolting at us would be worrying for all involved. I’m unsure if the dog was leashed if it was, this person didn’t do anything wrong but just exist while you let your kid bolt out the door towards danger.

CrimsonKnight_004 − INFO: Are you sure the dog was on your property to begin with? Your son rounded a corner out of your sight, is it possible he first approached the dog who was on the sidewalk, which then lured the dog into stepping foot into your yard?

ADVERTISEMENT

Ogolble − Esh. My kid was a runner, only recently stopped bolting from me,so I do get it. But animals don't have brains like humans and toddlers also don't have adult thoughts. Even though the dog was on your property, if the dog attacked, you could sue the dog owner, but that's not going to fix any medical/trauma/death that may occur.

These Reddit hot takes are spicy, but do they cut through the chaos or just fan the flames? One thing’s clear: the internet’s got opinions, and they’re not holding back.

This front-yard fiasco leaves us pondering where the line lies between freedom and responsibility. The dad’s protective roar and the dog owner’s sharp retort show how fast instincts can escalate. Both could’ve dialed down the heat, but hindsight’s always 20/20. What would you do if your kid—or your dog—sparked a neighborly showdown? Share your thoughts, stories, or tips below—let’s keep the conversation rolling!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *