AITAH for telling my older brother & his wife they deserved everything they got?

An 18-year-old girl struck it rich beyond imagination after a wrongful death lawsuit over her father’s faulty defibrillator and his inheritance — enough to never work a day in her life. Her mom, proud and protective, watched as the girl’s greedy uncle and aunt suddenly crawled out of the woodwork, demanding chunks of the money.

What started as relentless begging escalated into false accusations, attempted bank fraud, and a courtroom meltdown. When the dust settled with legal consequences for the uncle, the mom bluntly told him he deserved every bit of it — sparking debate over whether she went too far.

‘AITAH for telling my older brother & his wife they deserved everything they got?’

The windfall came from tragedy and justice:

My, 51f, daughter 18, recently came into alot of money, like never have to work again type money. my daughter's father passed away when she was 11, due to a...

We were contacted by an attorney from our area who'd sued the manufacturer and already had 2 other families from our area on board. I decided to go ahead with...

The lawsuit settled when my daughter was 16 and everything was put into an account she could get into at 18. She also inherited all of her fathers money, assets,...

On top of all of that, her car was totaled by a careless driver and she got 34k from the guilty party and their insurance.. I cannot touch her money,...

The brother’s greed surfaced immediately:

my older brother has always been greedy and thinks if someone around him has money then he must have some of it. his wife is just as bad.

When it came about that my daughter had all of this money, my brother suddenly started calling me daily, trying to be nice, ect. I knew exactly what he was...

I told him the accounts were in my daughter's name, not mine and under her full control. my brother tried to manipulate me into getting money from my daughter to...

ADVERTISEMENT

my brother has always felt the lifestyle differences between my daughter and his were unfair. I never married, my daughter and I lived with my parents, my dad passed some...

my brother only comes around when he wants money. My brother is absolutely convinced My mom has a ton of money and is going to leave it to my daughter.

He targeted the daughter directly:

ADVERTISEMENT

Soon enough My brother started trying to talk to my daughter. my daughter just ignored him. I told her she was in no way obligated to help her uncle and...

When my dad passed, my mom had roughly 6k left from his life insurance left. my brother was sure mom was lying and hounded her for months. Then they switched...

I thought it was hilarious, my mom split what was left with all of her children, but my brother was greedy and swore there should be more. He got incredibly...

ADVERTISEMENT

my brother showed up unannounced to the house, I knew he was waiting to try and bully my daughter into giving him money. He tried again to get me to...

my brother seemed appalled and said my daughter should be giving me money. I didn't tell him she would. my brother also tried to goad mom into asking my daughter...

my brother immediately went into asking when my daughter came home. He pretty much talked like she had no choice, stating he would pay her back, which we all know...

ADVERTISEMENT

my daughter told my brother no, that she wasn't giving him any money. my brother got angry and told my daughter it wasn't fair, that his daughter had college to...

He said some incredibly cruel things and my daughter told him to get out. He got even angrier when my daughter told him I might be the things you called...

Escalation turned criminal:

ADVERTISEMENT

Things went silent, which worried me even more because I know how they are. We were on our way to an appointment one day when my phone rang and I...

I didn't answer until we were parked and I listened to the vm. my brother said my daughter had called their home, pretending to be their daughter and was saying...

My brother called my daughter more cruel things. I asked my mom what do you think we should do and my mom said she'd try to handle him. when my...

ADVERTISEMENT

the money my daughter would give them because they planned on sueing my daughter for emotional stress. my mom is old but not stupid, my mom asked if they had...

my sil took the phone at that point and proceeded to launch a ton of insults towards mom and my daughter. my mom told her that nothing would happen without...

I knew my daughter didn't do anything, my mom knew and my daughter let me see her phone. the night this supposedly happened my brother had called my daughter, but...

ADVERTISEMENT

my sil proceeded to call back to back. Screaming ensued. my daughter asked if my mom and I would be angry if she called the police. My daughter said she...

I said no, I wouldn't be mad, mom agreed . so the next time my sil called, my daughter picked the phone up, saying, I hope to God your right...

I knew then it was true bullcrap. the police did get called, my brother and sil pointed the finger at my daughter. phone records were obtained and my daughters innocence...

ADVERTISEMENT

It didn’t stop there:

fast forward a few weeks, my daughter gets a call from the bank manager who said my brother was in the bank, trying to withdrawal money from my daughters account...

My daughter told the bank manager to hold my brother there. I went with her and my brother was very irate when he saw us come in. he launched into...

ADVERTISEMENT

I told him my daughter can handle her own fiances just fine. the bank manager called the police and my brother was given a court summons.

When he went to court he tried to tell the judge my daughter was hard r worded and needed someone to handle her money. the judge told him that's not...

they tried to ring my daughter out, saying horrible things. my sil testified and said my daughter was a horrible person, had always made their daughter feel less than and...

ADVERTISEMENT

my sil said my daughters dream was to go to the college she was in, and her scholarship didn't cover all 4 years. the judge told them that their daughters...

after this was all said and done, my brother still tried to get money, he demanded my daughter give him the 34 k from the car accident for everything she'd...

Entitlement to family money, especially a child’s inheritance from tragedy, is a common toxic dynamic that destroys relationships. The brother’s pattern — sudden “niceness,” manipulation, false accusations, and fraud attempts — shows extreme greed crossing into criminal territory.

ADVERTISEMENT

False reports to police and bank impersonation are serious offenses with real consequences, as seen here. Courts rarely entertain “emotional distress” claims without evidence, especially against proven innocence.

Financial experts advise securing inheritances in trusts early and cutting contact with predatory relatives. The mom’s firm stance protected her daughter while modeling healthy boundaries.

ADVERTISEMENT

Telling him he “deserved it” is blunt truth, not cruelty — actions have consequences, and enabling greed only escalates it. No apology needed when defending your child from exploitation.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reactions were mixed — many called it obvious NTA and urged stronger protection, but a significant portion dismissed it as fake or ragebait due to dramatic elements:

Competitive-Bat-43 - Obviously you are NTA. Why do these people still have access to you, your mother and your daughter. Block them on everything and freaking move away!

ADVERTISEMENT

Get orders of protection. Put the money in an unbreakable trust so that (GOD FORBID) you all die he still can't get the money. I am worried for your safety

SerenityPickles - He is borderline delusional and scary. Get an estate lawyer to Make sure your mother’s home, assets and money are set up in a trust that spells out...

Make sure you have new locks on your home and all windows are secured. Look into door and property cameras. Secure anything valuable that he could walk away with. There...

ADVERTISEMENT

Many doubted authenticity:

Adventurous_Eye_1002 - Fake story for sure

az-anime-fan - sorry op, you get a downvote for this obvious ragebait, you should work on your creative writing because the AI bot posts are much more interesting.

ADVERTISEMENT

DisastrousMechanic36 - I’m going with fake

WhatHappenedMonday - This story makes no sense at all. Fake, fake, fake.

Leather-Novel1447 - Applause, utter fiction, b__pkin country soap opera.

Some criticized handling:

helius0 - Let me get this straight. You know the kind of person your brother is. And instead of shielding your daughter from his bullying/b__lshit, you just straight up told...

Others supported cutting ties:

Spoopyowo - NTA, y'all need to cut him and his wife out of your lives. What a toxic nightmare. Good on you, your mum and your daughter for not giving...

Valuable_Smoke166 - This story you made up is boring, needs some s__ or violence to make it interesting. Next !

More skepticism:

[Reddit User] - What country is this in? This isn’t real at all and makes no sense.

Nedstarkclash - Is this story real? There is no way a judge would allow your brother and SIL to ramble like that. I find everything rather dubious.

IamNotTheMama - No idea why this is here, just about 500 words about why you hate your brother and SIL Maybe have a better (real) story next time you post.

lovely_vah - Nah, this story is fake. You kinda had me up until the courtroom "scene". This ain't how it works and even I, a lawyer from a whole different...

ChewbaccaTheRookie - Cool story. Needs more dragons.

If real, the mom is solidly NTA — greed like that deserves consequences, and protecting inheritance from vultures is basic parenting. But heavy skepticism dominates, with many calling obvious fiction due to over-the-top villainy and courtroom antics.

True or not, it highlights real risks around sudden wealth in families. Would you go full no-contact immediately, or give one warning first? How do you spot (and stop) entitled relatives early? Thoughts below.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *