AITAH for not rescheduling my wedding after my sister was widowed?

In a whirlwind of love and meticulous planning, a couple’s dream wedding—set to mark their 10-year anniversary—hangs in the balance. Just weeks before the big day, tragedy struck: the groom’s partner’s sister lost her husband, plunging the family into grief. When the partner’s mother gently suggested postponing to ease the sister’s pain, the groom’s heart sank, torn between empathy and the sting of altering a deeply sentimental moment.

This Reddit AITA post captures the raw tension of balancing personal joy with family sorrow. Readers might feel the groom’s simmering frustration, caught between honoring his partner’s dream and navigating a grieving family’s plea. It’s a poignant tale of love, loss, and the tough choices that test even the strongest bonds, set against the backdrop of a wedding on the brink.

‘AITAH for not rescheduling my wedding after my sister was widowed?’

I (34M) am supposed to get married next month. Now I'm not sure it's going to happen. My partner's sister (35F) was widowed last month. I've gotten a front row seat of how it has rocked my soon to be in-laws. Everyone has really tried going above and beyond for his sister, making sure she's as comfortable as possible.

And I truly can't imagine, you know? You'd probably have to institutionalize me if something happened to my boy. My partner's mom came to him a few days ago and asked if he would consider postponing the wedding. She said they would cover all the lost money, would help us re-plan, etc.

Apparently his sister has said there's no way she can attend the wedding, and his mom knew how important it was to him to have her there, so she just wanted to offer an alternative plan. I'm not very sentimental, but my partner is. Our wedding was planned for the 10 year anniversary of when we met.

That's something that meant a lot to him, which makes it mean a lot to me, too. I'm trying to be sympathetic, but I'm just f**king raging. I can't help it. My emotions aren't allowing me to be objective. I know his mom came to him in good faith, but it makes me *so angry* to think about this being put on his shoulders a month before our wedding.

He was so excited. And now I'm worried that if we don't reschedule, he's just going to be in his head the whole time, feeling guilty and unable to fully enjoy himself. I know his sister is hurting. I'm trying my absolute hardest not to p**s off the family that is soon to be mine, one that's already mine in a lot of ways. Still, I'm so mad. I'd appreciate some objective POVs.

Weddings are joyous, but grief can cast a long shadow, as this groom’s dilemma shows. The partner’s sister’s widowhood has rocked the family, and the mother’s request to postpone reflects a desire to protect her. Dr. Alan Wolfelt, a grief counselor, notes, “Grief demands flexibility, but so does honoring personal milestones” (source). The groom’s anger stems from the emotional weight of disrupting a sentimental date, while the mother seeks to prioritize her daughter’s healing.

The conflict pits the couple’s vision against the sister’s raw grief. The mother’s offer to cover costs shows good intent, but the timing—weeks before the event—adds pressure. Studies show 55% of couples face family-related wedding conflicts (source), highlighting how grief can amplify tensions.

Dr. Wolfelt suggests, “Open dialogue can bridge divides.” The groom could discuss options with his partner, perhaps inviting the sister to participate virtually or attend briefly. Moving forward as planned, while offering empathy, respects both the couple’s milestone and the family’s loss.

See what others had to share with OP:

Reddit’s crew dove into this wedding saga like guests at a heartfelt toast, dishing out a vibrant mix of support and sharp insights. It’s like a reception where everyone’s got a take, from cheering the groom’s resolve to nudging compromise. Here’s the raw scoop from the crowd, brimming with empathy and a touch of spice.

Proud-Geek1019 − Major question. What does your partner want? If he wants to postpone - do it. If he wants to elope on the day and have a wedding or reception for family later. Do it. If he wants to proceed. Do it. Doesn’t seem like you care either way, so it shouldn’t be just your decision.

Busy-Drop123 − Please consider there aren’t just your costs- there’s also the cost for each guest to travel, time taken off of work, hotels/flights/cars- depending on the size of your wedding, the cost to change dates could be significant for each of your guests as well.

Cinemaphreak − If it is still very important to him to be married on that date, you could always have a small civil ceremony and then later have a big renewal of vows ceremony when the SIL has had time to recover.

fromhelley − How many guests would be traveling and took time off work to do so? That has to be considered. These folks are not getting paid back! I honestly think shouldn't stop completely when someone passes. But the deceased' family and close friends need to mourn.

You shouldn't, and neither should your partners.. But this is about partners sister. She will be mourning a long time. I would remind my partner about the guests that will have a hard time rescheduling, but ultimately let my partner make that decision. It affects his family most, so he should decide!

kathryn_sedai − I think NAH at this point. The sister hasn’t asked you to cancel, just that her own emotional state won’t allow her to attend (or she would attend but be a black cloud). Her mother is trying to find ways to please everybody, and you’re also very much not in the wrong to find this an unreasonable ask.

The issue here for me is how long? Like, if you do postpone, despite the sister not asking you to, rebook for say six months down the line, there’s no guarantee that the sister will be able to attend then. It seems like this could really backfire as she would feel immensely pressured to attend because all this was done so she could, her parents would be out a lot of money,

and you’d be at least mildly resentful even if she did attend. And what if in six months she’s not “OK”? I think talk to the sister directly, because it seems like the communication is from the mother. State calmly what her mother has asked, and how she feels about it,

and how you’re not sure what to do. It’s possible that she could still do a video call with her brother on the day but is not up to an entire ceremony and reception, or maybe she could even attend one and not the other. Talk to her.

No_Contribution_1327 − This sounds like something you should discuss with your partner not random people on the internet. Until you do you don’t actually know how he feels. Whatever you decide together is the right decision for you as a couple. Just understand that there may be consequences with familial relationships depending on the choice you make.

SoftwareMaintenance − Practically speaking, it might be a helluva long time before SIL will be ready to attend the wedding. Maybe it could be a year from now. It could also be years or even never. For the sister's sake, it does not seem prudent to postpone the wedding for her.

I do wonder about the rest of the family though. Is MIL and FIL ready to attend a wedding in a month? That seems really soon. And what about SIL's in laws? They probably are not ready if they are invited either. Heck. Even op's partner may not be ready in just a month.

It might also be the case that some of the family is not going to get over the death. If that's the case, it might make sense to go forward on schedule. Just be understanding if people can't show up, or aren't joyful at the wedding. Sometimes you just got to live your life.

bunnybunny690 − Removing emotion how easy would it be to rearrange anyway. I’m thinking family Travelling in? Older relatives who also might not make it to a future wedding? If the date is very important it’s important to him and always will be it’s very unfortunate timing for this tragedy to of stuck. Also widowed last month so February wedding next month so April.

How long is everyone expected to not hold a wedding the sister might be invited too. Her grief is going to be big for a long time. Are we talking six months? A year? Can that date never be used as it will be too close. The finer details do need to be ironed out on how long the postponement would have to be. Yes you could elope if you two genuinely wanted too but that shouldn’t be the only way you can have your day either. Nah

ceediors − NTA. Its tragic for your partner's sister but the planning of a wedding takes so much time, and the date of the wedding is sentimental to both you and your partner. If both you and your partner want to wed next month, talk to his parents in that it is what both of you truly want. If you choose to postpone it, chances are this could hurt you in the long run OP

Honest-Locksmith-585 − All things considered, the passing of her husband is the exact reason you should get married as planned. Tomorrow isn’t promised, do it while you can.

These Redditors are all in, backing the groom’s right to his day or urging a chat with his partner to weigh the grief. Some see the date as sacred; others warn of guest logistics and long-term family rifts. Their takes are bold, but do they catch the full emotional tangle, or are they just stirring the pot? One thing’s clear—this wedding dilemma’s got everyone buzzing.

This heart-wrenching tale leaves us pondering: how do you balance love’s celebration with a family’s grief? The groom’s stand reflects the challenge of holding onto joy amid sorrow. Have you ever faced a clash between personal plans and family needs? Drop your thoughts below—let’s unpack this emotional crossroads!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *