AITA for not letting my friends use my backyard for their wedding because they do not want me to bring a “plus one?”

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 1 Comment

On a warm spring afternoon, as the echoes of laughter and childhood memories mingle with the promise of new beginnings, an unexpected conflict has arisen. The man who now owns his grandparents’ cherished home faces a dilemma as he readies the venue for a long-anticipated wedding. The property, blessed with a picturesque lake and charming gazebo, has always been a sanctuary for heartfelt gatherings.

Yet this celebration of love has taken a dramatic turn. A demand has surfaced: he must attend the wedding without a plus one, all because of complications linked to a turbulent past relationship. This requirement has not only put his personal choices in question but has also stirred tensions among lifelong friends, leaving everyone wondering if some boundaries should remain inviolate.

‘AITA for not letting my friends use my backyard for their wedding because they do not want me to bring a “plus one?”?’

Here is the situation. Last summer, I bought my grandparents' house. This house was the hangout spot for my friends and I throughtout our childhood. This includes my friend

But, going through the process of getting approved to buy, I found out that she has massive amounts of credit card and personal debt that she hide from me throughout our four years together. I decided to breakup as a result. That was about six months ago. I met Leslie because Dave's long-term girlfriend (

Dave and Kim are engaged and set to get married in April. When I was buying the house, they asked if they could have the ceremony at the gazebo, which I agreed to do. In December, I started dating again. Leslie has not taken this well at all. She thinks we are going to get back together and has tried multiple times to make that happen.

I have told her in no uncertain terms that isn't happening. Dave and Kim have asked me to not bring a plus-one to the wedding for

If that is the case, then they need to find a new venue for the wedding. They are pissed about this given the short time frame of when the wedding is supposed ot happen. So, we are at an impasse.. AITA?. **Edit** **I have seen a few things brought up a number of times in the comments, so I will quickly address them here:**

1. **I am fully aware of the liability issues, which is why I purchased, and they reimbursed me for a

2. **The wedding will have a maximum, if every comes, of 75 guests, 5 catering staff, and 5 security staff (the security is because this is an open area that anyone walking past can access). The house has hosted events twice this size and logistically it has been fine. On the property are two cottages, one with one bathroom and the other with two bathrooms.

he only portion of my house that will not be locked during the wedding is the finished basement. The basement has two bathrooms.** 3. **Every person who is single (ie. not in an established relationship) received an invitation with a plus-one, including me and Leslie. This talk came after I sent in my return card and indicated I was bringing a plus-one.

Now, they are saying they do not want me to have the plus-one because Leslie blew up about it and they are afraid of a blowup at the wedding.** 4. **Leslie indicated she intends to bring someone on her card. I do not know if she will actually bring someone.**

The OP’s dropped an update on the saga—curious? Click here to check it out!

Letting your partner meet your family can feel like a monumental step in a relationship, yet hosting a wedding on your own property brings its own set of challenges. In this case, the host must balance family legacy, personal freedom, and the expectations of those he cares about. His generous offer to host the celebration now clashes with the constraints imposed by others, turning a proud moment into a potential source of future regret.

Analyzing the heart of the matter, it’s clear that the host stands at a crossroads between upholding his rights as a homeowner and appeasing his friends’ concerns over potential drama. His decision not to allow a plus one appears rooted in past relationship scars, yet it also reflects the ongoing struggle to assert personal boundaries. The conflicting requests raise questions about loyalty, entitlement, and the inherent complications of shared histories among friends.

Broader issues come to light when evaluating how personal pasts can intrude on public celebrations. Social dynamics often force individuals to sacrifice personal happiness for group harmony.

As noted by renowned relationship expert Dr. John Gottman—who observes, “The way couples manage conflict is more important than the conflict itself”—this instance underscores the importance of clear, respectful communication when personal relationships intermingle with group obligations. His insights, available on his website at gottman.com, remind us that refusing to compromise sometimes preserves one’s integrity, even at the cost of strained friendships.

With the stakes this high, some sensible advice emerges. In situations where personal history complicates social events, setting clear boundaries from the outset is crucial. The host might consider reiterating his reasons in a calm, collected manner or even suggesting alternative arrangements for those who prefer a drama-free celebration. Ultimately, prioritizing his peace of mind and maintaining honest communication could pave the way for resolution, even if it means a temporary rift among old friends.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

The Reddit community has been quick to weigh in with their hot takes, blending humor and direct commentary. Some suggest an “Uno Reverse” move that turns the tables, while others insist that personal property rights trump external demands. These opinions, as varied as they are candid, reflect the complexities of balancing generosity with self-respect and invite readers to ponder how they might handle similar challenges.

ItWorkedInMyHead − Pull an Uno Reverse. Tell them Leslie isn't allowed on your property and watch their heads explode.

Not-a-Cranky-Panda − They want to tell you who you can have at your own home and think is is fine, they're nuts.

ConsistentDepth4157 − Ask them why they think Leslie is welcome on your property

6poundpuppy − NTAH. Well….. you have 4 choices. 1. Deny them the wedding on your property (unless they “let” you have a date) 2. Allow the wedding and don’t have a date. 3. Allow the wedding and bring your date regardless of their wishes. 4. Allow the wedding if they don’t invite Leslie. Choice is yours entirely. You’ll likely lose the friendship no matter what you do at this point, so just do what makes YOU happy.

gotsmoxie − Wait- it is a “so let me use your land, gazebo, house, and lake to make our wedding happen, but you are not allowed to bring a date because of your ex-girlfriend” request! Not to mention the fact that your land will be trampled on, possibly driven on, partied on, the lake may be used for many interesting or and n**arious deeds.

And you may be responsible for all the people that show up because you own the land and the liability for damages or for personal injury may be on your home insurance? Heck NAW, NTA! That is some bs there!

chaingun_samurai − People who are benefiting from the generosity of others do not get to place demands.

Ginger8682 − First things first. Have an attorney draft an agreement or waiver between you and the marrying couple, that of anyone gets hurt on your property or if any damage is done to the property the couple is responsible for it not you and your homeowners insurance.. Secondly, it’s your house do as you please.

mcindy28 − NTA Stand your ground and die on this hill!! The entitlement is real ... YOU BETTER BRING A DATE!! Or they can find another venue.. Question... Are they even paying you?? And don't bring a gift even if they are.

PrairieGrrl5263 − NTA. None of this is on you, OP. Having Leslie as a guest at the home where she was going to be a co-owner is enough of a sticky wicket. Attending a wedding at the home of your ex has got to be aaawk-ward, especially since it's Leslie's own stupidity and deceit that caused the breakup.

Seriously, a plus one for you would be the least of Leslie's problems. You're not wrong for taking the stand you are, OP; just know this may be the end of these friendships.

Toffor − your problem may be bigger than just this wedding. I've been in a similar-ish situation where an ex and I shared (part of) a social circle. Once she established with our shared friends that my presence was upsetting to her, I found myself iced out of almost all events.

Because when she saw that she could dictate if I was invited or not to an event by her acceptance or refusal, she starting going to EVERYTHING (and I was invited to almost nothing). I'd nip this in the bud right now if I were you. I was iced out for about a year until people started to realize how unfair it was.

In conclusion, this story exemplifies the delicate balancing act between personal rights and the expectations of long-standing friendships. With a wedding set against the backdrop of cherished memories and potential past resentments, it raises important questions about boundaries, respect, and compromise.

What do you think—would you stand your ground on your own property or bend to avoid conflict? Share your thoughts and experiences, and let the conversation begin.

For those who want to read the sequel: UPDATE: AITA for not letting my friends use my backyard for their wedding because they do not want me to bring a “plus one?” 

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One Comment

  1. Pingback: UPDATE: AITA for not letting my friends use my backyard for their wedding because they do not want me to bring a "plus one?" - Movies & TV update: News, Reviews and Trending