AITA for playing volleyball in the day of my sister’s wedding?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

On a bright, hopeful morning, the stage was set for a family celebration that carried both love and anticipation. An accomplished volleyball player was ready to make her mark in an early game, unaware that her enthusiasm might cast an unexpected shadow on her sister’s wedding. The subtle tension between personal passion and familial commitment was about to unfold in a way that left everyone questioning priorities.

As the day progressed, the natural excitement of a victory began to interlace with delicate family emotions. The wedding atmosphere, meant to be filled with joy and unity, found itself caught in the crossfire of two conflicting moments – one of athletic triumph and one of cherished matrimonial celebration. The unfolding situation left observers wondering if celebrating personal success could ever be fully separated from sensitive family dynamics.

‘AITA for playing volleyball in the day of my sister’s wedding?’

I’m (18F) in my school’s volleyball team and we had a match scheduled for the day of my sister’s (24F) wedding. The game was early in the morning, the wedding would be at night, so there would be no conflict. Anyway, some relatives of ours who were in town just for the wedding heard me talking about the match and chose to go.

It was their own decision, I only mentioned the game but didn’t invite anybody personally. After the game, I come home. My team had won, I was excited, and some of our relatives were asking me about the team, and whether I plan to continue on playing when I’m in college etc.

My sister was already there – she chose our parents’ place as her HQ – and I could instantly tell she looked upset. When we were alone, I asked her what was the problem (I thought something was wrong with the wedding planning at first), and she went out on me about how this was supposed to be her day and I made it all about me when I chose to play and when I told our family about it.

I told her I can’t control other people’s reaction and that I didn’t insist for anyone to come, but she was still upset. We couldn't continue the conversation because she was about to get her hair and makeup done. We get to her wedding and of course she had other things on her mind.

But after the ceremony, I went to hug her and her husband during the party, and I told her a brief ‘I still want to talk to you about today’, but she just said ‘Now it’s not the time’. And that’s where we are now, we didn’t talk any further. AITA?

Letting your partner or family meet your significant moments can feel monumental, and this scenario is no exception. The interplay of self-expression and familial expectations is complex. In this case, the OP’s decision to focus on her personal victory, despite knowing the importance of her sister’s day, raises questions about the boundaries between personal fulfillment and family duty. Often, the issue isn’t the action itself but the timing and sensitivity of its presentation.

A closer look at the situation reveals two opposing viewpoints. On one side, there is the thrill of achieving a long-awaited victory and sharing that excitement with well-wishers. On the other, there is the duty to honor a sibling’s special celebration without diverting attention. This tension is not uncommon in family dynamics, where subtle cues and timing play crucial roles. The OP’s excitement, although genuine, may have overshadowed the emotional significance of her sister’s milestone.

Broadening this discussion, many families struggle to balance individual passions with collective events. Recent studies emphasize the importance of timing and context in family interactions, suggesting that sensitive subjects should be reserved for more appropriate moments. As highlighted by various relationship experts, understanding when to celebrate and when to hold back is key. For instance, a report on effective family communication underscores that choosing the right moment to discuss issues can preserve harmony and respect during important life events.

According to relationship expert Dr. Terri Orbuch, “Couples that communicate effectively are much better equipped to navigate conflicts without letting their emotions sabotage special moments.” This wisdom applies broadly to family dynamics as well. Dr. Orbuch’s insight encourages individuals to temper their personal triumphs with empathy for those around them. By appreciating the emotional landscape of significant family milestones, one can learn to celebrate responsibly while preserving the unity and respect essential to lasting relationships.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

The general sentiment among the Reddit community is that, although the excitement of a victory is entirely understandable, the timing could have been handled better. Many felt that mixing personal celebration with a family milestone led to an unfortunate clash of emotions. In essence, the consensus is that while being proud of one’s achievements is natural, it is equally important to respect the distinct significance of major family events, reserving personal discussions for a more appropriate time.

Both-Enthusiasm708 − Something feels off. I'm gonna say YTA because if I knew my sister was mad because she thought I was making her wedding about me, I would shut up and smile the rest of the day and then talk to her after.

The fact that you felt the need to approach her in what sounds like the receiving line tells me that you may be a bit self centered or oblivious. This also makes me think maybe the story didn't happen exactly as you said.

Old_Inevitable8553 − You weren't in the wrong until the last bit when you wanted to talk about it at the party. That's where YTA. That wasn't the time to discuss anything. As it was your sister's wedding, and it was her moment to shine. Not for you to bring up what happened earlier. You should've waited until the following day to even start that conversation.

Disastrous-Nail-640 − You are fine until you mentioned it again during the reception. For that, YTA. You knew she was upset. She had let it go to enjoy the day. And you decided to bring it up while she was literally in the middle of her wedding? Really?

GothPenguin − YTA-For bringing it up in the reception line. That was their moment and the time to celebrate them not your moment to want to talk about that.

rockology_adam − YTA. This is a niche call, OP, and I acknowledge that, but in the morning, with the stress of wedding prep, your sister had a bad reaction to attention being focussed on you. That's her bad, and she's out of line. But bringing it up at the party later as something you wanted to talk about? That's really distracting.

It's also very self-centering, and does make me actually wonder about the volleyball game earlier in the day. While, without that context, I don't care about the volleyball game, it's a strange call on your part but not wildly out of line, within the context of trying to call her out about it at her wedding party later that day, I really don't like it.

Why on earth did you try to talk to her about it at the wedding party? What about the situation made it imperative that you talk about it there and then? I can't imagine a reason for you to mention it at the party that isn't self-centred or petty.

It wasn't urgent. It was passed and unimportant for the evening. Why bring it up at the party at all? There's no reason to go to your sister and try to pick up a fight from earlier in the day except to pick a fight with her.

Affectionate-Log-260 − Relatives were likely bored with no festivities until evening. You are NTA for playing. NTA for not dissuading relatives from attending match.. However, YTA for bringing it up to sister at reception. Really poor form

ActiveSufficient3944 − NAH, but you're slightly immature (your sis may be too). You really REALLY should not have said

after you let them enjoy the newlywed high. It really wasn't necessary to say right then. Your comment should've been about how beautiful she looked or how wonderful the ceremony was or how much you hope she enjoys the party, etc.

The fact the you needed to make a comment to shift attention back to yourself does have me wondering ever so slightly if you did make sure to talk about the game so others came to it. 

Somuchallthetime − YTA. You came home after the game all excited cause you won and kept the attention on yourself by answering all your family’s questions rather than coming home and simply not talking about it.

Awkward_Energy590 − ESH If you had left it alone, instead of bringing up the argument in the middle of her Reception Line, you'd be NTA. But you didn't drop it, even in the middle of her big day.

You are correct in that you can't control other people, and being excited about a win is cool, but you kept bringing it up. That's where you went wrong. And your sister is silly for being upset about it prior to the ceremony. Very fully justified in being upset DURING the celebration.

LowBalance4404 − I was with you until. and I told her a brief ‘I still want to talk to you about today’ And that's when you lost me. YTA because she's right, that moment was NOT the time to dig this back up.

In wrapping up, it becomes clear that navigating family events alongside personal triumphs is a delicate dance. Both the intensity of personal passion and the need for family respect must be balanced with care.

What would you do if you found yourself in a similar situation? Share your thoughts and experiences as we continue to explore the intricate ties that bind family and personal achievement.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *