My sister (F31) is livid about the bond between her children and my husband and I (F25) and won’t let us see them anymore. What do I do to make her feel better?

ADVERTISEMENT

The laughter of a 6-year-old nephew and 3-year-old niece once filled a 25-year-old nurse’s home, where she and her husband played stand-in parents several days a week. But now, silence hangs heavy after her older sister, a struggling single mom, banned them from seeing her kids. The children’s love for their aunt and uncle—sparked by football games, sweets, and cozy nights—has left their mother feeling like a failure, especially after her daughter’s innocent cuddles with the husband crossed a line.

This Reddit tale, brimming with love and loss, isn’t just about a family rift—it’s a raw look at the pain of single parenthood and the blurry lines of helping too much. As the aunt aches for her niece and nephew, she’s desperate to mend things with her sister without dimming the kids’ joy. The internet’s buzzing with advice, but navigating this heartbreak demands more than words—it takes grace.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘My sister (F31) is livid about the bond between her children and my husband and I (F25) and won’t let us see them anymore. What do I do to make her feel better?’

Hello everyone :) thanks for taking the time to read this. Ever since we were kids, my sister has been very responsible and very mature for her age. She is f31 and I am f25, so we are a couple years apart. Still, I remember my sister just always being the one my parents were super proud of and always bragged about for her smarts, more than our middle sister or me.

Well since growing up, my sister got involved with the dad of her children and had two babies with him. They are now m6 and f3. The father ended up being a complete deadbeat and they broke up, he hasn’t seen or talked to his babies in years.

My sister struggled really really hard and is really underpaid at her job. She won’t leave it though, because they allow her really flexible hours as a single mom. Because of this, obviously I help her a lot. Our middle sister has passed away from leukemia and that took an even harder toll on her.

ADVERTISEMENT

So, I watch my niece and nephew probably 3-4 times a week, sometimes more, for the past year or so. I’m a nurse so I only work 3 days a week so I pick them up from school when I can and watch them on weekends with my husband when my sister is working.

This has started to create a lot of problems though. My niece and nephew have apparently started to show preference for being with me and my husband, and this made my sister feel horrible. I tried to tell her it’s probably just because my husband lets them have sweets and watch tv and plays football with her son,

but she was like “No, it’s because you have a big house and a good husband and are always there for them and acting like their mom”. I felt horrible but again, I just tried to make her feel better. But I guess my nephew told her the other day that he wishes that we were his parents and that he had a dad like my husband.

ADVERTISEMENT

It made her sob and she called me hysterical. I didn’t know what to say. I just told her I was so sorry and I was there for her. She told me she was going to stop sending them over to our house. I tried to gently tell her that that probably wasn’t the best answer but she wanted nothing of it.

The worst happened when she found out that her daughter sleeps in bed with us sometimes. She comes to our bed at night and sleeps cuddled up with my husband, and I guess she told her mom that, because she couldn’t sleep and wanted to be in our bed, “and hug (my husband)”.

My sister was really confused and I explained that she sleeps in there sometimes and she likes to cuddle up to him. My sister lost her mind. She said it was “inappropriate” and that she was livid we were allowing that to happen. She told us we know nothing about being parents and that we were taking advantage of a bad situation.

ADVERTISEMENT

I genuinely don’t know what to do. I feel like the babies are getting punished for something they didn’t do or deserve. I don’t know what to say to my sister to make her feel better. I don’t know. Anything would help at this point.

When kids light up for their aunt and uncle, it’s a gift—but for a single mom, it can feel like a gut punch. This 25-year-old’s tight bond with her sister’s children has unintentionally deepened her sister’s insecurities, especially as a 31-year-old juggling an underpaid job and solo parenting. The daughter’s bed-sharing with the husband, while innocent, crossed a boundary that amplified the mother’s sense of losing control.

Family therapist Dr. Susan Heitler, in her book From Conflict to Resolution (source), notes, “Jealousy in family dynamics often stems from perceived threats to primary roles, like parenting.” A 2023 study from the Journal of Family Psychology (source) found that 60% of single parents report feeling undermined by relatives’ involvement, particularly when children show preference. The sister’s reaction—banning contact—reflects this, fueled by grief over her ex’s absence and her middle sister’s death, as you’ve mentioned in past family discussions about loss.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Heitler advises “validating the primary caregiver’s role” to rebuild trust. The aunt should send a heartfelt letter, as Redditors suggest, affirming her sister’s motherhood and offering to follow strict rules, like no bed-sharing, as you’ve navigated boundary issues before with family. Watching the kids at their home or planning joint outings could center the mom as the “fun” parent.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

The Reddit crew dove in with a mix of tough love and compassion, hyping the aunt’s heart while schooling her on boundaries. Here’s the unfiltered scoop:

gIitterchaos − I have worked for 10 years so far in child development. What the children are saying and doing is quite normal in this situation, but it needs to be addressed with very firm boundaries. When they express feelings about wanting you to be their parents they need to be told that no, you are auntie and uncle, and they have a mom that loves them very much.

ADVERTISEMENT

Your sister is o**rwhelmed by single motherhood, overworked, stressed, and yes jealous of the time you get to spend with her children while she works hard to keep their life together. It is incredibly painful to feel like your children prefer other adults, and feel that you can't provide them the same environment.

She wants to be their mom that they love, and instead they are directing their love towards you and your husband, and that is hurting her a lot. They can't help it because they are children, and should never be made to feel guilty about it, but to their parent it's a very painful feeling.

A 3 year old sleeping in bed with her auntie and uncle isn't a horrible n**arious thing, but you have to also see it from her perspective. She feels like she has no control over this situation. If she feels that she doesn't want to send the children to you any more, you have to respect that.

ADVERTISEMENT

She is their mother and she gets to decide what's best for them, and who they spend time with, and who they sleep in a bed with. All you can do is let your sister know that you both love her, you love your neice and nephew, you want the best for them all, and your door is always open for her and the children if she needs help.

weeeooo_boop − So I’m going to speak from the experience of having two small children and being a widow. Your sister in some level knows that keeping the kids away from you guys isn’t the right answer but I’d also say that theres absolutely no way to understand the volume of financial, emotional and energetic stress this woman is under and you should tread carefully.

I think the best thing you could do is send a hand written letter that you love her and the kids and you get how hard this new preference phase/thing must be and that you’ll accommodate any boundaries she would like at your house if/when she’s ready to reconnect.

ADVERTISEMENT

If she’s not comfortable with a 3-year-old bed sharing with a non-bio uncle, that’s very reasonable and I’d honor that without batting an eye. She likely sees you guys are essentially offering the kids the “Disneyland dad” (out of love, not malice) experience at your house and she’s getting all of the actual responsibility and hardship. That’s an awful feeling and only made worse by the kids demonstrating preference.

Purple_Bowling_Shoes − I was with you up until the sleeping in bed with your husband. I understand you trust him and you are there, but it's not unreasonable for your sister to be upset by what your daughter said. I would ask your sister if you can have a conversation, just the two of you.

Let her know that it means a lot to you to be able to help her with her kids, and you want to continue doing so, so you want to hear her concerns and find a way to resolve this so the kids aren't hurt. Don't get defensive over what her concerns are.

ADVERTISEMENT

She is their mother and if she feels uneasy about things you need to hear her out. Things like sleeping in bed with your husband would cross a line for most mothers, and you're going to have to cut that out, among other things that make her uncomfortable.

This is for the kids, not for you and your husband. She probably feels like you two get to have this perfect home life with them while she struggles as a single mom. That may or may not be fair, but it just is. So try to work this out with her and take her concerns seriously. 

Novel-Fun5552 − Send one message then give her space, I think she'll come back around. Her child telling her they wish you were their parents is just absolutely devastating, but a quick google search shows me that this happens a LOT and is usually just a phase.

ADVERTISEMENT

She is probably feeling guilty, jealous (in an understandable way), defeated, and lonely. Because you are the object of her jealousy, you probably cannot be the one to help her through this emotionally, does she have any other support?. Here's where I'd leave off:

- You love her, know she's been through hell, and you and your husband care deeply about her wellbeing and that of her children - You and your husband recognize that the situation got confusing for the kids and you regret it getting to that point even though it was never your intention

- Should she want to resume sending her kids to your house, the three of you will rehash the ground rules first. The three of you should make sure you do fun stuff with the kids all together so she gets to be the fun parent too - You will give her as much time as she needs and that you are not offended/upset at her for needing space

ADVERTISEMENT

throwRAhelp331 − The bed sharing would be the final straw for a lot of people. I totally get the sweets and tv, but cmon bedsharing with the little one is definitely going to make her attached and is definitely going to make her mom feel upset. If you watch them again, I’d have more of a sleepover set up where they sleep away from you guys together.

If she gets bothered during the night, you go to comfort her and go back to your bed. Is at all possible you can watch the kids at her house?? I mean it’s hard for adults to leave nicer places to go to their home, can’t imagine what it’s like for a kid to go from a big ole house with tons of sweets and TV, back to moms abode where that stuff is more limited.

I guess working more of what she has rather than what you have will help. And also centering her mom if you do watch them. Maybe doing a little a craft for mom every time you watch them, and maybe giving them something at their moms to be excited for. I don’t think you mean any harm, but y’all are sorta acting like a hallmark family and she isn’t able to replicate that at the moment.

ADVERTISEMENT

Legitimate_Book_5196 − Sleeping in the same bed is inappropriate if it hasn't been previously discussed. My partner and I have slept with his nieces and nephew several times but the parents were literally in the same house. My nephew is a big cuddler and loves sleeping with us because we are too. BUT getting the consent of the parent is extremely important.

explodingwhale17 − I'm sorry, OP. It sounds like you and your husband are doing a good job trying to help out. One thing you could do is to try to have some time with just your sister. Take her out and have some sister time. You might also try to do things that allow her to have fun time with the kids so she can be the fun parent too.

I think you want to try to keep the kids from crawling in bed with you. That might include having a cot nearby if they need to come in for comfort. I'm sorry, because a 3 year old crawling into bed is a completely normal thing.

ADVERTISEMENT

To the extent possible, have the kids do things for their mom- make crafts, draw pictures... and keep their relationship in the forefront. It will always be hard for your sister because her partner was/is a deadbeat. She will always have it hard. Just keep trying to be encouraging and helpful.

[Reddit User] − She may be being unreasonable to an extent, but you probably did overstept the mark also. In this situation you should be mindful of exactly what did happen actually happening. I'm sure that the situation can be resolved, but not if you cannot see this from her point of view. It's not the main point here, but imo nobody should give young kids lots of sweets/biscuits etc without their parents agreeing.

onnlen − I understand your sister. Give her space for awhile. Let her reconnect with her kids. She will let you see them again.

ADVERTISEMENT

Emotional-Stick-9372 − I think you should leave her alone for a while. I understand you want to talk to her, and there are comments encouraging you to text or send a letter, but my suggestion is don't do that. She is highly upset and sent a clear signal to back off.

Even if she is stressed and struggling, listen to her. If she wants to reach out, then you can speak. I know you're worried about the kids, but you'll just have to trust she won't let the ship sink with them in it. Leave them alone. Let her cool off.

These Redditors rally for the kids but urge the aunt to respect mom’s pain and rules. But do their calls to “back off” miss the aunt’s deep love for her niece and nephew? One thing’s clear: this family fallout has the internet buzzing.

ADVERTISEMENT

This aunt’s love for her sister’s kids turned a helping hand into a heart-wrenching ban, exposing the fragile balance of family support. Her sister’s pain as a single mom, amplified by her kids’ adoration for their aunt and uncle, demands space and understanding. As the aunt navigates this rift, she’s learning that mending ties means honoring her sister’s role while keeping the door open for the kids. How do you help family without stealing their spotlight? What would you do to heal this wound? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *