AITA for calling out my father and cutting off my brothers after discovering they hid a financial windfall from me?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In an emotionally charged family saga, long-held responsibilities and hidden fortunes collide, exposing deep-rooted wounds. The narrative opens with the weight of years spent shouldering financial burdens and supporting siblings, only to have that trust shattered by secret transactions. The shock of discovering that a hidden windfall was concealed behind closed doors sets the stage for a dramatic reckoning, where betrayal and unspoken resentments come to the fore.

The scene is painted with somber hues of disappointment and betrayal. The narrator, who has consistently carried the weight of family obligations, finds himself isolated by deceit. His realization that intimate financial matters were manipulated without his knowledge sparks a fierce need for accountability, igniting a decision to sever ties with those who have repeatedly disregarded both his trust and sacrifices.

‘AITA for calling out my father and cutting off my brothers after discovering they hid a financial windfall from me?’

I have been the primary provider for my siblings since 2019. My father was emotionally abusive growing up, and after my mother passed, I took on the responsibility of financially supporting my younger siblings—paying for their education, food, and other necessities, even while working hard to keep myself afloat.

As my father was retired and his pension wasn’t sufficient. Meanwhile, my father and his wife (they married in 2021) have never contributed much but have constantly badgered my siblings for money. Recently, I found out that one of my brothers, Sam, received a significant financial windfall.

Instead of telling me, he hid it from me, gave a large chunk to his church, sent money to our father (who lied about needing it for an

The only reason I found out was because my sister Emma traveled back home and Troy told her. She told me, and when I confronted Sam, I learned that he had intentionally kept it from me because he was “finalizing results.” Yet he had shared the entire money! It doesn’t help that Sam and Emma are twins. Emma would be going to law school this year and would need financial help.

But he didn’t remember to gift her anything. This was my major angst as I wasn’t looking to share in the money. I am financially comfortable. To make matters worse, my father later called Emma a “destroyer

I feel betrayed. For years, I struggled to ensure my siblings had what they needed, and the moment someone else had money, they didn’t even think I was important enough to be informed. So I made a decision: I cut them all off —my father and his wife, Sam, and Troy. The only person I want to have in my life is Emma, as she was the only one honest with me.. So, AITA for refusing to forgive them and cutting them off?

Financial dynamics in families can be as complex as any business ledger, where transparency serves as the bedrock of trust. In this case, the core issue lies in the covert handling of unexpected wealth. The narrative exemplifies how decades of familial duty can be undermined by dishonesty. When one sibling hides a significant financial windfall and misallocates the funds, the disruption is not merely monetary—it fractures the essential bonds that hold a family together.

Analyzing this situation further, the betrayal is compounded by long-standing emotional neglect and financial exploitation. Years of providing for siblings, coupled with the harsh memories of past emotional abuse, add layers of intensity to the betrayal felt when undisclosed wealth is mishandled. The hidden windfall becomes a symbol not just of lost money but of the disregard for the sacrifices made by the primary provider. Such events force us to reconsider the dynamics of obligation versus expectation in family relationships.

According to renowned personal finance journalist Jean Chatzky, “Open communication about money in relationships sets the tone for mutual respect and shared responsibility.” This insight, which echoes widely in financial circles and relationship counseling forums, underscores the principle that transparency is crucial. When financial decisions are made behind closed doors, the resulting gap in trust can cause irreparable harm. Jean Chatzky’s perspective reminds us that clear financial boundaries and honest discussions are essential for maintaining harmony, especially in close family ties.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Here are some candid reactions from the Reddit community—raw, unfiltered, and laced with a touch of dark humor. The responses range from outright support for severing ties to thoughtful observations on the necessity of accountability in family matters. They illustrate a broad spectrum of opinions from fellow redditors who view the hidden windfall as a symbol of long-simmering betrayal.

YeeHawMiMaw − If Sam can afford to give away all of his windfall, he doesn't need your support any more. Cut Sam off. If Sam can afford to give away all of his windfall, he can support your dad/step mom from now on. Cut them off.. If Sam can afford to give away all of his windfall, he can support Troy. Cut Troy off.

Since Sam is now supporting all of them, you can afford to help your sister with law school expenses. Just make sure you pay directly to the school so she isn't funneling money to the leeches.. NTA

lady_sparx − NTA. You've supported your family financially and emotionally for years, and discovering that they hid a financial windfall from you is a huge betrayal. It's not about the money, but the lack of respect and honesty. You’re right to cut them off for your own well-being, especially since Emma is the only one who was honest with you. Protecting yourself is completely understandable.

monkerry − Set a trust if you want to help Emma so she can't be bullied to

ttppii − I find it impossible to understand why anyone who has been struggling would give a significant portion of extra money to church?

ProfessionalParty468 − NTA, and if you ever talk to any of them again you’re a better person than I

GhostOfMost − NTA - it sounds like they are well aware of who they are. This windfall happened and they were immediately all on the same page, which was, “keep this between us.” Your dad even accused your sister of snitching on them. Wow. It sounds like you’ve found out that your family is a bunch of grifters. Better late than never. I’m sorry. That sucks.

Appropriate_Speech33 − I would have made the exact same choice to cut them off. What the f?! NTA, but all of your bothers and dad are massive assholes. Although I am curious about why Sam didn’t give anything to Emma or tell you. Misogyny? (You didn’t say your gender, but I assumed woman). Stupidity?. Not that it matters. I’m just curious about those things.

newwriter365 − NTA.. You realize that they cut you off, right?. Return the favor.

robinluvssweetums − NTA. Good for you. I think you should invest in some self-care for yourself, as well as therapy.

LeftPhilosopher9628 − NTA - and if you decide to help Emma with law school, make the payments directly to the institution

In conclusion, the story highlights the painful intersection of duty, trust, and financial deception—a scenario where open communication and fairness seem to have long been forgotten. It raises a poignant question about where the line should be drawn between familial obligation and self-preservation. If you were in a similar situation, would you choose to rebuild trust or cut ties for good? Share your thoughts, experiences, and potential solutions, and join the broader conversation about the intricate balance between love and money in modern families.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *