AITA since I told my gf she’s freaking out over nothing?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In relationships, even minor issues can spark deep emotional reactions. Here, a small change in a skincare routine—a discontinued acne cream—unleashes long-buried insecurities that challenge both partners.

The girlfriend’s distress, fueled by past body image struggles, contrasts sharply with her boyfriend’s practical problem-solving approach. This brief, tense moment illustrates how personal vulnerabilities can turn everyday frustrations into significant emotional upheavals.

‘AITA since I told my gf she’s freaking out over nothing?’

My gf has had body issues the whole 5 years we have been together. I love her and remind her how beautiful she is constantly. She has dealt with an eating disorder before me, and I cook for her to make sure she eats stuff other than energy drinks, chips, and sugar.

As of late, she has been having trouble with acne. She might have like 2 pimples and think the world is over. I had tons of acne in high school, got made fun of, and got over it. She has been dealing with it due to the birth control pills she takes. I have told her multiple times that if she hates it, we can go back to condoms or switch pills.

She just doesn't due to fear of other pills' side effects and/or

She's crying on the phone ,driving, talking to me about how she's having a panic attack, and wanting to scream and cry in the store after noticing it is not being made anymore. I first told her to pull over and not to drive if she's panicking like this. Then, I told her a realistic plan of trying other products that I could even buy for her so she could test them.

I also told her about this beef tallow thing that she showed me a while back. She wasn't happy and told me how she

She yelled at me and hung up. I can understand how much she hates having acne, but trying other creams and potentially finding a better one sounds so easy to me. She will maybe have 4 pimples for a few weeks and won't explode. Am I The A**hole for saying she shouldn't freak out over it?

This situation highlights the delicate balance between offering practical advice and acknowledging deep-seated emotions. The boyfriend’s logical suggestions missed the mark because the real issue wasn’t the acne cream at all—it was a manifestation of longstanding self-doubt and anxiety about appearance. Minor blemishes can sometimes trigger intense emotional responses, especially when linked to past experiences of body image issues.

As dermatologist Dr. Whitney Bowe explains, “The skin reflects our emotional health; even small irritations can reveal deeper concerns.” Her insight reminds us that what appears as an overreaction often stems from underlying vulnerabilities.

Rather than rushing to solutions, a more compassionate response involves simply listening and validating the emotional pain. This approach not only helps de-escalate the immediate crisis but can also encourage seeking professional support if needed, fostering a healthier path toward mutual understanding and emotional resilience in the relationship.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Here are some hot takes from the Reddit community – candid and humorous.

Affirmativerobot − NAH  but your girlfriend’s issues with her body are beyond what you can reasonably help her with. If she isn’t in therapy already, she truly should look into it and take action.  Her freak out wasn’t over just this cream, it was over the storm of emotions she feels regarding her own body and face. This isn’t something you can fix with logic.

Good job telling her to pull-over. Good job listening and taking her seriously. Just not the right time to offer pragmatic solutions. In the future it would honestly be better to listen, validate, keep it vague like “we’ll figure something out” and come at her with actionable steps later. 

Independent_Prior612 − The middle of a meltdown is not the time to tell someone they shouldn’t be melting down. You need to have that conversation when everyone is calm. She felt dismissed and invalidated.

SupermarketNeat4033 − Softest ESH. She didn't actually freak out or scream as hard as she can, she

You're in solutions mode, trying to fix the acne situation. However, the problem for her at that point is not actually the acne itself, its dealing with experiencing her emotions and express them. By quantifying that emotional expression as

However, she is expressing those emotions in an unhealthy and under-regulated way. Reaching the point of a panic attack and taking out her emotions on her partner is not acceptable. That's something she may need to seek a therapist for because she needs to work on being able to self regulate better than this and not letting her emotions lead to bad behavior and negatively impacting others.

But, just a tip: Guide the emotion train to a slow halt at the nearest station, don't ask the conductor to slam the emergency breaks when it's going 330mph and expect that to work out. Trying to tell someone that their very big emotions are just unnecessary or don't need to be happening right now rarely ever makes the situation better.

Strong emotions have a neurochemical/hormonal components to them so if she's in the throws of extreme stress and her brain chemistry is being effected by a flood of Cortisol and whatever else; trying to logic your way into getting someone to in that moment ignore or shut down their emotional response isn't going to make those hormones and feelings suddenly stop.

andunelwen − NAH. Has she ever talked to a professional when she was struggling with the eating disorder? She might need to revisit talking to a therapist because while it does seem like an overreaction to you, something about it triggered her to react that way. Seems like there’s more to it than just the cream being gone. Might help to ask her in the future if she wants to talk about it or just get a solution!

Rastavaray − Sounds like she wanted to rant. She can no longer have the thing that works for her. No s**t she's going to have to try something else. That's not rocket science. Sometimes you just want to be able to rant and be validated in your disappointment. Not everything is a problem for you to solve.

Logical-Market-1847 − NTA, she seems to have underlying issues with Emotional control to flip out that badly over acne cream.

Inevitable-Tower-525 − Clinical counselor here! You’re not the a**hole, but you also weren’t skillful. Body image insecurity is strongly tied to overall r**ection sensitivity. Our culture tells people at a very young age that they won’t “belong” if they have aesthetic flaws.

R**ection sensitivity is neurologically wired to create panic because we’re social creatures that need secure attachment like we need water. In this case, your girlfriend was tapping into this insecurity. Before I orient you to where you could have been more skillful, let me say that the primarily responsibly of creating skillful security lies in each individual.

Meaning that at the end of the day, it’s your girlfriend’s responsibility to enhance her sense of security within her own nervous system, not yours. But choosing into a shared life creates valid reason for you to act in a way that helps her create security rather than perpetuates insecurity.

By focusing on the “overreaction,” you’re telling your girlfriend that you are not on the same plane as her and you are looking down on where she is. She now feels more attachment insecurity which fuels more body image sensitivity. Now onto the more skillful response.

When the insecurity arises, recognize that it in itself is all encompassing, but it is separate from your girlfriend. It’s like a possession of fear. Separate the averse nature of the insecurity from the pleasant reality of your girlfriend as a vulnerable human deserving of love.

The next skillful behavior is to trace the insecurity to contain it. Encourage her to vocalize where the cloud of insecurity is. And just listen curiously while maintaining groundedness in your nervous system. By doing this, you’re putting a container around her fear and creating attachment.

This lessens the insecurity and helps ground her, subsequently lessening the fear and panic and creating better outcomes for both of you. If any “reality checking” is going to happen, it has to be evoked from within her to be valuable.. Hope this helps!

More-Diet3566 − NTA, but.... The problem isn't the acne. At least, not really. Gonna go out on a limb here and guess she came from a hyper critical family. And / or maybe got bullied. . Her perception of self is very distorted - she has trouble seeing herself accurately. Some tips if you are trying to help - next time, if she calls panicked like that, say, what's going on?

(Listen). Okay, it is going to be okay. (Reassure her). Calmly tell her to find a place to pull over so you can talk. (Do Not tell her to calm down or that she is overreacting because in her mind this is a big deal). Have her take a few deep slow breaths. When she has her breath closer to normal. Let her fully discuss what is going on in her head.

If she only mentions the cream, tell her to come home so you guys can figure it out together. (It sounds like you're invested in helping her so it is better she is there with you to work on this problem together). When she gets home, skip the words - just hug her for a moment.

When she is okay, then you can let her talk again and see if you can try to find the cream somewhere else and, if not, look into other options. But either way, let her know, when she is calm, that she is beautiful, and you lover her.  I don't think you are TA or a bad guy, Most people don't know how to handle this type of issue.

Whatever it stems from, it is pretty deep rooted and likely started when she was younger. Someone made her feel ugly and unworthy, and no, no matter what self controlled improvements she does, she still has moments were she believes the lies she was told when she was younger.

She has trouble seeing past those lies. This won't change until she can see the real issue. I hope she chooses to tell you about the comments or events that led her to feel this way - that would do far more healing for her than any cream she buys. I wish you guys the best.

toiletannihil8r − nah, birth control will make you feel f**king bonkers too idk if that's helping her

IcePrincess_Not_Sk8r − Soft YTA Never in the history of human beings has telling someone to calm down, ever calmed them down.... She very likely knew she was overreacting. She wanted you to listen to her, not try to problem solve. Sometimes, people just want to be mad. Sometimes, they just want to vent. Sometimes, they want to scream in the safety of their own home, car, whatever, to decompress and then move forward.

These popular opinions offer a spectrum of views, reflecting the complex nature of interpersonal conflicts. While some argue that the OP’s logical approach misses the mark when emotions are involved, others suggest that a more listening-oriented strategy would have been more supportive. As always, the reality is nuanced, and each perspective contributes to a broader understanding of how love and stress intersect in modern relationships.

In conclusion, this story reminds us that the gaps between empathy and logic can often define the way we navigate personal relationships. While practical advice has its place, acknowledging and validating emotional pain is equally important. The intricate dance between love, support, and understanding makes all the difference when one partner is at a vulnerable crossroads.

What would you do if you found yourself caught between logic and emotion in a similar situation? We’d love to hear your experiences, thoughts, and ideas for striking the right balance in a relationship.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *