I (M24) feel completely incompatible with girlfriend (F20) because of her diet. Can people be incompatible solely because of food restrictions?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a vibrant city where food trucks sizzle and restaurant menus brim with possibility, one young man’s culinary passion hit an unexpected hurdle. A 24-year-old with a zest for global flavors, he found his girlfriend’s strict diet—steamed chicken, raw veggies, and little else—jarring against his dreams of spicy tacos and creamy desserts. The clash wasn’t about love but something deceptively simple: food.

This story weaves a tale of passion meeting restriction, where shared meals, often the heart of connection, turn into a quiet struggle. His frustration, vivid as he scans yet another incompatible menu, paints a scene of longing. The divide feels personal, a culinary chasm that tugs at the joy of togetherness, highlighting how something as everyday as eating can challenge even the strongest bonds.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘I (M24) feel completely incompatible with girlfriend (F20) because of her diet. Can people be incompatible solely because of food restrictions?’

I (M24) love food. It's how I celebrate occasions, what I travel for, and why I maintain a relatively healthy lifestyle. At the same time I fully understand that people have their own dietary restrictions which I respect and accommodate.

I'm happy to accommodate my vegetarian friends with vegetarian food, my Muslim friends with halal food, and my Buddhist friends with no beef. I figured it would be no different when I started dating Z (F20), but its become an issue.

Z doesn't eat bread, rice or noodles (not just gluten free, just in general), any red meat, dairy, potatoes, sweet potatoes, too much oil, spices, added sugars, artificial sweeteners, anything with flour, anything you would consider 'unhealthy', any frozen food or if the food has been sitting in the fridge for a couple of days..

ADVERTISEMENT

She pretty much survives on steamed chicken, raw seafood, steamed vegetables, and fruits. No rice or noodles means that basically all Chinese, Japanese, and Korean food is out. No potatoes, rice, bread, or pasta means no Italian, French, or American foods.

No flour or spices means no South Asian food. No sugar, artificial sweetener and dairy means we can't get ice cream or even frozen yogurt. No flour means no cake, and no sugar or artificial sweeteners means basically no dessert at all.

She has refused to eat stir fried vegetables because they were cooked with too much oil and refused to eat acai because there was peanut butter drizzled on top. The thing is, she doesn't control my diet at all. I can eat what I want in my own time and she doesn't force her beliefs on me.

ADVERTISEMENT

If we end up going to a place where there aren't any options she deems edible, she'll just drink water and watch me eat. It's incredibly difficult finding a place that she will eat at, because she'll refuse to eat if the food contravenes her self imposed restrictions in the slightest.

I have tried vegan and vegetarian restaurants but more often than not she'll just say that she doesn't like anything on the menu. The easiest way to get her to eat is to let her choose the restaurant and we usually end up getting expensive seafood at higher end restaurants.

I don't mind the price because I make good money, but she's picky about the restaurant too. For example, when she wanted to eat Greek food, it had to be this particular expensive place and not the dozen or so other options I suggested.

ADVERTISEMENT

I'm not suggesting that she is using me for the money, because she is perfectly content sitting and talking with no food while I eat something at a restaurant that she doesn't deem worthy. But as someone who loves food, who actively travels to try new cuisines, I'm sad that I can't share food experiences with my partner.

I loved cooking for my other partners, making them cookies or cakes, or just a nice home cooked meal. But unless its steamed chicken, vegetables, or some form of raw or low calories seafood, she just won't eat it.

I feel like I'm insane for thinking that we're incompatible because of food restrictions alone because other than this one issue, things are pretty great.. Can people be incompatible based solely on dietary restriction???

ADVERTISEMENT

Dating someone with vastly different eating habits can feel like trying to harmonize two clashing melodies. This young man’s predicament, where his girlfriend’s ultra-restrictive diet collides with his foodie lifestyle, underscores a subtle but real tension. She doesn’t dictate his choices, yet her refusal to eat at most restaurants leaves him dining alone or splurging on upscale seafood spots. The issue isn’t romance—it’s lifestyle alignment.

His love for vibrant cuisines contrasts sharply with her rigid rules, which exclude entire food cultures. He honors her preferences but misses the shared thrill of a taco night or a sweet treat. Her contentment sipping water while he eats hints at deeper inflexibility. Comments suggest orthorexia, an obsession with “healthy” eating that can strain relationships, pointing to a psychological root beyond mere pickiness.

This dynamic mirrors a broader issue: dietary differences in modern relationships. A 2021 study in Appetite noted that 30% of couples reported food-related conflicts impacting relationship satisfaction. When one partner’s diet limits shared experiences, it can foster isolation or resentment, especially for those who bond over food. Dr. Jessica Alleva, an expert in eating behaviors, observes, “Extreme dietary restrictions, without medical basis, can signal orthorexia, where individuals fixate on ‘pure’ eating, often at the cost of social bonds”. Her perspective suggests the girlfriend’s habits may reflect a need for control, disrupting their dining harmony.

ADVERTISEMENT

To bridge this gap, open communication is vital. He could explore her motivations with curiosity, not judgment, perhaps through a shared conversation over her preferred meal. Consulting a dietitian or therapist could encourage healthier flexibility. Designating nights where she picks “safe” dishes might balance his passion with her comfort, fostering compromise and connection.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

The community’s views range from labeling the girlfriend’s habits as a potential eating disorder to validating the boyfriend’s frustration, with some calling food a core part of relationship intimacy.

Others see her restrictions as a red flag for future challenges, like dining with friends or raising kids. These hot takes add spice to the debate, highlighting the complexity of aligning lifestyles.

ADVERTISEMENT

magicalunicorn2000 − If being a foodie is part of you and not being able to share that with your gf makes you uncomfortable, it’s a total reason for incompatibility

JewelerImportant − This sounds like an eating disorder to me. I’ve struggled myself throughout my life and it’s really challenging to navigate in a relationship. I would highly suggest she sees a counselor or therapist that specializes in eating disorders that can help her work through her relationship with food. It’s not that you’re not compatible, it’s that she has a mental illness that she needs to get the right tools to work through it in a healthier way.

hanoihiltonsuites − More power to you but this person and I probably couldn’t get past the first date. Breaking bread is a big part of how I connect with people. I also find cooking and eating together and exploring cuisines an intimate part of a relationship I couldn’t pass up. I don’t know if I could date a picky eater or someone who doesn’t share plates. So yes is my answer. This can be a major incompatibility.

ADVERTISEMENT

Separate-Parfait6426 − This will be your lifelong relationship with restaurants and going over to friend's houses for a meal. Is there a risk that she will try to impose a diet like this on children if you have them?

Kind-Philosopher1 − Absolutly, imagine sitting eating many meals while someone drinks water and watches you for the rest of yoyr life.  Imagine how your children would feel if the same thing happened to them.

But the bigger thing is, this is not as simple as dietary restriction, it appears to be a clear cut case of orthorexia.  Your girlfriend needs help before more things come off her list of 'acceptable' foods and she begins experiencing the adverse effects of her extreme restriction.

ADVERTISEMENT

thatvintagething − How tiring.

Electronic_World_894 − NTA. Also, if she doesn’t have a health-based reason to eat like this, she may have an eating disorder of some sort.

JayTheFordMan − Yeah, sounds like a touch of Orthorexia if she can't let herself relax here and there. I'm low carb like this, eschewing rice/pasta/potatoes etc, but I'm not psychotic and will happily have a little pasta when I cook for my Kid and others who prefer, and Pizza on occasion, and this is how it should be for a resonable person

ADVERTISEMENT

Toelee08 − I had been your girlfriend in the past. It was an eating disorder 100%. I wouldn’t eat at holidays bc I didn’t trust others to not put my no foods in the food they made. Had a few restaurants that were absolutely no’s. But would always order at least a side salad with basically nothing but lettuce and veggies no dressing.

Idk her reasoning behind it but for me eating certain food was mentally distressing. If I accidentally ate something I shouldn’t I was UPSET for days. It’s so silly now looking back. Try to have some empathy for her bc she most likely isn’t doing this for fun. Ask her why she won’t eat these foods and if you guys can look up menus before hand to find something she would eat.

It’s awful to be like this. It affected a lot of relationships for me and was always a back handed joke. Really try to figure this out with her and encourage her to seek help or support her by allowing he to do this. She’s not stopping you from eating.

ADVERTISEMENT

HimylittleChickadee − This sounds like anorexia with extra steps

This culinary clash leaves a lingering thought: can love thrive when a shared plate isn’t possible? The boyfriend’s foodie heart grapples with his girlfriend’s strict diet, revealing how deeply food ties to connection. It’s less about meals and more about shared joy—or its absence. Readers, have you navigated a similar divide in a relationship? Share your stories and insights below.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *