AITA for not going to Thanksgiving over the dishes?

Every year, Thanksgiving should be a time for gratitude, family togetherness, and warm memories. But for some, the holiday has gradually transformed into a battleground of responsibilities. This year, the idea of joining a gathering where dish duty falls solely on their shoulders seems more like a chore than a celebration. The conflict centers on one simple, yet frustrating task: doing the dishes.

For many, the holiday spirit is overshadowed by the recurring expectation of cleaning up—especially when everyone else is free to relax or enjoy other activities like soaking in the hot tub. The narrator, tired of being the only one tasked with dish duty, found his patience worn thin. With mixed emotions and a touch of humor, he decided that missing this Thanksgiving was a small act of rebellion against unfair expectations.

‘AITA for not going to Thanksgiving over the dishes?’

This weekend is Canadian Thanksgiving. I (29M) live in the United States but my stepmom is Canadian and her mom always comes down from BC for the weekend to celebrate with a feast for my mostly American family. To be honest, my “step-grandma”’s cooking is not good. And she is the most passive aggressive person I have ever met.

Every year she makes such a big deal about how much work she put into her bland ass food and expects endless praise for her efforts. But I digress. Every year at Canadian Thanksgiving, my husband and I are asked to do the dishes. It’s fine, we don’t mind it. But the hard part is that we are guests, and we are the only people ever expected to help.

At first it was like “Okay we are the youngest, so that’s why.” but in the past few years, my stepmom’s nieces and nephews, all in their early 20s, were there and after dinner went in the hot tub. Meanwhile, if I’m playing with my nephew I don’t get to see much, I hear from the kitchen my step-grandma say loudly “if only someone would help me with the dishes” and of course my dad comes over and says “Hey can you guys help her with the dishes”.

I’m just sick of being the only ones expected to help. This is our second year living in a different city and about a month ago they asked if I was coming. I told them I wasn’t sure and later told them I wasn’t. They offered to pay for our flights and I still said I couldn’t make it. Made up an excuse. But really it’s the dishes.

Again, don’t mind doing them, just sick of being the only people expected to help out while everyone else is socialize and hang in the hot tub. I have talked to my brothers (both older) and one agrees with me and the other thinks that’s a stupid reason. So I am wondering, am I the a**hole?

Balancing family expectations and personal boundaries can be challenging, especially when one feels consistently burdened by unshared responsibilities. In family gatherings, roles often become established by tradition rather than mutual agreement, leaving some members feeling exploited. The narrator’s frustration over always being the designated dish-drawer highlights an important issue in family dynamics: the equitable distribution of household tasks. The stress from repeated imbalances can quickly erode the joy of shared celebrations.

In reflecting on this recurring dish duty, it is useful to consider the value of setting clear boundaries. When one’s contribution is taken for granted year after year, it not only drains energy but also sows seeds of resentment. Relationship expert Dr. Henry Cloud once remarked, “Boundaries define the relationship between what we are responsible for and what others are responsible for, and enforcing them is crucial to maintaining self-respect.”  His words remind us that family relationships thrive when personal limits are respected and when each member shares the load.

Building on that perspective, it is clear that the narrator’s decision stems not from a dislike for his family, but rather from the need to reclaim personal balance. When tasks like dishwashing become a recurring source of contention, small gestures—like saying “no” to a traditional role—can serve as a catalyst for deeper conversation about fairness. This incident is emblematic of a larger issue: the negotiation between long-standing family traditions and evolving personal responsibilities, especially when those traditions feel outdated or unbalanced.

Finally, adopting more assertive communication strategies can help families reshape how responsibilities are assigned. Professional counselors often suggest that discussing expectations ahead of gatherings can prevent misunderstandings and ensure everyone feels valued. This proactive approach can transform a routine task into a shared, mutually agreed-upon activity, preserving the spirit of the holiday while honoring each individual’s right to set healthy boundaries.

See what others had to share with OP:

Here are some candid reactions from the Reddit community—raw, humorous, and affirming the right to set personal limits. Comments range from support for rejecting the dish duty to suggestions on how to renegotiate family responsibilities. Fellow redditors point out that an invitation is not a subpoena, and that no one should be forced to play janitor for a holiday feast.

Tanuk-E- −  NTA. Shame on your siblings for not offering to help. It's fine to help out every once in a while but for you guys to be the cleanup squad each time? Not cool and y'all are being taken advantage. And shame on your step-grandma for making bland food.

Kaynico −  Info: why not just say no to your dad? It sounds like from your post that he's the one targettting you guys.  Why deprive yourself of seeing your nephew and the rest of your family instead of just saying

StAlvis −  INFO. of course my dad comes over and says “Hey can you guys help her with the dishes”. And you're unfamiliar with the words

fancy_underpantsy −  If you go, have your bathing suit on under your regular clothes before dinner and make sure your nephew does as well. Then immediately as dinner ends, hit the hot tub. Be the first to leave the table.. Don't let the bastards win.

houseonpost −  NTA: But nobody can take advantage of you without your permission. Talk to your dad before hand and explain why you don't feel like coming and come up with an alternative plan. Given you don't like the cooking why don't you offer to do some or all of the cooking? Nobody would dream of asking you to do the dishes.

Waste_Worker6122 −  NTA. An invitation is not a subpoena. That said you might want to work on your assertiveness and learn to use the magic word no. You could attend and simply say

lostalldoubt86 −  NTA- Tell your father it is someone else’s turn this year. If you want to be petty, suggest your brother who doesn’t think being asked his a big deal.

Appropriate-Plum-863 −  NTA. Why pay for a trip to eat bland food and be treated like the help? (Does your family also celebrate the US Thanksgiving holiday - and if so, how is the food, company, and chore distribution then?) Just say

EquivalentBend9835 −  Paper plates, plastic cups and cutlery. We did this to my mom. My SIL come over thanksgiving and put all the china, glasses, and silver cutlery away. She said that her daughter and daughters in law aren’t maids and we want to visit with the family too. Now everyone brings food and cleans up. Oh, my mom can’t cook with out dirtying up every pot and pan and never cleans as she goes. 😳

JellyBelly1042 −  😂🤣😂😂 I'd go and as soon as dad asks I'd say no I'm great here thank you and if anyone has something to say let them know if their hands moved as fast as their mouth they could help with dishes. Don't offer my services if you're not offering yours. Your family would hate me because I'd tell them where they could go along with step grandmother and that dried out unappealing turkey.

In conclusion, the story raises a valid question about the balance between tradition and personal well-being. When repetitive obligations like dishwashing overshadow the joyous spirit of a holiday, it is natural to push back. Is it too far-fetched to refuse participation solely to avoid being the perennial cleanup crew?

What strategies can be adopted to reassign tasks more equitably among family members? We invite you to share your views and personal experiences. What would you do when family traditions start to feel more like burdens than celebrations?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *