AITA for telling my dad and stepmom they never should have put the inclusion of my siblings by my maternal family on me?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A young girl’s heart aches as she navigates a family torn between love and loyalty. At 17, she’s caught in a tug-of-war between her late mother’s vibrant family and the new life her father built with her stepmother. Picture a cozy living room, where old photo albums filled with her mom’s smile sit tucked away, while her half-siblings’ toys spill across the floor—a blend of past and present that doesn’t quite fit. Her maternal grandparents, once her daily refuge, now feel like a distant treasure she’s fighting to keep.

The tension simmers as her dad and stepmom urge her to bridge the gap, piling grown-up expectations on her teenage shoulders. It’s a story of grief, identity, and the weight of family ties, leaving readers wondering: how do you balance love when it pulls you in two directions?

‘AITA for telling my dad and stepmom they never should have put the inclusion of my siblings by my maternal family on me?’

My mom died when I (17f) was 4 and my dad remarried when I was 7. I also met my stepmom when I was 7. I went from spending every day at someone in my maternal family's house to staying home with my stepmom. I missed my maternal family.

My grandparents had me most days but I also spent time between an aunt and an uncle who lived close by to us too and each would take turns having me as well. I missed not seeing them every day. Then there was some tension between my dad, stepmom and my maternal family. It was over my dad wanting me to call my stepmom 'mom' and wanting her to adopt me.

He wanted my maternal family to get on board and encourage me to accept that. I was never adopted. Then when my stepmom had my half brother a year later the tension ran deeper because they didn't treat my half brother like a grandchild. To be honest they didn't even meet him. He wasn't a part of their family and I knew that.

My dad and stepmom expected that. When it was clear my maternal family weren't going to include my younger half siblings they wanted me not to see them at all. I cried when my dad told me so they changed their mind. But for years they would tell me how much my half siblings feelings would be hurt that my family wouldn't accept them.

They asked me if I really loved my half siblings, if I really hated them, and then asked why I wouldn't insist we're all the same and if I'm loved they should be too. It was a lot. For a while my half siblings would cry when I'd go to see my family and not take them with me.

My stepmom told me it upset her that I wasn't the big sister who would make sure we were all treated the same. She also told me love shouldn't be conditional on blood and that I don't love her any less for being my non-biological mom. I told her I didn't love her like my mom.

That I felt differently about her. She got mad and told me she was the only mom I knew and how it hurt her feelings and made her want to give up if she was always going to be stepmom. Talking directly to her I use her name, when talking about her I say stepmom, never mom. The oldest two of my half siblings understand now why I have family they don't.

The younger ones still cry and get upset when I see them and they can't come. My dad and stepmom still tell me how I should put my siblings feelings first. I told them the last time they said it that they never should have put that on me, a kid, and they should never have attempted to make that come between me and my family.

My dad told me I need to understand where they're coming from and they had six kids total to think about, not just one while the other five were told to go f**k off. He told me I should have been a better sister to them. My stepmom said I should respect them more as parents.. AITA?

Family dynamics can feel like walking a tightrope, especially when grief and new relationships collide. This teen’s story highlights the messy reality of blended families, where good intentions sometimes lead to emotional missteps. Her father and stepmother’s push for unity clashed with her need to preserve her mother’s memory, creating a rift that’s all too common.

The teen’s situation reflects a classic challenge: balancing loyalty to one’s roots with new family ties. Her maternal family’s distance from her half-siblings isn’t rejection—it’s a natural boundary, as they’re not biologically or emotionally connected. Meanwhile, her dad and stepmom’s insistence that she “fix” this dynamic placed an unfair burden on a child. As Dr. Joshua Coleman, a family therapist, notes in a 2023 article on Psychology Today, “Children shouldn’t be mediators in adult conflicts. Expecting them to unify a blended family can erode trust and autonomy.” This rings true here—the teen’s emotional honesty was met with guilt trips, not understanding.

This scenario ties to a broader issue: blended families often struggle with unclear roles. A 2021 study from the Journal of Family Issues found that 40% of step-parents report tension over differing expectations, especially when stepchildren are old enough to remember a deceased parent. The teen’s refusal to call her stepmom “mom” isn’t rebellion; it’s a way to honor her late mother’s unique place in her heart. Her parents’ push for a one-size-fits-all family ignored her grief, which needed space to breathe.

Dr. Coleman’s advice offers a path forward: “Validate the child’s feelings and let relationships evolve naturally.” For the teen, this means her dad and stepmom could acknowledge her maternal ties without demanding she reshape them. Open conversations—perhaps with a family counselor—could help her half-siblings understand why her family connections differ, reducing their hurt. The parents might also reflect on their own family ties, like the stepmom’s relatives, to share the load of inclusion.

Ultimately, the teen’s courage to speak up deserves applause. Readers, what do you think—how can families blend without erasing what came before? Share your thoughts below!

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit’s got some spicy takes on this family drama, served with a side of wit and wisdom. Here’s what the community had to say:

Trespassingw − NTA. It's cruel to prohibit child's relationship with her loved relatives. Why don't they involve SM's relatives for her kids. It's heartbreaking to read all these stories about kids pressured into

74Magick − Why is this such a common occurrence? Complete nonsense.. NTA of course.

Visual-Lobster6625 − NTA - 99% of the stories I see on Reddit regarding kids, step parents, and half-siblings happens when relationships are forced. You were 7 when your mom passed away, you would still have some memories of her. Those don't get erased because she's gone. Your dad and stepmom trying to replace your mother was wrong.

They should have focussed on building a friendship between you and your stepmom first. Her insisting on the title of

The older ones understand because they're old enough to understand you had a different mom. Your dad and stepmom are the only ones making the kids sad, it's entirely their fault because they don't explain that you have a different family from them.

sfrancisch5842 − Ask you dad how would he feel, if he was the one who died, and your mom remarried and her new husband adopted you, essentially wiping away any memory of him? Would HE want his family, his parents, to embrace a “replacement”?. He is fucked up if the answer is yes. OP, NTA. You had a mom. You loved her and love your memories of her and of your family on her side. There is NOTHING wrong with that.

I_have__no__idea_ − NTA Sound like pure emotional blackmail. I might be wrong but is there any possibility that they're trying to get free childcare off them? If you spent so much time with them when you were younger, they might have hoped that your maternal family would take them too? Either way, what they are doing is wrong.

It also sounds like your father and stepmom are somewhat trying to erase your mother, so naturally they would not be on the best of terms with your maternal family. Your younger siblings will, like the oldest, learn why you have other family and they will understand,

them crying is probably highly fed by your stepmom and dad pretty much telling to be sad, their parents are saying that you're leaving to be with people that don't love them, they don't know why they have to be sad, but their parents are telling them to be, so in their minds, they must be. I understand that it might be difficult right now, but unfortunately,

I think the best solution is to just wait this one out, once your siblings learn what is actually happening and don't care, your dad and stepmom will have nothing else to emotionally blackmail you with. Also, quick question, what is the situation with your stepmom's family?

Are they in the picture at all? And if so, what is your relationship with them like? (I do not mean any of this accusatorily, I am just curious, because if they're not in the picture it may explain, but still not excuse, some of their behavior). (Edited for spelling error)

Interesting_You_2315 − NTA. My oldest sister passed young and her husband remarried before her body was cold. It broke our hearts to have to include the new stepchildren. It was include them or not see our niblings again. We didn't want to hurt the other kids but they were not related to us. And we didn't like seeing our loved one replaced.

whowasthatreally − NTA. This is not fair. They are interfering with your relationship with your blood relatives, and trying to guilt you into doing what they want. You are standing up for yourself, good for you!

FractionofaFraction − NTA. Yet another case of parent and step parent dismissing the emotions and preferences of a child. I'm guessing you're planning on seeing your maternal family a lot more and your dad / step-mom / half siblings a lot less once you move out?

camkats − Your dad and stepmom are AH. You are NTA. For them to try to manipulate you this way is disgusting. Stick to your guns and keep relationships with your mom’s family strong.

Opposite_Community11 − Why would your mother's family want anything to do with your step siblings who are no relation to them? I know I wouldn't.. Don't they have their own maternal and paternal grandparents?. NTA. Your father and stepmother are crazy.

These opinions are straight from the Reddit hive mind, but do they capture the full picture? Maybe there’s more to unpack—what’s your take?

This teen’s story reminds us that family isn’t just about shared dinners—it’s about respecting each person’s heartstrings, even when they tug in different directions. Her stand against unfair expectations shows strength, but it also opens the door for healing if her parents listen. What would you do if you were caught between honoring your past and embracing a new family? Drop your thoughts below—let’s keep this conversation going!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *