AITA for telling my mom she doesn’t get to decide where I’ll be buried and ending all chances of her overruling my wishes?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In the quiet shadow of a terminal diagnosis, a 19-year-old young man faces his mortality with fierce clarity, choosing to rest eternally beside his father, who died when he was four. His mother, remarried and adamant that her current husband is his true father, demands he be buried in their family plot, sparking a bitter feud. With legal papers in hand and his sister as his ally, he locks in his wishes, leaving his mother heartbroken but his identity intact.

This Reddit story is a gut-wrenching clash of love, loss, and legacy, where a young man’s final stand stirs family tensions. Readers might feel his resolve, a beacon of autonomy amid grief. It’s a poignant tale of claiming one’s story, even when it fractures familial bonds, raising the question: who gets to decide where we rest?

‘AITA for telling my mom she doesn’t get to decide where I’ll be buried and ending all chances of her overruling my wishes?’

I (19m) have terminal cancer and I have been faced with death since I was 16 when my cancer was first diagnosed. My wishes on where to be buried have been figured out and my sister (26) helped me get a lawyer to make my wishes legal. The thing is my mom doesn't like them and it's become a fight.

My dad died when I was 4 and mom remarried when I was 6. My mom sees her husband as her one true love and she considers him mine and my sister's dad even though we have never called him dad and my sister was way old enough to not consider him a dad. I know I was young enough to consider him a dad.

But to me he was never my real dad and I only had one. My mom wants me to be buried in the plot she and her husband bought together. I want to be buried with my dad. Mom's upset about it because it means she won't be buried with me when the time comes. My sister and I told her she could choose to be.

Dad was her husband. Mom said she moved on from him and her husband is her actual husband now and has been her husband longer than dad he's been our dad longer than dad was. I told her it didn't matter because he wasn't my real dad. Mom told me the people who raise you are your real parents not the people who make you.

My aunt suggested I get cremated and split the remains but I don't want that. I don't want to go into mom and her husband's grave. So I made the will and I even got paperwork so my sister has the decisions when I'm gone and can stop mom from going against my wishes.

Mom got so mad when she learned about it. I feel like I had to. I know this is really hard for mom. My aunt keeps giving me a hard time. She said I don't even believe in heaven or hell so why would I care. But if I'm going to be forever in stone I want to die as my dad's son and not be claimed as my stepdad's son. Even if that breaks mom's heart.. AITA?

This young man’s battle is as much about identity as it is about mortality. His choice to be buried with his father honors a bond unbroken by time, while his mother’s insistence reflects her own narrative of family. Her push to erase his father’s role dismisses his truth, fueling conflict. Dr. Kenneth Doka, a grief expert, notes, “Grieving individuals need their choices validated, especially in terminal illness” (source). His legal steps ensure his voice endures, a powerful act of agency.

Family disputes over burial are common—30% of end-of-life plans face objections (source). The mother’s focus on her husband’s role and the aunt’s dismissive stance ignore his emotional reality, risking further alienation. His rejection of cremation underscores his need for a singular legacy.

Doka emphasizes respecting patient autonomy. The young man could gently explain his choice to his mother, focusing on his love for his father, not rejection of her. Readers, how do you navigate family clashes over final wishes?

Therapy might help the family process this rift, but his legal safeguards are wise. He should confirm cemetery permissions and prepay funeral costs to cement his plans, ensuring peace for himself and his sister.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit’s crew jumped into this heart-wrenching saga like it’s a family council, offering a mix of fierce support and sharp rebukes. Picture a virtual fireside where everyone’s dissecting the mother’s demands, from cheering the young man’s resolve to slamming her control. Here’s the candid scoop, pulsing with empathy and a touch of fire.

Ill-Investment-1856 − Your aunt is an i**ot. And your mom needs to respect your wishes. Make sure you have legal authority to open your dad’s tomb and be buried in it. Talk to the cemetery and make sure that everything is clear for you.

TSOTL1991 − Simple rule: Anyone who doesn’t honor the wishes of a dying person is an a**hole unless it’s something impossible to do. Story: I had a cousin who died in his 40’s. I was at his house while his brother and his daughter were discussing the funeral arrangements..

The daughter told his brother that her father had always said he wanted to be cremated.. The brother said “Oh no. I don’t want to do that.”. Then the daughter piped up with “Me neither.”. So, they had him embalmed and buried.. I was appalled.

VegetableBusiness897 − I went through this too, altho I get along with and actually like my step. But my mom is going to be buried with him, his first wife, parents and sister, abs there's room for his bio kids.

But my bio dad is all alone in the plot he bought for 'our' family (he died before 30 of leukemia)I'm not much for big burials, more just a cremate and chuck my ashes somewhere. But dad's plot is a garden cemetery, and a state historic site, and he's all alone. So I'm getting a beech planted for me and my dad, along with my ashes. It's already all set up.. Peace to you and your sister, sorry the rest of your family sucks

SoundCor3 − Your mom is treating this like a game of Monopoly she's just trying to buy up all the properties! But guess what? You’re the one holding the deed here.

I_wanna_be_anemone − NTA Your body, your decision. You’re a legal adult and your choices should be respected. You chose the person you trust to honour your wishes, the fact your mom is wasting precious time making this situation about her feelings is telling in itself. I’m sorry you’re going through this.

Tell your aunt to back off and shut up if she can’t be supportive of you during this time, that it’s disgusting she’s harassing someone dying instead of learning how to actually support people. Your mom has a limited time to show you she cares enough to put things aside and enjoy what time she has left with you.

She’s allowed to be hurt, she’s allowed to be upset. But even if you were a perfectly healthy 19 year old, she doesn’t have the right to disrespect boundaries you’ve set about stepdads place in your life. As long as you’re aware of the consequences of your boundaries, you have every right to enforce them. (Aka every AITAH post about ‘I told X they had to do Y or never speak to me again, now they’re not speaking to me!’) 

ContemplatingFolly − I suspect this is partially just about her knowing she will lose you, and burial elsewhere is symbolic of that.. I hope you can help her bring the focus back to creating good memories now.. NTA of course.

DixieDragon777 − One way to help secure your wishes is to prepay your funeral at the funeral home you want. Put it in your contract with them that you will be buried with your dad. In the state where I live, the legal next of kin has final say on final arrangements.

That person can ignore the wishes of the deceased, even if it's in the will, and use a different funeral home, crematorium, or bury them wherever, even in the backyard of the NOK's home, as long as the burial takes place within 24 hours of death.

But if you prepay, your mom would have to pay again to have your funeral the way she wants it. That's $10-15K. Getting a refund of your money would take time, if it's even possible, and she probably won't have the cash to pay herself. But it all depends on where you are. Laws vary a lot. Your attorney will help you more than Reddit, I'm sure.

TuttiFru1ty − I mean, if I were in your shoes, I’d want to be buried next to my favorite person too! Plus, who wouldn’t want their own VIP section in the afterlife? Reserved for Dad’s Son Only!

OodlesofCanoodles − Sit your mom down in a public place. Make a list of things you want to tell her. Remind her that your time is short. . Remind her this is making your life worse. . Remind her that this is making your sister's life worse. Remind her that your sister has a chance of having children and this shifty behavior is souring her relationship with her sister.

Put it in words that her behavior is hurting everyone else, that you aren't changing your mind, and remind her that her behavior is hurting her future relationship with grandchildren.  Your mom sounds like an i**ot so sorry for having to deal with this but if you remind the goldfish about how it really is, sometimes they hear correctly if you break it down enough 

Jack-off1 − You’re absolutely NOT the a-hole!

These Redditors are all heart, rallying behind his autonomy or calling out the family’s overreach. But do their takes fully grasp the weight of terminal illness and family grief, or are they just rooting for justice? One thing’s clear—this story of legacy and loss has everyone stirred.

This soul-stirring tale leaves us asking: how do you claim your story when family fights your truth? The young man’s choice to rest with his father is a brave stand for identity, even if it wounds his mother. Ever faced a clash over legacy or final wishes? Share your thoughts below—let’s dive into this emotional storm and unpack what matters most!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *