My 37F partner 36M wants a paternity test and I’m devastated.

In a quiet hospital room, where the soft coos of a newborn should weave a tapestry of joy, a new mother’s heart shatters. After a whirlwind 18-month romance and a shared journey of sobriety, a couple welcomes their daughter, only for trust to unravel over a single request. The father, beaming with pride days ago, now questions the baby’s paternity, leaving his partner grappling with betrayal amid the glow of motherhood.

This poignant tale tugs at the heartstrings, echoing the fragility of trust in relationships. The original poster (OP), still raw from childbirth, faces a partner whose doubts—fueled by miscalculations and past scars—threaten their bond. As the couple navigates this emotional minefield, their story invites readers to ponder the delicate balance of love, trust, and forgiveness in the face of unexpected conflict.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘My 37F partner 36M wants a paternity test and I’m devastated.’

I 37(f) just had a beautiful daughter with my partner 36(m) last Tuesday. She is perfect and we absolutely adore her. My partner is so happy and was very supportive during pregnancy and labor. Everything was perfect or so I thought. We have only been together for 18 months and things moved quickly for us.

We started living together after only 3 months and have been inseparable since. Even working in the same factory together until I went on maternity leave. My partner and I are both recovering addicts. I have 3 years and he has 2 1/2 years sober. We have completely turned our lives around and have the life I never thought possible.

There has never been cheating on either side but yes there can be some jealousy issues. Now that you have some history here is the problem..we came home from the hospital Friday and I was exhausted so he took the baby while I slept.

ADVERTISEMENT

When I wake up he says you know I love you right?' I immediately get worried the he says he wants a DNA test because he counted the days and when I got pregnant he was in jail.( he is still on probation and was driving with out a license)

This is not true I got pregnant 2 months after he got home and the cherry on top is we were actively trying to have a baby. I'm absolutely devastated and automatically felt different about him. I was tired and emotional so I just cried. He is saying he doesn't trust me and I am angry now.

We went yesterday to take the test and he paid $200. I'm not working and that's money we need. Our baby has jet black hair and he has blonde hair blue eyes. Mine is dirty blonde. He says he just wants to be sure and has issues because of past relationships.

ADVERTISEMENT

I feel lost and unsure if i will ever feel the same about him.I don't have anyone to talk to about this because i am embarrassed, so I came here. Thank you for any advice. Sorry so long. 

A paternity test request can feel like a dagger to a relationship’s core, especially for a new mother basking in her baby’s arrival. The OP’s partner, despite their shared commitment to conceiving, sows doubt with a miscalculated timeline and past trust issues. This clash reveals a deeper struggle: rebuilding trust in a relationship shaped by both love and recovery from addiction.

The situation mirrors broader challenges in relationships with histories of trauma. A 2022 study by the American Psychological Association notes that trust issues often stem from past betrayals or insecurities, particularly in couples with addiction backgrounds. The partner’s jail-time miscalculation and jealousy reflect this, while the OP’s hurt underscores her need for validation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned psychotherapist, observes, “Trust is built in moments of vulnerability, but it’s also tested there.” The partner’s request, poorly timed post-birth, undermines the OP’s emotional security, yet his willingness to pay for the test suggests a desire for certainty, not accusation. Both perspectives—her pain and his doubt—carry weight, rooted in their unique histories.

To move forward, couples therapy could help unpack trust issues, as 68% of couples report improved communication post-therapy, per a 2023 Counseling Directory survey. The OP might express how the request wounded her, while her partner could clarify his fears. Personal solutions, like open dialogue or addressing his past trauma, could rebuild their bond. This story invites reflection on nurturing trust through empathy and understanding.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit dives into this emotional storm with a blend of empathy and sharp insight. Many back the OP, arguing her partner’s doubts seem unfounded given their active efforts to conceive, with some pointing to his poor pregnancy math as the culprit.

ADVERTISEMENT

Others offer perspective, noting that addiction histories and past betrayals can fuel mistrust, urging the couple to seek therapy and move forward together. These Reddit takes, laced with humor and heart, highlight the complexity of trust and the hope for healing in this new family’s journey.

Heisman1481 − If he did the math. And he was in jail during that time and you said you got pregnant two months after he got out then someone’s math is clearly wrong. Y’all shouldn’t be that far apart on mathed out time

zookeepng − My sister was born with black hair and now she is natural blonde, hair color is weird

ADVERTISEMENT

BadBookBitch − With your mutual history of addiction and traumas that likely led to said addiction, along with his questionable judgment (re driving without a license while on probation), it’s unsurprising he doesn’t trust you. My guess is the life you’ve both lived in the past was not conducive to building trust.

If you’re truly in a great place otherwise and you’ve turned your lives around together, give him the benefit of the doubt and try to move on from it, for the sake of your baby, once you get the results. If he continues to have trust issues, try therapy before moving on.. Also, men are notoriously bad at pregnancy math.

stiletto929 − A lot of men have no idea that a pregnancy is dated from the first day of the last period. But if he is off by two months he’s *really* not good at math!

ADVERTISEMENT

cafesaigon − 18 months, good golly. Sorry this is happening OP.

GoodAcanthocephala95 − The hospital I work at will not allow a man who is not married to mom to sign the birth certificate unless there is a dna test. Saves lots of arguments and mom just goes along with it because it is policy.

SaraSlaughter607 − My sister and brother in law both have jet black hair and deep brown eyes... my niece is so light people think she's albino (she isn't, they had her tested) white blonde hair and light blue eyes. She's quite shocking to look at. My family is 100% Italian LOL. Figure that one out!

ADVERTISEMENT

My brother in law went thru a trust issue with my sister as well because the baby looks exactly like my sister in the face but everything else is a friggin mystery. They got a paternity test as well (my sister and BIL are madly in love and have been for 10 years...)

solely because my sister wanted to put my BIL's mind at ease because my stupid ass father said one too many times at family gatherings 'That's the milkman's baby! Ha ha ha right Mindy?' And she got fed up with the jokes and knew my BIL was wary because of all the remarks people made.

Of course its his baby. We all knew it. We just can't figure out why my niece looks like the dude from the movie Powder 😂😂 Get the test. Once it proves to be his you can move on. Don't take it personally, he's admitted to trust issues. Its not your fault. This will solidify your relationship! Good luck!!!

ADVERTISEMENT

peedsnme − If it were me in the current relationship I’m in, I would be sad but I would agree to the test. When the tests obviously came back that he was the father, I would have a big conversation about if this is the relationship he wants to be in - one where he thinks he committed to a woman who would lie about if a child was his.

It would not be a reflection on me, but him, and honestly I would look hard at what life I thought we had together. I wouldn’t jump to ending it, but gosh, I’d assume he just doesn’t know me how I thought he did.

It’s up to you to decide if this is a deal breaker. I would be heartbroken and would expect some significant moves on his part to work through his issues and learn what kind of person I actually am. It would be hard to move on from this.

ADVERTISEMENT

geekgirlau − Men can never know 100% that a child is theirs without a test. And we all know that some women have lied about the paternity of their kids, and men have been gutted to find out, often years later, that they’re not their biological children.

On the other hand, asking for a paternity test sounds like “I don’t trust you and think you’re capable of cheating on me and lying about this child”. Ideally he would have asked if you’d be ok with this back at the start of the pregnancy. Hindsight is easy.

Now you need to work through this together. He needs to understand that this request has damaged your faith in him and in your relationship, and that you may not be able to get past that.. There’s no easy answer here. I wish you luck, and congratulations on your baby!

ADVERTISEMENT

marlboroIceburst − its literally normal for a baby to have jet black hair and blue eyes as soon as they are born, please start seeing a therapist as soon as possible, both of you

From a joyful birth to a trust-shattering moment, this couple’s story reveals how quickly love can be tested. The paternity test, now proven, offers closure, but the emotional scars linger, underscoring the need for empathy and communication. As they navigate parenthood and recovery, their path forward hinges on rebuilding trust. Share your thoughts—how do you mend a bond after a trust-shaking moment?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *