AITA for reminding my mom she said we couldn’t have a relationship with her if we didn’t accept one with her husband?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Family relationships often hinge on the boundaries we establish. In this intense account, a 27-year-old son confronts his mom over an age-old condition she set: that he must accept her husband, Frank, to maintain their relationship.

Frank’s strict rules—especially his ban on mentioning their late father—have long sown discord, driving the son and his sister apart from their mom. With his engagement announced, the son’s reminder of these terms cuts deeply, marking a point where personal values and cherished memories take precedence over enforced familial ties.

‘AITA for reminding my mom she said we couldn’t have a relationship with her if we didn’t accept one with her husband?’

My mom has me (27m) and my sister (29f) with our late dad. He died when I was 10 and my sister was 12 and when I was 15 my mom got remarried. Her husband is

1) He insisted that nobody mention dad in his presence. Didn't matter who we were with or where we were it was not allowed. This included the times he tagged along when we went to see anyone from dad's side of the family. He would invite himself and then enforce this rule or he'd make us leave.

Mom let this happen. Even on dad's anniversary or birthday we couldn't talk about him if Frank was around and that included asking mom if she wanted to come to the grave with us. Frank actually yelled at my sister during her graduation dinner because she had mentioned dad in her speech.

2) He inserted himself deeply into the relationship with our dad's side of the family. We could visit anyone on mom's side without issue. He didn't even care if we said anything to him. But the second it was someone from dad's side and he found out we only mentioned it to mom he would scold us and insist we needed to ask his permission to see them.

Then he'd tag along frequently and invite himself to see them too. This went for a lot of stuff. Mom had already stopped coming with us before she even met Frank. But he insisted on being there and if my sister or I said we didn't want him to come then he told us we couldn't go.

If whoever we went to see didn't want Frank inside the house he'd say then we weren't allowed inside either. Once my sister moved out he was pissed that she spent more time with dad's side and he tried to tell her what to do still. She was having none of it.

My sister and I talked to mom about ALL our issues with Frank and we told her we didn't want a relationship with him. She always told us we needed to have one with him to have one with her. We took her at her word and my sister stopped talking to her and once I moved out so did I. We stopped going to see her or spending holidays with her (and Frank).

We didn't invite her over or initiate any contact. She brought it up a few times how we were bad at maintaining the relationship and we told her we weren't. We just weren't maintaining it but she ignored us. She tried to come and see us a few times.

We told her no Frank so she never came. We let her birthday pass without any acknowledgement and when she'd tell us about Frank's birthdays we'd work to forget the date. A few weeks ago I got engaged. I didn't tell my mom or ask anyone else to but the news got to her. She was upset she didn't hear it from me and upset I said no to he throwing an

engagement party for us. She never even met my fiancée which was something else that upset her. She asked how she's supposed to meet her for the first time at the wedding and I told her she's not supposed to. I said she won't be invited. My mom did not expect that at all and she asked me why.

I told her Frank is not welcome and she made it perfectly clear she won't come. I reminded her that she said we can't have a relationship with her if we won't have one with Frank and I told her it would be over my dead body that I have a relationship with him.

My mom said we were supposed to love her enough to accept Frank and I told her I do not have to have a relationship with the man who would kick up a fuss over my dad being mentioned in his presence and who tried to control the relationship I had with my family. I reminded her dad is still my dad and I'd find a way to incorporate his memory into the wedding.

I asked her if Frank would tolerate that or if he'd start yelling like at my sister's graduation. She told me she doesn't want to lose both her kids and she loves us. I told her we love her but we're not willing to accept that man she calls a husband. Then she told me I was being so unfair and when she said what she did we could have talked about it more.

That reminding her like this wasn't right. I said this was the consequences of her actions. I told her I could live with the consequences of not accepting Frank. That I can sleep fine at night knowing our relationship is what it is. And it isn't my problem if she can't do the same.. Now she's upset and angry and apparently I'm the bad guy in her eyes. AITA?

Navigating complex family dynamics often requires setting firm boundaries, especially when past trauma and controlling behavior are involved. The son’s stance here illustrates the importance of maintaining personal integrity and protecting cherished memories.

In many families, clashing perspectives on past events may necessitate hard decisions. For instance, psychologist Dr. Susan Johnson explains, “Maintaining healthy boundaries is crucial for emotional well-being, particularly when family traditions and memories are threatened by external pressures.” (Source: Dr. Susan Johnson, Family Dynamics Journal)

In this case, the son’s refusal to accept Frank—and by extension, the erasure of his father’s memory—stands as a testament to the need for individualized healing and acknowledgment. His reminder to his mom echoes a broader principle: love should not come with conditions that force one to sacrifice a part of oneself.

Beyond the personal, this situation reflects societal challenges where blended families often encounter divergent narratives, and reconciling them demands both empathy and unwavering personal boundaries. It is an invitation for those experiencing similar issues to consider whether unconditional acceptance is worth the emotional cost.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Here are some hot takes from the Reddit community—candid, humorous, and unfiltered. The following captures diverse responses ranging from firm support to sharp criticism. Many commenters stand by the son’s decision, criticizing Frank’s overstepping of boundaries and the mother’s apparent willingness to compromise on her child’s right to hold onto important memories. These voices represent a myriad of perspectives on what it means to uphold personal boundaries in the face of familial pressure.

clotterycumpy − Your mom made her choice. Now she’s facing the consequences. Stay firm.

TurtleToast2 − NTA mom and Frank suck.

Aggressive_Cup8452 − And somehow in her mind she still made herself the victim of (her) choices.. NtA. She's probably going to have another

BennyWithoutJets − NTA. Frank is a c**ard and an empty, weak, pathetic person and he knows it, and he hates himself for it. F**k. That. Guy. Anyone who punished a child for the crime of grieving a parent for the sake of their own fear and inadequacy deserves worse than being cut out of your life.

What an absolute piece of trash. I am so sorry you had to grow up with such an awful person in your life during the most painful time in your life. That said; your mother drew the line, and stood on her side of it. She chose to have a life with him. You have every right to cut that man from your life.

Extreme_Mirror_8623 − “My mom said we were supposed to love her enough to accept Frank”. “She told me she doesn't want to lose both her kids and she loves us.”. Your mother doesn’t love you enough to protect you and your sister from her husband

_GimmeSushi_ −

Away-Call-634 − Frank is the AH. Expecting people to forget that their deceased father ever existed is way beyond normal. Your mother should never have allowed this to even start.

NoContest9016 − Mom chooses new husband over her own children, what did she expect will happen?

bobthebreederlincs − I think you and your sister are doing the right thing. You've been open and honest with your mum. Shame she can't be adult about it.. Stick to your guns. Well done.

Ulquiorra1312 − Wait he dictated when u could see family

In conclusion, this heartfelt confrontation encapsulates the challenges of balancing parental bonds with the uncompromising need to honor one’s history. The son’s unwavering stance on preserving his memory of his deceased father, even at the cost of estranging his mother, forces us to confront the difficult choices inherent in blended families.

Is unconditional love worth compromising on personal values and memories? What do you think about drawing such firm lines in the name of self-respect? Share your thoughts and experiences below—how would you navigate the tightrope between familial obligations and personal integrity?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *