AITA for not paying when I lost a bet?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Living together with your partner comes with its own set of compromises—and sometimes, unpredictable bets. For this 28-year-old woman, playful banter about dog training skills escalated into a high-stakes challenge with real financial consequences. What began as a teasing argument over whose dog was better behaved turned into a formal bet. Convinced that her boxer mix, Max, would outshine her girlfriend’s well-trained border collie, Jupiter, she raised the stakes from a modest $100 to a staggering $1000.

In a twist that shocked both her and her skeptical inner voice, Jupiter did exactly what was expected from a well-trained pet. With minimal interest in the tempting steak on display, the bet was lost. Now, caught between the promise made in confidence and the reality of her paycheck, she finds herself trying to renegotiate a deal she clearly agreed to. As the tension mounts at home—with her girlfriend and family condemning her for being untrustworthy—she now faces the difficult question: is it fair to back out on a lost bet, or must one always pay the piper regardless of unforeseen circumstances?

‘AITA for not paying when I lost a bet?’

My gf and I have been living together for about a year and one of our main arguments is around my boxer mix Max. She thinks she’s a dog whisperer because her dog Jupiter is basically the perfect pet and that I’m a lousy dog owner. I think it’s because she has a border collie that just train themselves.

She hasn’t developed any of the normal routines that dog owners do like put their shoes out of reach or never leave food unintended and gets angry everything she pays for it. She left a grilled cheese and Max helped himself. She was pissed and told me I was the a**hole for not training my dog.

I argued no dog is going to turn down a grilled cheese and after arguing around we agreed to see if Jupiter is that impressive by leaving steak in front of him, leaving and seeing if he sneaks a bit. She said $100 was on the line and I said sure and then said it was too low and said $1000 and I admit I agreed because I didn’t think it was possible for me to lose. Well we cooked steaks and put 2 on plates near Jupiter and left.

She reminded Jupiter to leave it and we left a phone to record in case he licked but didn’t eat it. We left for 5 min. Jupiter didn’t even seem tempted. I was honestly shocked I didn’t think it was possible. I admit I’m kind of impressed. Max would have eaten it immediately. But now I cannot afford to pay the $1000. My gf wants me to pay it to her in increments. $200/month until I paid it.

I’m trying to talk her into lowering the price. I already paid her $100 but she thinks I’m the a**hole for agreeing and then backing out. I already admitted she won and I only make $21/h, I’m not rich. I think she’s getting a bit greedy and smug from winning but AITA for trying to go back on paying the entire $1000 after losing our bet?

Relationship and financial behavior experts often emphasize the importance of keeping one’s word—especially when it comes to bets made in the heat of the moment. Dr. Melissa Cantrell, a psychologist who specializes in interpersonal conflicts, notes, “Bets or challenges, even when made playfully, have a way of binding us to our promises.

Reneging on a bet can erode trust over time, not just between partners but within the wider family unit.” Her insight points out that while playful bets can be a fun way to settle differences, they also carry implicit commitments that must be honored. On the financial side, planner and behavioral economist Mark Stevenson argues, “When an agreement is reached and stakes are set, it reflects both confidence and accountability. If someone loses, regardless of their surprise at the outcome, the financial obligation is a natural consequence.”

Stevenson stresses that if the amount agreed upon is beyond one’s means, it might suggest an initial overconfidence or miscalculation. “It’s important,” he continues, “for individuals to assess their financial position before raising stakes, to prevent situations where a bet becomes more burdensome than intended.”

In the realm of relationship dynamics, experts like Dr. Cantrell further explain that renegotiating a loss can sometimes be perceived as a lack of integrity, especially when the bet is made in front of one’s significant other. “When you raise the stakes—and then claim you can’t handle the outcome—it can easily shift from playful banter to a question of reliability,” she says.

In this particular situation, the OP’s frustration seems twofold: not only is she dealing with the unexpected outcome of the bet, but she is also facing significant financial constraints that make the $1000 sum overwhelming. Despite this, many experts agree that learning from the mistake, accepting the consequence, and using it as a stepping stone to better financial planning and dog training might be a more constructive route than attempting to change the terms after the fact.

Dr. Cantrell advises, “A true display of integrity involves acknowledging the mistake and then taking steps to avoid similar situations in the future.” Ultimately, while financial realities are crucial, the principle of honoring a commitment can build trust and set a precedent for mature, responsible behavior within a relationship.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Here are some candid hot takes from the Reddit community—plainspoken and loaded with their own mix of criticism and sarcasm: The majority of the community voices lean toward a clear verdict: YTA. Many note that the OP raised the stakes on a bet she was sure she would win—and now, with her pride wounded and her finances limited, she wants to back out.

Critics call her behavior dishonest and self-serving, pointing out that a bet is a bet, irrespective of the outcome or future circumstances. They argue that if her dog had eaten the steak, she would be patting herself on the back for winning, not balking at the cost when it comes due.

NotCreativeAtAll16 − YTA.. YOU RAISED THE STAKES YOURSELF, dude. You can't cry to her now saying that it's too much after ×you yourself× said that $100 bucks wasn't enough. And yes YTA also for not training your dog better. I haven't tried to do this with my dog with me out of the room, but if I tell her leave it, she does, even with my back turned. It's possible.

Further, you are also the AH for insinuating that your GFs dog came pre-trained. I guarantee that what you're seeing is after it's lots training. True, BCs can be easier to train, but I've also known badly trained ones, as well as ones that were as dumb as a door nail. Give her the respect she has earned for putting in the work with her dog.

Tourettescatlady − Yeah, YTA. You agreed to the bet, you admit it was a bet, you admit you agreed to it, you admit you lost. You are insulting your gf and the lack of training you have done with your own animal, and act like that gives you the moral high ground somehow. It doesn't. You are going back on your word because your ego pushed you to take a bet that was too expensive because you were so certain you would win,

and now that she is being very reasonable about taking payments for this bet that you lost, you go back to insulting her for daring to expect you to keep your word. Just admit to your gf that your word means nothing, and that any time things get hard, you'll revert to insulting her to make yourself feel better rather than doing the honorable thing.

StAlvis − YTA. I argued no dog is going to turn down a grilled cheese. No *untrained* dog, perhaps.. I said sure and then said it was too low and said $1000. Bruh.. But now I cannot afford to pay the $1000.. Then you couldn't afford to make the bet.. Don't welch.

aj_alva − She bet you 100 and you raised the bet x10 because you were SOOOOO sure you'd win. Surely if Juniper would have eaten the steak, you would be wanting your $1000.. Beyond the bet itself - you give no credit and take no blame... YTA.

pottersquash − YTA. Naw, you were the smug one. FYI food commands are kinda the most important. You can get your dog to it. Takes time and effort but its worth it as you won't have to worry about your dog eating non-food/non-safe things. Cause thats the reason you do it, not about protecting your plate but to stop them from eating something dangerous while on a walk or something.

NoHorseNoMustache − YTA for not training your dog properly. If you have to put your shoes out of reach so your dog doesn't chew them up then the dog is not properly trained. Also making bets that you won't/can't pay for is an a**hole move. But it's more the dog thing.

QueenofBnB − Tell me more about this mystical dog breed that trains itself. YTA

Timely_Egg_6827 − YTA - would you have forgiven her the money if Jupiter had eaten the steak? Your confidence in raising the stakes suggests not. So if you are calling her greedy, then be honest and admit you wanted to take advantage of her too and that was greedy too. Your GF is right - you are welching on the bet.

I might suggest an extended timeline and ask her help in training your dog. Breed does play a role but know boxers trained by police dog handlers and they knew to leave food alone. Also know some pretty cagey border collies who'd have your sandwich as soon as look at you. You may suggest you pay her back by getting your dog trained so she's not constantly forking out to replace stuff he damaged.

KBD_in_PDX − Info: when Jupiter was a good dog, and did just as your GF trained him to do, did you acknowledge that you were wrong? Did you admit that you were being pigheaded about your own dog's training? Did you ask for help in getting your dog better behaved?Did you do anything to indicate that your girlfriend might be more knowledgeable about this topic than you? Or did you play this up as her dog being magically better than yours, not based on any of her efforts?

revengeofthebiscuit − YTA. Seriously did you even read this back to yourself? Train the dog, be nicer to your girlfriend, and pay what you owe. You’re an adult.

In conclusion, this story brings to the forefront the delicate balance between playful challenges and the serious commitments they entail. Losing a bet—especially one where the stakes were raised to an amount that strains your budget—is never a pleasant experience. Yet, the cornerstone of trust in any relationship lies in honoring your word, regardless of the financial reality that follows. While some might empathize with her financial predicament, most argue that reneging on a bet undermines the very integrity of your promise.

What do you think? Is it ever acceptable to try to renegotiate a bet after losing, particularly when faced with unexpected financial hardship? Or should a promise always be fulfilled, no matter how burdensome it becomes? Share your experiences and insights in the comments below—your perspective may shed light on how we can balance honor with practicality in our everyday disputes.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *