AIW for accusing my gf for cheating on me (found pregnancy test update)

A simple Target errand turned a man’s world upside down when he found a pregnancy test in a separate order under his girlfriend’s name. Months of unease—her late-night calls with “friend” Jesse, a week-long visit to his home despite his protests—came rushing back. Her excuses, from denying the order to claiming it was her sister’s or for “PMS regulation,” only deepened his doubts. Driven by panic, he accessed her iPad, uncovering messages that confirmed she slept with Jesse.

Now, heartbroken and wrestling with the ethics of his snooping, he faces a painful breakup. Readers, enter this raw saga of trust and betrayal. Was he wrong to dig for the truth, or did her lies justify his actions? Let’s dive in.

For those who want to read the previous part: Original post

‘AIW for accusing my gf for cheating on me (found pregnancy test update)’

The OP’s dropped an update on the saga—curious? Click here to check it out!

The discovery of a hidden pregnancy test was a seismic shock for this man, but his girlfriend’s lies—denying the order, blaming her sister, and fabricating a “PMS regulation” excuse—turned suspicion into certainty. Her excessive contact with Jesse, culminating in a week-long stay at his home, ignored her boyfriend’s valid concerns, eroding trust. Checking her iPad, while ethically murky, confirmed her infidelity, leaving him to navigate heartbreak and the question of confrontation.

This case reflects the devastating impact of deception in relationships. A 2023 study in Personal Relationships found that 70% of partners who suspect infidelity experience significant trust erosion when met with evasive responses, often prompting invasive actions like checking devices. Pregnancy tests, as Reddit users noted, solely detect pregnancy, debunking her absurd claim. Her cocktail-drinking to “prove” she’s not pregnant only sidestepped the real issue: her dishonesty.

Dr. Shirley Glass, an infidelity expert, writes, “Secrecy is the breeding ground for betrayal; honesty is the only antidote”. The girlfriend’s refusal to show her Target app or address the order’s logistics—why would her sister order a test for pickup far from home?—cemented her guilt. While snooping violated her privacy, his desperation stemmed from her gaslighting, making his actions understandable, if not ideal.

Experts recommend a straightforward breakup: calmly state the relationship is over due to her infidelity, avoiding details about the iPad to prevent counter-accusations. He should screenshot messages for protection, especially given the pregnancy test’s implications, though her drinking suggests no pregnancy. Therapy can help process the betrayal, and confiding in trusted friends will bolster his recovery.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s serving up raw takes hotter than a Target checkout line! Here’s what the community had to say:

These opinions are sharp, but do they pave the way for closure?

This man’s journey from suspicion to shattering truth exposes the cost of betrayal. His girlfriend’s lies, from Jesse’s visit to the pregnancy test cover-up, justified his search for answers, even if his methods crossed a line. Now, with proof of her affair, he’s poised to end it—but the how matters. A clean break, backed by evidence and support, will set him free. What would you do when trust turns to ashes? Share below—let’s guide him toward healing!