AITA for not checking on my friend after she dropped out of my wedding party?

The moments leading up to a wedding are often filled with excitement, planning, and the hope of sharing cherished milestones with your closest friends. When those you trust suddenly let you down, the pain can feel compounded by the stress of wedding preparations. In this story, the OP recounts how the departure of a bridesmaid—and the ensuing fallout—left her questioning the authenticity of a long-held friendship.

With plans in motion and expenses already on the line, the unexpected withdrawal of a friend over the cost of a dress struck a nerve. Coupled with confusing group chats and hurt feelings, the OP’s decision not to check on her friend afterward has sparked a firestorm of opinions, making her wonder if this was ever a true friendship—or simply an inconvenient relationship that was meant to end.

‘AITA for not checking on my friend after she dropped out of my wedding party?’

I was very excited to ask 2 of my girls who I see the most to be in my wedding party. Let's call them (Lisa & Shelley). They both said yes and it was great. But 3 months in (4 months before the wedding), Lisa said she couldn't afford it and was dropping out. I said it was alright but I was a bit hurt.

I had so far asked them to buy a dress that was around $100-$120, and had paid for drinks and food at the one meeting we've had. Lisa (& her bf) both work and make decent money, and pay low rent since I rented them a suite as I manage a building so I was confused that they couldn't afford it.. Shelley isn't working MUCH so I said I could help her pay for her dress if it would help.

After Lisa dropped out I asked Shelley if she was still ok doing it. Her & Lisa are very close also so I just wanted to be sure. She said she did and that was great. That same night on our group chat with the other 4 girls in the wedding party, Shelley started texting that it was crazy I expected them to pay $100 for a dress to be in the wedding and dropped out on the chat.

I was really hurt and felt confused why 2 of my closest friends who I have ALWAYS been there for, wouldn't step up to be a part of my wedding when I would do ANYTHING to be in theirs if they asked. As my wedding isn't far I needed to replace one of them soon and knew the perfect girl to do it, so I asked her the next day so she could have time to prepare etc.

She was SO happy, and said she'd be honored. I had wanted to ask her but we already had 6 people each, so I was happy that I got a chance to after what had happened. It honestly made the hurt of my 2

After about a week of nothing from Shelley I get a text message saying how awful it is that I didn't check on her to see how she was doing or to make sure she didn't want to do it before I replaced her.. I am absolutely FLOORED that she is angry with me about this!

She has since sent me messages saying how hurt she is and that she doesn't know me anymore and has started saying BAD things about my fiance to people they both know.. I don't even know if there is a friendship to salvage after this.. Am I the worst friend ever? Or is it normal that I'm thinking maybe she never was my friend?

Wedding planning can bring longstanding relationships under unexpected stress, and disagreements over financial contributions are more common than one might think. When monetary expectations clash with personal finances, even the closest friends may find themselves at a crossroads. In this case, the OP’s request for her friends to cover a modest expense—an investment in a dress—may have been seen as reasonable by some and overbearing by others. However, the reaction from her friend indicates that underlying expectations were misaligned from the very beginning.

Studies on interpersonal relationships suggest that when commitments are made, unmet obligations—especially those involving money—can quickly erode trust. Experts highlight that clear communication about responsibilities and financial boundaries is essential to sustain friendships during high-stress events like weddings.

According to relationship counselor Dr. Jenn Mann, “Disputes over money are among the most common triggers for conflicts in close relationships. Being upfront about expectations can prevent a lot of heartache later on.” Such insight reflects that what might seem like a minor financial request may carry deep implications about reliability and mutual support.

Moreover, the issue here goes beyond finances to touch on themes of respect, reciprocity, and perceived loyalty. When a friend publicly complains about an expense after having already accepted the invitation, it creates a double standard that leaves the host feeling hurt and unvalued.

Recognized experts advise that in such circumstances, maintaining a transparent dialogue can reveal whether the conflict stems from genuine financial struggles or is simply a pretext for an emerging imbalance in the relationship. As the wedding date approaches, the urgency of these decisions highlights the role of personal boundaries in preserving one’s own emotional well-being while ensuring that relationships remain healthy and mutually beneficial.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

The Reddit community has weighed in strongly on the situation. Many users condemn the friend’s behavior as an act of entitlement and narcissistic pettiness, arguing that the OP’s expectations were entirely reasonable. The consensus is that if someone drops out and then complains about not being checked on—even after clearly backing out—it reveals more about their character than about the host’s actions. Others emphasize that the financial commitment was modest and that the friend’s refusal to engage in open, honest dialogue only fuels the existing tension.

Flimsy-Car-7926 − NTA. $100 is super reasonable for a bridesmaids dress. And what where you supposed to be checking on her about? Like honestly? It's YOUR wedding. She dropped out. You didn't have to double check ANYTHING. Some people really do think the entire universe revolves around them. You're good. I'd be cutting off someone bad mouthing me and my fiance. 

Clean_Factor9673 − These girls aren't your friends. Raise Lisa's rent to market rate, she was using you for housing.

Scenarioing −  

Why would you do either of those? Why would you wait around on getting a replacement when the date is just around the corner? What a weirdo.. She's not going to the wedding is she? NTA.

hardboiledegg2024 − NTA. Are you sure Lisa is your friend and not just there to get low rent from you? If she’s not even willing to spend $100 on your big day, idk if I’ll call her your “closest friend”. Also, Shelley comes across as throwing a tantrum in an attempt to get you to offer to pay and not having to fork out anything.. NTA OP, but choose your friends better…

Dependent-Union4802 − They are bad friends. Everybody knows you have to buy a dress to be a bridesmaid. They should never have accepted in the first place

AppeltjeEitje1079 − NTA, I don't understand why she would expect you to? She dropped out of the wedding after being snarky about the 100 for the dress (very reasonable btw). They sound like awful friends, block them, not worth stressing over!

petsymatary − I had a friend drop off out my wedding *the day before* telling me that he couldn’t afford to take time off work bc he was looking to move to my city so he needed the good reference from his current job.. Guess who hasn’t moved to my city and guess who I haven’t talked too since? I wouldn’t ever talk to those girls again. Them being close and both dropping out seems like too much of a coincidence.. NTA.

imamage_fightme − The sheer level of narcissistic pettiness from your 'friend' is off the charts. NTA. Was she seriously expecting you to beg her to be your bridesmaid? You had asked her, she accepted, then drops out - I feel like if you had pushed for her to stay on, she'd complain that you're expecting too much!

This feels like a power move where you couldn't win no matter what you do - even if you'd paid for the dress, she'd probably make it a thing with the other bridesmaids that you didn't pay for theirs, and then the next thing you know you're spending another $2000 covering all the bridesmaids and groomsmen attire to make it fair. Nightmare. This girl is stirring s**t for no reason and she isn't your friend.

Royal-Principle6138 − I don’t understand why any bridesmaid have to pay for their own dresses when I got married I paid for dresses and suit hire

OldMetalHead − NTA - Now you know who they really are. Sometimes you just have to let the trash take itself out. Congrats on your wedding.

In the end, the fallout from the wedding party drama raises fundamental questions about what it means to be a friend. The OP’s decision not to check on a friend who had already withdrawn, and who later resorted to disparaging remarks behind her back, appears less about neglect and more about self-preservation.

When financial expectations and personal loyalty collide during one of life’s most significant celebrations, it’s crucial to reflect on whether the bonds of friendship are built to last under pressure. What do you think—should the host have reached out, or was it time to let go? Share your thoughts and experiences; let’s discuss how we navigate the complexities of friendship when stakes are high.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *