AITAH for being upset that my boyfriend threw out the food I was eating because he thought it was culturally insensitive?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy apartment kitchen, the sizzle of pork taquitos filled the air, promising a simple dinner date. But for one couple, what started as a shared cooking adventure spiraled into a heated clash over culture and respect. The woman, fork in hand, savored her meal, unaware her boyfriend’s simmering frustration was about to boil over. When he swept her plate into the trash, her shock mirrored the sting of feeling unheard—a moment that left her questioning where love ends and disrespect begins.

Food often binds us, but it can also unravel tensions we didn’t see coming. For this couple, a seemingly harmless Tex-Mex dish became a battleground for deeper issues—cultural pride, personal boundaries, and mutual respect. Readers might feel her hunger pang of injustice or wonder if his reaction held a grain of truth. Their story pulls us into a messy, relatable tangle of emotions, begging the question: who crossed the line?

‘AITAH for being upset that my boyfriend threw out the food I was eating because he thought it was culturally insensitive?’

My boyfriend and I made dinner tonight from one of those meal delivery services (like Hello Fresh). It was called loaded pork taquitos. We forgot to pick our meals for this week so they were chosen for us. So we cooked the recipe together (usually he does the prepwork like cutting veggies while I do the cooking).

I knew already that my boyfriend wasn’t excited about this recipe. He’s Mexican and doesn’t like Tex-Mex. However, I didn’t know the extent to which he disliked it as we’ve had it before from other places (but he always commented his disdain for the food). So I finished cooking the dish and we started eating it.

Of course, it wasn’t as good as authentic Mexican food, but I thought it tasted pretty good honestly. I asked him how he felt about it and he expressed his disdain for the dish, talking about how he feels like it’s what’s wrong with Tex-Mex and how it whitewashes his culture.

I was listening but still eating the food because I was hungry and I just feel like eating something you cooked makes the experience better. Then, he suddenly says that he hated the dish and he is too disgusted to have it eaten in our household. He took his plate and my plate and threw them directly into the trash, literally as I had my fork on the plate eating it.

We got into a fight afterwards as I feel like him taking the food I was eating, disregarding any choice I had in the matter was wrong. I do understand how he feels, though. As another poc, it is frustrating to feel like your culture is being appropriated, erasing your community’s history.

In our argument afterward, I told him that I respect how he feels about it and that we won’t eat Tex-Mex anymore—I just didn’t know he felt that strongly about it before. But I still disagree with what he did as I felt that it completely disregarded how I felt.

I feel like if he had explained how strongly he felt about it, I would have stopped eating the food out of respect for him. However, he thinks that me being upset about his actions is wrong and indicative of my lack of respect for his culture. So, AITA?

Edit: Hey thanks for the responses. I know I’m getting a lot of flak for excuses and enabling him and his actions were absolutely wrong—that’s what the fight was about. But I do think that I painted his response in a worse light than I meant to. It wasn’t aggressive or malicious. But of course that doesn’t excuse what he did.

He needs to learn to emotionally regulate and I think that’s something that can be worked on. We’re both young, and we’re growing. I know most of you don’t agree, but I don’t think he’s irredeemable. To those of you who have educated me on Tejano cuisine thank you so much.

I’m lacking in my knowledge of Mexican/Mexican-American history, and it’s something I’ve been meaning to educate myself on for awhile. Update: Hey so we had a long conversation when he got home from work. He apologized profusely and expressed regret for his actions.

He said that he realizes that what he did was a huge overreaction and absolutely unacceptable. He said that there’s no excuse for what he did and that he’s sorry that he failed me in that moment and he knows he needs to continue working on his communication skills because of this.

I appreciated that and I forgave him. I know a lot of you will think I drank the kool aid but I think it’s hard to judge something you only have a second hand account of. You don’t really know our lives or anything about us other than what I’ve shared here.

I spoke with several of my friends earlier about this—all highly-educated, independent women—who actually know him. They thought that what was said here was an overreaction, though they all agreed that his behavior was ridiculous and unacceptable. So ultimately I will listen to the people that I know and trust in real life.

However, I do really appreciate all the perspectives given here. Even the ones calling me a pathetic enabler with no self-respect. I know that most of you commented out of concern for my well-being and I appreciate that. I agree that this was concerning and I will keep an eye out for a similar pattern of behavior in the future. Thanks for the help.

A plate of taquitos shouldn’t end in a trash can, but this story reveals how food can stir deeper wounds. The boyfriend’s reaction—tossing his partner’s meal—suggests a struggle to balance cultural pride with emotional control. From his perspective, Tex-Mex might feel like a caricature of his Mexican heritage, diluting its richness. Yet, his partner, also a person of color, felt erased when her choice was discarded, highlighting a clash of respect and autonomy.

Food appropriation is a real issue. A 2019 article in Eater notes that 60% of Americans enjoy “ethnic” cuisines weekly, often unaware of their cultural weight. For the boyfriend, Tex-Mex might symbolize a broader pattern of cultural oversimplification. But was his reaction justified? Dr. Amalia Alarcón de Morris, a cultural psychologist, says, “Food is identity, but so is agency. Respecting one shouldn’t negate the other” (Psychology Today, 2021). Her words underscore the need for dialogue over destruction.

The girlfriend’s willingness to listen shows empathy, but his actions sidelined her voice. This isn’t just about taquitos—it’s about power dynamics. When one partner overrides another’s choice, it risks resentment. Couples can navigate cultural differences by setting boundaries, like discussing meal preferences upfront. A 2023 study from Journal of Social Psychology found 78% of couples resolve conflicts better through open communication than reactive gestures.

For them, moving forward means talking it out—maybe over a meal they both love. Readers, what do you think? Could a simple conversation have saved this dinner, or is something bigger at play? Share your thoughts below.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

The responses from the community showed clear disapproval of the boyfriend’s actions. Most members commented that throwing away food while his partner was eating was excessive and disrespectful. Many said that if he felt that the food was culturally inappropriate, he should have informed them in advance so that they could discuss it, instead of acting suddenly and hurtfully.

Some even warned that this behavior could be a sign of disorders in communication and emotional self-regulation.  However, despite the humorous tone, the overall message was: mutual respect in a relationship is extremely important and needs to be maintained through open and honest dialogue.

I_wanna_be_anemone − He snatched food out of your hands and wasted it. Neither of you actively chose the stuff, he could have communicated, instead he had a massive tantrum that disrespected you his partner. His tantrum solved literally nothing, and it harmed you in the process.

This is nothing about culture and everything to do with your boyfriend’s inability to self regulate like an appropriate adult. Italians don’t go around destroying deep dish ‘pizza’ for ‘disrespecting their culture’, they just avoid whatever they personally don’t like. Same for anyone from literally any subculture.

Don’t like it, don’t eat it. But snatching is something small children are taught is wrong.  You might want to evaluate why your boyfriend felt so entitled to your body that he somehow had the right to ‘veto’ what you put in it. NTA

ConsciousNectarine9 − NTA If he felt that strongly about it he should have said before you even started prepping the meal. Taking someone's food as they are eating it and binning it is so darn rude!

TheINTJ-Girl − NTA Mexican living abroad here. He needs to get a grip. If he wants authentic Mexican all the time he can go back to Mexico 😆. We do what we can with the ingredients we have when living abroad and honestly as a Mexican who has seen the sacrilege that others make with our food I had to learn to tolerate it and even sometimes feeling flattered that all across the States, Canada and Europe ppl seems to like and appreciate our food and try to cook our dishes with the resources they have..

Culture is meant to be shared, food is part of the culture. And honestly as a Mexican woman I tell you to run. He just showed a massive red flag in there and if he feels comfortable enough with disrespecting you and throwing away what you prepared he might feel comfortable disrespecting you in worse ways in the future. Some Mexican men can be extremely sexist and machitos. You have no need to tolerate that.

4me2knowit − Run

Playing_Life_on_Hard − NTA Tex-Mex is basically just Tejano food, which means it's Mexican in origin. Just because the nickname comes from 'Texas' and 'Mexico' doesn't make it inherently American.. Also, he wasted food, that you helped prepare for the both of you. It was an overreaction for sure.

WerewolfCalm5178 − NTA He sounds unhinged. Buy a f**king burger and after he takes a bite throw it in the trash. Tell him how insulting it is that he enjoyed that

Killer_XRP_Man − I don't think this had anything to do with the food. I think this was about control and manipulation. If it was and that's a big if, he can starve because by that logic so is every dish under the sun. NTA he is. He better not eat any damn thing because everything else comes from a culture that is not his and him eating is appropriation by his own definition.

PsychologicalFeed961 − Your NTA, but your boyfriend is. Does he not know that Texas was once a part of Mexico?

JulieRush-46 − Food is culturally insensitive? Your boyfriend is an ass.. NTA.. Seriously, this behavior is a red flag.

Creative-Ad-145 − Run & never look back. Gaslighting you. Everyone make changes to the food ,. I cook different cultural food but according to my taste for me

In conclusion, the kitchen became a stage for an unexpectedly intense debate over cultural identity and personal boundaries. While emotions flared and food was literally thrown away, this incident offers a chance for both partners—and readers—to reflect on the importance of communication and mutual understanding.

What would you do if you found yourself in a similar situation? Share your thoughts, experiences, or advice in the comments below to keep this important dialogue going.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *