Roommate Tries to Sue Pregnant Woman Over Her Lease, Forgets They Are Both Lawyers

She thought sharing an apartment with a close friend would be easy; she was dead wrong. For one expectant mother, her pregnancy announcement turned her cozy shared apartment into a high-stakes legal battleground. Instead of celebrating, her roommate weaponized past personal trauma to demand the impossible, leading to a cold war of missing kitchen appliances, swapped picture frames, and hostile silence.

What started as a tense domestic standoff quickly escalated into a bizarre war of legal threats and dramatic emails. But the roommate made one critical mistake: she forgot who she was dealing with. This wasn’t just an ordinary roommate dispute—it was a clash between two trained legal minds. Curious how this high-stress domestic dispute unfolded? The full story is right below.

Roommate Tries to Sue Pregnant Woman Over Her Lease, Forgets They Are Both Lawyers

UPDATE: AITAH for getting pregnant without considering my roommate’s feelings

We have all been there—trying to balance sensitivity to a friend’s past pain while navigating our own major life milestones. However, when empathy is met with hostility, maintaining boundaries becomes essential for survival.

A few months ago, I made a post about my living situation.

Now that my lease has ended, I thought an update was warranted.

First, a little more background on my roommate.

She and I were friends for about a year before we decided to live together.

The pregnancy-related trauma I mentioned in my earlier post was her getting an abortion two years ago because she decided she did not want to have a child with her...

She was open about this happening—she told me about her abortion the literal day that I met her.

We also had a mutual friend who was trying to conceive with her husband at the time I got pregnant.

This mutual friend would openly talk about her attempts to get pregnant, including a miscarriage, with my roommate, and my roommate appeared to have zero issues discussing these topics with...

ADVERTISEMENT

Now onto what happened next.

I took the advice of a lot of you (and my IRL friends) and told my roommate via text (to have it in writing) that I would not be leaving...

In response, she said, '👍,' which viewers of RHOSLC will recognize as a Gen Z 'f*** you.' After I stood my ground, things at the apartment were tense.

ADVERTISEMENT

I spoke to her in person only once more, when I asked if she would move her car so I could put our trash bins out.

She said she would do it and then didn't, leaving me to scramble to get the bins out in time the next morning.

She also routinely had guests over—in particular, one former friend of mine that I had a falling out with (unrelated to roommate) to antagonize me.

ADVERTISEMENT

She also replaced all the pictures of us in the apartment with pictures of her and this former friend.

I’ll admit that I was petty too.

I took my microwave and toaster out of the kitchen and put up a single ultrasound picture in a common area (but I removed it after two days since I...

ADVERTISEMENT

In general, though, I stayed in my room 99% of the time I was in the apartment and did not see or speak to her again after early April.

I completely stopped using the kitchen and common areas.

Even when I had my mom visit, she and I would spend all our time locked in my room.

ADVERTISEMENT

A dramatic exit often reveals the true depth of a domestic rift, transforming a quiet cold war into a messy, physical departure. When shared responsibilities are abandoned, the remaining tenant is left to clean up the physical and financial wreckage.

Unexpectedly and without telling me, my roommate moved out on May 8th.

She took several of my things, blocked me in the driveway for hours, and refused to reimburse me for the couch we had bought together and utilities she still owed...

ADVERTISEMENT

When I asked her to reimburse me for these things over text, she said that she would not be paying me anything because I had 'bullied her out of the...

I had never asked her not to bring certain people over and did not consider my taking the microwave and toaster away 'bullying' anymore than I considered her putting up...

Despite taking several things that belonged to me, she was kind enough to leave her side of the fridge full of rotten food, leave trash strewn all over her old...

ADVERTISEMENT

Surprisingly, she paid rent for the month of June.

Prior to her moving out and this conflict arising, another mutual friend (though he was primarily my friend, to be fair) had asked if he could stay with us on...

Both of us had said yes and planned to let him stay in our spare room.

ADVERTISEMENT

After my roommate moved out and had been out for over a month, my friend came to stay.

Since my roommate had had the master bedroom and bathroom (and paid the same as me in rent, by the way), I set up an air mattress in her old...

The spare room was on the other end of the apartment from the bathrooms and was adjacent to the kitchen, so I thought setting him up in my roommate's old...

ADVERTISEMENT

As he was a guest, I didn’t charge him any rent or utilities; I just let him stay because I appreciated the company.

Two weeks before our lease ended and well over a month after she had moved out, my roommate and her dad used a spare key to re-enter the apartment.

My friend was there at the time, but I wasn’t.

ADVERTISEMENT

She told my friend she and her dad were there to 'patch holes in the wall' but left after only a few minutes without making any effort to repair the...

Instead, she sent an email to the landlord alleging that I was violating our lease by illegally subletting her room and demanding that I reimburse her for rent.

My landlord was thankfully a rational person who also thought my roommate was crazy and told her that any dispute was between the two of us and he would not...

ADVERTISEMENT

Nothing ends an empty legal bluff faster than a well-constructed reality check from someone who actually knows the law. When professional credentials are weaponized to intimidate, a precise understanding of tenant rights becomes the ultimate defense.

Shortly after the landlord politely told her to get f***, she emailed me, CCing her parents (she is a 28-year-old practicing attorney, by the way) alleging that I had failed...

ADVERTISEMENT

I read through the lease and saw that it did not proscribe guests but did limit occupancy to two adults (not lessees) at one time.

A violation of this portion of the lease entitled the landlord to raise the rent, but did not entitle the co-lessees to any liquidated damages for the breach.

I wrote her a very strongly worded email in which I detailed that I had not broken our lease, she had suffered no damages, my friend was not trespassing nor...

ADVERTISEMENT

I also included texts of her agreeing to reimburse me for the couch, admitting that her dog had destroyed the property, and giving me permission (though again this was not...

Finally, I defined reproductive coercion and abuse for her and told her that her actions were essentially an attempt to coerce me into an abortion and then abusing me financially...

I told her not to contact me again and that she was welcome to take me to small claims court and explain to a judge why she had moved out...

ADVERTISEMENT

Since then, she’s been silent.

I moved out last weekend and asked the landlord to split our deposit in half, which he agreed to.

My pregnancy is progressing well and I’m nearly halfway through! And it seems like this saga is finally over, fingers crossed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Community Opinions

The community was overwhelmingly supportive of the expectant mother, with many pointing out the sheer irony of a practicing lawyer getting out-lawyered.

u/MistyFlowersi NTA. she really thought she could pull the "i'm a lawyer" card on another lawyer and win lmao. good for you for standing your ground and protecting your peace....

u/Life-Wealth-3399
Please, please tell me when you replied to her email you reply all so her parents can see what she is doing, please tell me you did that.

u/ReceptionPuzzled1579 She’s an idiot and you are too nice. I would have taken the entire deposit, her part being reimbursement for unpaid utilities and the couch since you had evidence...

u/SadFlatworm1436
NTA but I love that you buried “entitled cúnt” in the TL;DR

u/ER_Support_Plant17 What does she do when she sees random pregnant people in her daily life? At the grocery? At the drugstore, etc. They are EVERYWHERE! Also how would she of...

u/Beginning-Fun6616
No damage deduction for the holes made by the ex-roommate?

u/Sparklingwine23
This story is even more wild knowing that she is an attorney.
Glad youre in a much better place amd congratulations!

u/subjectfemale
Damn boo hopefully you can rest easier now.
Really ticked off that she got so much from you and still wanted more.
Evil b

u/RamenNoodles620
Well done. Did her parents ever say anything? Her including them in this was pretty funny.

u/AZDarkknight
Im assuming she didnt have any deposit left as that would have been required for the repairs to the property?

u/Cheeseballfondue
I love the lawyer-on-lawyer Sternly Worded Letters in this story!  Great job, OP.

u/PaleIrishEastcoaster The ultrasound pic was unnecessary but you admit that. But NTA, your ex roommate might need therapy to help process her trauma. She cannot expect any woman she lives...

u/turBo246 Wow! I remember reading the original post and not seeing this going well! Thanks so much for the update!! I am positive that she behaved this way and wanted...

u/NameLips When my wife and I were in our 20s, we were friends with an older couple (older for us at the time meant they were in their late 30s)....

u/Proud-Leave3602
Oh, she needs HELP.
You handled this really well. Good job, OP.

A few commenters also wondered if the roommate's parents were thoroughly embarrassed after being copied on her failed legal bluff.

Roommate relationships are fragile, and when personal histories collide with major life events, the fallout can be incredibly messy. While the roommate’s past trauma is undeniable, her attempt to use it to dictate another person’s reproductive path crossed a significant line of boundaries. Do you think the roommate was acting entirely out of unresolved trauma, or was this just a case of pure entitlement? And how would you have reacted if a roommate tried to bring their parents into a legal dispute over your lease? Share your hot take below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *