AITA for feeding my daughters soft ball team “junk” at our sleepover?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy small-town home, a lively gaggle of 13-year-old softball players gathered for a sleepover, their laughter echoing over plates piled high with pizza and brownies. The host, a 35-year-old mom, thought she was nailing the fun vibe with classic slumber party grub—until a group chat exploded with complaints from newer team moms. Suddenly, her “treat” menu was labeled “junk,” sparking a parenting feud that’s got the whole team buzzing.

This Reddit AITA post dives into the messy clash of sleepover expectations, where one mom’s attempt to keep things fun collided with others’ strict food rules. Readers might feel the sting of her surprise, caught between wanting to host a blast and facing unexpected judgment. It’s a relatable tale of small-town drama, parenting styles, and the unspoken rules of team bonding.

‘AITA for feeding my daughters soft ball team “junk” at our sleepover?’

I35f have 3 children all enrolled in extra curricular’s. My oldest daughter who’s 13, plays in softball and has for years. I live in a smaller town, so I know the other girls parents and we are well aquatinted I even consider a few of them friends.

We take turns having big huge sleepovers for the girls at our homes and this weekend it was my daughters weekend. We had never discussed what we should and should not feed the girls, just allergies and such so I didn’t think there were “rules.”

My other child is also in sports and I have never had complains about this either and I’ve hosted these sleepovers before, just not this season yet and there are a few mothers newer parents to the team. Anyways, I had bought the girls pizza and breadsticks, and had pink or regular lemonade offered for dinner.

I also had a lot of snacks, mostly chips, but I did bake some brownies as well. The next morning I had just got a lot of Dunkin’ Donuts. It’s 15 girls I’m feeding so I figured it was easiest because these type of things feed alot of children. My children don’t normally eat like this either, I just was excited for the first sleepover at our house this season.

Anyways, I’ve gotten some complains from the newer moms to have joined the group in our groupchat, and have said that I shouldn’t be loading their children up on sugar and junk food and how their kids don’t eat like that at home. I replied back that it was a sleepover it was suppose to be a fun event for the girls so what was the big deal?

That offended them; they accused me of undermining their parenting and said there daughters wouldn’t be coming to my daughters sleepovers anymore unless I decided to feed them better food. This caused an argument because like I said no one has ever mentioned what they feed the children at these sleepovers, and there was never any “rules.” I thought it was fair game.

I then again said it was just fun food, it was a slumber party, and a few of the other parents agreed with me. A few hours later that mother replied in the gc that her daughter would no longer be coming to any events at my home since I couldn’t see that fun food was just a different word for junk. Then called me a lousy mother for feeding children up with that s**t, then left the groupchat.. Aita?

Sleepovers are a rite of passage, but this mom’s menu sparked a parenting showdown. Her choice of pizza, chips, and donuts—classic slumber party fare—drew fire from moms enforcing stricter diets. Dr. Natalie Muth, a pediatrician and nutrition expert, notes, “Occasional treats at social events rarely harm kids, but parents’ food philosophies can clash” (source). The host’s assumption of “no rules” met resistance from newcomers with rigid expectations.

The conflict reveals a divide: the host saw the sleepover as a special treat, while critics prioritized consistent nutrition. Surveys show 45% of parents disagree on food at kids’ events (source), reflecting broader tensions in group dynamics. The harsh “lousy mother” jab escalated things, turning a menu spat into a personal attack.

Dr. Muth suggests, “Clear communication prevents misunderstandings.” The host could propose a pre-event chat to align on food preferences, offering a mix of treats and healthier options like fruit trays. This balances fun with inclusivity, cooling tensions while keeping the sleepover spirit alive.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit’s squad crashed this sleepover saga like kids diving for the last slice of pizza, dishing out a vibrant mix of cheers and sly digs. Imagine a team huddle where everyone’s got an opinion, from backing the mom’s fun menu to shading the critics’ overreach. Here’s the unfiltered scoop from the crowd, packed with support and a sprinkle of sass.

Bella_de_chaos − Has she hosted yet? What do the other Mom's that have been around the block serve when it's their turn?

odyssea88 − I’m gonna go with NTA here. These moms never communicated any dietary restrictions to you and as a parent that’s their responsibility if they’re letting someone else look after their child for a night. And honestly you’re correct, sleepovers ARE supposed to be fun.

These are supposed to be bonding activities for the team and stuff like this is supposed to be a treat. Also you’re feeding fifteen children, I don’t blame you for taking the easy option of pizza and chips. Maybe you shouldn’t have argued with them and simply said you’d provide different options in the future for the girls but what’s done is done now.

89MustangSally89 − NTA. This seems like typical food for a softball party, especially when it’s one household feeding the entire team. If I sent my kid to a sleepover like this, this is exactly how I’d expect them to eat. It’s one night, it’s not going to do harm.

Take this from a parent who obsesses over my kids getting enough fruit and veggies! Sometimes, eating “healthy” just isn’t realistic given the situation. Kuddos to you for being a nice mom by letting all these teenagers into your home and getting them all food.

Majestic_Shoe5175 − NTA. Sleepovers are meant for junk food. It’s a treat and not something that happens every night. I do think that after a night of junk food a good balanced breakfast is needed. Scrambled eggs are super easy to whip up for a crowd, a pre cut fruit tray, yogurt along with the donuts. But that’s just me and what I would serve. I wouldn’t care if my daughter went to a sleepover and only ate junk once in a while.

jasmxne__mxchelle − NTA. If the parents who are complaining about it actually cared as much as they are portraying, they would’ve said before the sleepover what their kid should/shouldn’t have. If it really did bother her and she genuinely wanted to get across to you to stop feeding their child that stuff she could have had a private conversation requesting politely to stop.

Then if you disagreed or there was no compromise she could decide to let her child stay or go. The way about this especially the ending of her calling you a lousy mother shows her immaturity and her inability’s to have a civil conversation. However the entire conversation that took place could have definitely been handled better from both sides.

PhysicalGift6442 − NTA. These dumb parents are complaining because you fed their kids (with YOUR money) sugary foods for a single sleepover? They clearly lack a good understanding of how nutrition works because two meals of pizza and donuts isn’t going to kill anyone who doesn’t have severe medical issues.

ChanceLengthiness2 − NTA. Choosing healthier snacks is more or less a thing when kids are toddlers and yes, we all would offer fruit and water at playdates so as to not rock the boat. But once they hit teens, the girls know what they should or should not eat.

I hosted 10 twelve year old girls at my house Friday and a few other moms actually sent their girls WITH junk food as a “thank you” to me for being the host. My daughter doesn’t drink Sprite during the week, but for sleepover I bought a case.

The moms who didn’t send snacks had nothing to say to me except “thanks for hosting, you’re a saint.” Our girls are also all athletes and healthy eaters all week long. In your case, I’d consider it a blessing these moms wont let their girls come to your house anymore.

I wouldn’t want anyone coming over whose parents criticize food choices. It shows they can’t trust their girls to make decisions for themselves or they want to control everything about them and IMO this leads to unnecessary power struggles (not to mention possible eating disorders down the road).

One time I offered to get my son’s 14yo friend a milkshake and his response was “oh my parents wouldn’t approve of that.” So I respected his choice and their rules. It’s not that hard. These moms are being petty and only hurting their daughters.

WatchingTellyNow − INFO: What has the food been at other sleepovers? I'm sure your daughter could tell you.. And have those girls attended any previous sleepovers?. I ask because there may be an implicit agreement that the longer standing parents didn't leg you know about.

12th_MaMa − I don't think you're an a**hole for feeding girls junk food at a sleepover. Who doesn't expect pizza ??. A fruit or veggie tray is fun for sleepovers too.. If they want to feed the girls kale salads they can. On their turn.. We'll see who's going to be the favorite.

kayjax7 − NTA - Yes, it is a lot of junk food, but it's a sleepover. Could you have offered some healthy snacks like a veggie tray? Sure. Would I expect it if i sent my kid? No. Feeding 15 kids each a portion of baked chicken with veggies is a lot of work when you can simply order a pizza with your phone.

These Redditors are all in, applauding the mom’s slumber party classics or roasting the complainers’ drama. Some see pizza as sleepover gospel; others suggest a veggie tray for peace. Their takes are lively, but do they catch the full flavor of this parenting clash, or are they just stirring the group chat pot? One thing’s clear—this snack spat has everyone talking.

This small-town drama leaves us wondering: where’s the line between fun treats and parenting rules? The mom’s sleepover menu shows how quickly good intentions can spark a feud when expectations collide. Ever faced a parenting clash over party plans? Share your thoughts below—let’s dig into this slumber party showdown!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *