Aitah for not forcing my kids to play inside with my nephew?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a crisp afternoon, where the scent of pine drifts from a backyard woodlot, and a gaggle of kids bursts off the school bus, their sneakers kicking up dust. A 38-year-old mom, juggling snacks and sippy cups, watches her brood and nephews scatter—most darting to a makeshift fort in the trees, their shouts painting the air with joy. But one nephew, glued to his phone, prefers the couch over the call of adventure, sparking a family tiff.

The mom’s in a pickle: her sister’s upset, claiming her 12-year-old son’s being left out because the other kids won’t ditch their outdoor escapades for his movie marathon. The accusation stings—should she really force her teens to stay inside on a sunny day? Readers can feel the tension: balancing one kid’s preferences against the group’s wild spirit is no easy feat, and it’s got everyone debating who’s right.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘Aitah for not forcing my kids to play inside with my nephew?’

This family drama spilled onto Reddit, where the mom shared her side of the story. Here’s her original post, diving into the clash over kids’ playtime choices.

I am 38F I have 4 kids ages 16M, 14M, 12M, and 3F. My sister (35F) has one kid age 12M. I also have a brother (30M) whose kids are 4M & 10M. After school every day all of the kids come to my house until their parents get off of work. 3F isn't in preschool yet so she is home all day and 4M does half days preschool I pick him up at 12.

I have a little fenced in play area for the babies and spend most of my time there. When the kids all get off the bus I normally have a snack ready and then most of them go outside and find somewhere to play. My kids are pretty feral. 99% of the time they are headed straight for the woods to 'the fort'.

ADVERTISEMENT

My brother's oldest usually does whatever my kids are up to. The issue is my sister's son. He does not like to be outside and mostly sits on the couch and either watches TV or plays on his phone. Every now and then he will go play with the others by it's rare and he's back inside pretty quickly. He is just not an outside kid.

Yesterday my nephew was upset because the others did not want to stay inside and watch a movie with him. He asked them and they all just wanted to go outside. When my sister came to pick him up he told her the other kids wouldn't watch a movie with him and he didn't want to play what they were playing.

So my sister is now upset and said all the other kids are excluding him and I should have made them stay with him instead. I told her my kids don't like to watch TV. They are working on their fort( there was a storm recently so they are rebuilding it) and enjoying being outside.

ADVERTISEMENT

If it were raining or something sure I could have made them come inside but it was a nice day so I'm not forcing 4 boys to stay in the house just because her kid wants to stay in the house. It was his decision not to go with them. They didn't say he couldn't they asked him if he wanted to go.

Well now my sister and her husband are both upset and believe I am allowing my children/ nephew to exclude their son. Idk if I'm an a hole here but I didn't feel like it was appropriate to force teenage/ preteen boys to sit inside and watch a movie when they wanted to be outside.

Managing a house full of kids with different vibes is like directing a circus with no ringmaster. This mom’s caught between her sister’s claim of exclusion and her kids’ love for outdoor play. Her nephew chose the couch over the fort, but his mom thinks the others should’ve joined him. The mom’s stance—letting kids follow their interests—clashes with her sister’s expectation of enforced togetherness.

ADVERTISEMENT

The heart of the issue is fairness versus freedom. The mom’s kids invited their nephew outside, but he opted out, a choice that doesn’t equate to exclusion. A 2021 study in Child Development found that allowing children to choose activities fosters social skills and independence. Forcing the group to stay inside risks resentment, not inclusion.

Dr. Tovah Klein, a child psychologist, notes, “Kids learn to navigate relationships by experiencing differences, not by adults mandating play”. Her insight suggests the mom’s approach—letting kids choose—supports healthy growth. The sister’s demand might stem from wanting her son to feel included, but it overlooks his agency in choosing solitude.

To bridge the gap, the mom could suggest occasional group activities, like a board game, while the sister could encourage her son to try outdoor play briefly.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit jumped in with opinions as lively as a kid’s treehouse party. Here’s a taste of the community’s takes, sprinkled with humor because, let’s be real, family feuds are best served with a laugh.

Fit_Base2089 − I love that you encourage your kids to go outside and use their imaginations! Your nephew isn't into that, and that's fine, but he needs to realize that he can't make the other kids watch a movie with him if none of them want to do so.

If your sister doesn't like the way you manage things in your home, she is free to seek after-school childcare elsewhere. It's entitled of her to demand that you cater to her child - one of SEVERAL who are in the home - when you are doing her a favor. NTA.

ADVERTISEMENT

SleepyGiraffe947 − NTA. Your sister is doing a disservice to her son. He was offered to join his cousins but chose not to. He’s not entitled to force them to watch a movie because he doesn’t like going outside. As a side note, I hope your sister is paying you to watch her son.

Eastern_Condition863 − NTA. The other kids aren't being mean, forcing him to do/not do something, and are inviting him to come along. The fact that he chose not to shouldn't force all the other kids to have to do what he wants to do. That's selfish behavior.

He can be upset, but he has to learn you can't make people do things just because you want to do them. I don't understand why parents can't ever let their kids feel upset or have their feelings hurt. It's part of growing and learning how to cope and manage. Your sister doesn't need to fly in to try to manage the situation. There's nothing to manage here except her own kid.

ADVERTISEMENT

TrixIx − Imagine having free childcare for a 12 year old in this economy and being mad that your child doesn't get to dictate the activities for everyone at said childcare..  Would she be okay with you forcing nephew to stay outside in the fort with the others and not allowing him inside if the others got mad he wasn't joining them?  I'm guessing that would be a Texas sized hell no from entitled and wrong sis.  

scienceoftophats − NTA and May I say how cool it is that you enable all these cousins to be together every day! Brava!

Quiet_Village_1425 − NTA. Tell them they can send him to an after school program. You are not here to play referee.

ADVERTISEMENT

whyumdoum − Nta this is just kids being kids your sisters kid is an inside kid and the others are outside kids as long as you’re sure the other kids aren’t purposefully excluding him it’s normal kid stuff to be cross with each other specially since you mentioned he’s 12.

So I’m 100% by your nephews next visit he would’ve forgotten this ever happened if anything you should tell your sister not to intervene because if the adults get involved it’ll be an unnecessarily prolonged thing.

[Reddit User] − You call it feral, I call it healthy. I grew up when the internet was just becoming A THING in people's homes and I still spent a lot of my days playing outside with the kids from the block. I miss those days.

ADVERTISEMENT

I miss playing in my friends' version of your kids' fort. Those days were golden, and your kids are experiencing that now. It would be terrible to deprive them of that because ONE kid wants to cloister himself inside.. NTA.

Stellar_Star_Seed − She sounds like a problem.

Spirited_Heron_9049 − If her kid doesn’t want to join in the fun, too bad for him. The best way to build resentment among kids to tell any of them they HAVE to do what one kid says. The ONLY way that works is to be a daily rotation and everyone has to participate bc eventually it’ll come back around to what you want.. Edited to add: NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit gems are spicy, but do they nail the truth? Is it fair to let kids run wild, or should one nephew’s indoor love call the shots?

This mom’s tale is a snapshot of family life—messy, vibrant, and full of competing wants. She’s navigating the tightrope of keeping kids happy while fending off her sister’s accusations. Reddit’s on her side, cheering for freedom over forced playdates, but the question lingers: how do you keep the peace when cousins don’t click? What would you do in this backyard showdown? Drop your thoughts and share your own family tales!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *