Fiance wanted an open marriage, so I called off the wedding. People are asking questions. Should I let them know why?
The soft hum of a therapist’s office turned icy as a groom-to-be sat, phone secretly recording, while his fiancée dropped a bombshell. Just weeks from their wedding, she proposed a one-sided open marriage—freedom for her to explore other men, but not for him. Her reasoning? She’d be too heartbroken if he strayed. Stunned but composed, he walked out, canceling the wedding and unraveling their future.
This isn’t just a breakup; it’s a raw clash of values, trust, and public scrutiny. The man’s calm exit belies the storm of betrayal he feels, while friends and family pepper him with questions. Readers might sense his quiet strength, wondering how to navigate such a public fallout without airing dirty laundry—or if the truth should come out.
‘Fiance wanted an open marriage, so I called off the wedding. People are asking questions. Should I let them know why?’
A wedding on the horizon should spark joy, not ultimatums. The OP’s fiancée blindsided him with a one-sided open marriage proposal, framed as “modern” but reeking of selfishness. Her claim that she’d be heartbroken if he explored other partners, while demanding her own freedom, reveals a double standard. The therapist’s role—seemingly rehearsed—raises ethical questions, though reporting may be tricky without clear misconduct.
This scenario reflects broader issues in relationship dynamics. A 2023 study found 15% of couples explore non-monogamy, but mutual consent is key (Journal of Sex Research). The fiancée’s unilateral demand violates trust, a cornerstone of marriage. Dr. John Gottman, a relationship expert, notes, “Trust is built through mutual respect, not ultimatums” (Gottman Institute).
The OP’s decision to end the relationship was sound, protecting his values. To handle questions, he can say, “We had irreconcilable differences about marriage expectations,” keeping it vague but honest. Sharing the recording risks legal issues—consulting a lawyer is wise, as some Redditors suggested. Moving forward, reflecting on red flags, like her secrecy about therapy, can guide healthier future relationships.
Check out how the community responded:
The Reddit posse rolled in like a truth squad, dishing out praise for the OP’s composure and shade for the fiancée’s audacity. It was like a virtual bonfire, with users roasting her hypocrisy and the therapist’s shady vibes. Here’s their raw take:
![[Reddit User] − Now that the wedding is no longer happening, people are starting to ask questions I am not comfortable answering. “I recently found out my fiancée was not interested in having a monogamous relationship. That was a dealbreaker for me.”. Good on you for not being a doormat. If she is going around spreading lies, consult a lawyer before you do anything with the recording. Make sure you have it backed up.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/180783cm-01.png)
![[Reddit User] − Can you provide an update after you figure out how to two other and what happened once you speak to her?](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/180783cm-11.png)
Redditors cheered the OP’s swift exit, calling the fiancée’s plan a shameless power grab. Some urged caution with the recording, while others suspected cheating. But do their fiery opinions capture the full truth, or just fan the drama? One thing’s clear: this therapy session bombshell has everyone talking.
This story is a stark reminder that love requires mutual respect, not manipulative deals. The OP dodged a lifetime of regret by walking away, but now faces a chorus of curious voices. Balancing honesty with privacy is his next challenge. Have you ever had to explain a tough breakup without spilling all the tea? What would you do with a recording that could set the record straight? Share your thoughts below.
