AITA for telling my sister she cant bring her fake emotional support dog to my wedding?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

As wedding day approaches, every detail matters to create the perfect celebration. In a story that intertwines family, health, and hard boundaries, a 29-year-old bride finds herself locked in a dilemma. Her dream of an outdoor wedding at a stunning venue is under threat by a single disruptive element—a pitbull that her sister insists qualifies as an emotional support dog. This claim, backed only by a dubious online certificate, contrasts sharply with the dog’s unruly behavior and its track record of causing chaos at past family events.

Under the gentle canopy of her envisioned wedding day, the bride’s allergy to dogs adds another layer of complication. The constant barking, jumping, and even an incident of the dog peeing on cherished furniture, all fuel her resolve. Despite offering a compromise to create a quiet space for her sister, the bride stands firm on a dog-free policy to ensure a smooth, allergy-safe celebration. The tension is palpable, leaving us to wonder: is maintaining these boundaries truly unreasonable?

‘AITA for telling my sister she cant bring her fake emotional support dog to my wedding?’

I (29F) am getting married in a few months, and were having an outdoor ceremony at a beautiful venue. My sister (26F) has a small pitbull that she claims is an emotional support animal. The thing is, its definitely not a legitimate support dog. She bought one of those fake online certificates just so she could take him everywhere.

Hes not trained at all, he barks constantly, jumps on people, and once even peed on our moms couch during a family dinner. To make matters worse, Im allergic to dogs. Its not life threatening, but I get itchy eyes, hives, and asthma symptoms when Im around them for too long. I manage it at family events by taking allergy meds but they make me sleepy and I really dont want to deal with that on my wedding day.

When I told my sister she couldnt bring her dog, she flipped out. She said I was discriminating against her for having anxiety and that I dont understand how much she needs him. I offered to set up a quiet space for her if she needed a break during the wedding, but she said I was being unsupportive.

My fiancé is on my side, but my mom is pushing me to just let it go to keep the peace. She said its just one day and that I can push through it. Meanwhile, my sister is now threatening not to come at all if her dog isnt allowed. I feel like Im being reasonable by asking for a dog-free wedding, especially with my allergies, but maybe I'm the a**hole?

When personal well-being and event integrity are at stake, setting clear boundaries becomes paramount. In this case, the bride’s decision to bar her sister’s so-called emotional support dog is not merely a matter of preference—it’s a health necessity and an essential part of preserving the celebration’s sanctity.

Emotional support animals, unlike service dogs, are not granted the same rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act. As stated by the ADA, “Emotional support animals do not qualify for public access rights because they are not trained to perform specific tasks for individuals with disabilities.”

This expert insight underscores the legitimacy of the bride’s concerns. The dog’s unruly behavior, coupled with her allergies, creates a compelling case for a dog-free event. Moreover, her offer to arrange a quiet space for her sister demonstrates a willingness to compromise on comfort without compromising her own health or the event’s quality. In essence, by prioritizing an environment free from potential chaos and health risks, she is protecting her once-in-a-lifetime celebration from unnecessary disruptions.

See what others had to share with OP:

Here are some of the candid reactions from the Reddit community—unfiltered and pointed:Many agree that if the sister cannot understand that a wedding is not the place for an untrained, disruptive animal, then her attendance might be better off reconsidered. The consensus reinforces that the bride is simply maintaining a necessary boundary for her special day.

meloncholymama − NTA! If she can't leave him home, then she can't come. Easy peasy.

amlosthere − NTA- she can just not come. You are allergic and shouldn't have to deal with that for a fake support dog, let alone paying for any damage it does to the venue or anything. People like your sister make it hard for people who actually need service dogs.

giririsss − You're not being supportive. Why would you?. She's the one who's meant to be supportive. Of you. She's there to support you, and celebrate your marriage.. The day has nothing to do with supporting her.. NTA. Don't back down. Don't let your mothers cowardice influence your day either.

ritlingit − It’s not “just one day”. This is a landmark event. It’s an event that your sister needs to handle her bs. It’s an event where your mother needs to stop making exceptions for your sister. It’s an event where a dog does not belong. In fact since there is much controversy around pit bulls it is probably not appropriate to bring one to a large event where people will be drinking alcohol, children may be there and there will be activity.

Tell your sister if she can’t handle a wedding without an emotional support she needs to stay home and tend to her mental symptoms. You are not a landlord or a restaurant. You are not obligated to include an emotional support dog whether it is real or not.

foldinthecheese99 − If you are in the US, ESAs are not protected under the ADA. There is not training or registration required. They are not required to be allowed in any business - your sister should know this if she educated herself on her ESA. I 100% support the use of them, but also she needs to know how to cope if her dog is not allowed in a business that enforces the difference between an emotional support animal and a service animal.

Has she ever spoken to a doctor about her anxiety? Medications? Some Prozac for high stress days? Understanding about attending the ceremony and dinner and leaving before the reception ends? There are a lot of solutions to help her without you needing to have an animal you are allergic to at your wedding. (Would be different if it was a service animal).

Chigrrl1098 − This has the tone of another creative writing exercise. I swear I've read this one before.

GuyFromLI747 − Things that never happened. AI Content Found. Percentage of text that may be AI-generated.. 100%. https://copyleaks.com/ai-content-detector

naranghim − NTA. I'm betting *the venue* would demand that your sister's dog leave since Emotional Support Animals aren't covered by the ADA (if you are in the US). The only law that really protects them is the FHA and that's for housing (and they're allowed to reject documentation from websites now).

Substantialgood4102 − NTA Emotional support animals are not the same as service animals. ESA are nothing more than pets. Service Animals provide a SERVICE for their owners. They are trained and certified. Stand your ground and don't let anyone try to persuade, guilt trip or manipulate you into allowing her to bring her dog. If she threatens to not come just say - we will miss you. The same goes for parents, siblings or any other flying monkeys that try coming at you.

No_Jeweler_7546 − It's one day? Yes it's YOUR DAY push through? Who wants itchy eyes in wedding photos NTAH

This story touches on the delicate balance between familial compassion and personal well-being. It challenges us to consider when and how to set necessary boundaries—even with loved ones—especially on a day as significant as a wedding. While maintaining a dog-free space might seem tough to those who view it as unsupportive, it is ultimately a measure to ensure a healthy, joyful celebration.

What would you do if your perfect day was threatened by an unexpected, uninvited element? Share your thoughts and experiences—how do you balance family expectations with personal needs on big life events?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *