AITAH for not correcting my friend who said I liked her before I met my partner?

In a dimly lit bar, laughter and clinking glasses fill the air as a group of friends swap stories, but one comment lands like a rogue spark in a tinderbox. A young man, happily partnered, freezes as his flirtatious friend J declares to everyone—including his girlfriend G—that he had a crush on her before they met. J’s words, tossed out with a tipsy smirk, stir unease, and his silence in the moment leaves G stung.

This isn’t the first time J’s playful boasts have raised eyebrows, but this time, they hit a nerve. G feels disrespected, and her boyfriend’s choice to avoid drama rather than set the record straight sparks a heated debate at home. Caught between loyalty and peacekeeping, he’s left wondering if his silence spoke louder than words. A tale of boundaries, egos, and unspoken truths unfolds.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘AITAH for not correcting my friend who said I liked her before I met my partner?’

I (27M) have a friend we’ll call J (25-26F) who I met about a year before meeting my partner G (23F). J had a boyfriend when I met her. Our friend group consisted of J, another girl, and 3 of us guys (plus J’s partner). J likes gossip, drama, etc.

J is flirtatious despite having a partner and would compliment, tease, and joke flirtatiously. She would also start to think that guys liked her, including myself and another guy in our group (maybe all?).

When she got drunk, if she felt like it, she would say “he used to like me” about multiple guys, and we were all used to not correcting her (if it was about us) or not questioning it at all. If we did, she would jokingly say something like “oh so you’re saying I’m not pretty?”.

ADVERTISEMENT

As you can see, I felt like correcting her was not possible or would not help. After I met G, I introduced her to my friends pretty early. She knew J for about two years before J started to make plans to leave the country.

One group night, most likely with drinks involved, J had said again that I used to like her before I met G, something I had not prepared G for. I remember telling G that I’m sorry for not telling her that J used to say that. She doesn’t recall me telling her.

We started to discuss this night recently and G feels hurt that J had the audacity to say that to her and feels like J shouldn’t go around telling people that, because we are in a relationship and she needs to know her boundaries.

ADVERTISEMENT

I understand and share her feelings, and I think I could have easily said something, but in the time I thought that avoiding confrontation like we have in the past was the best move. I can personally think of 4 other guys who she said she thinks are into her or likes her, and no one ever denies it.

G thinks I should have corrected her then, but I think not making a scene or big deal was also sparing extra embarrassment for G, since I know that J wants drama. My justification for not confronting J was that our friend group is aware of how J is.. AITAH?.

Navigating friendships alongside a romantic relationship can feel like walking a tightrope, especially when someone like J thrives on stirring the pot. This man’s decision to let J’s claim slide—rooted in a habit of avoiding her drama—backfired, leaving his girlfriend feeling sidelined. J’s flirtatious behavior, unchecked by the group, crosses boundaries, while his silence risks signaling complicity.

ADVERTISEMENT

J’s pattern of claiming male friends’ affection, even when unfounded, suggests a need for validation that disregards others’ relationships. A 2022 study on interpersonal dynamics notes that such behaviors can destabilize group cohesion, especially when boundaries aren’t enforced. His choice to stay quiet, shaped by J’s knack for deflecting challenges, reflects a common conflict-avoidance tactic—but at the cost of G’s trust. G’s hurt stems from feeling her relationship was disrespected in public, a valid concern given J’s audacity.

Dr. Harriet Lerner, a relationship expert, writes, “Silence in the face of disrespect can erode trust, as it implies acceptance”. Here, his inaction left G questioning his loyalty, while J’s unchecked ego fueled tension. The broader issue is how group dynamics enable problematic behavior—J’s friends, by not confronting her, indirectly embolden her drama. This can strain romantic partnerships, as partners expect defense against external slights.

He should apologize to G, acknowledging her feelings without excusing his silence, and set clear boundaries with J. A direct, calm response in the moment—like, “That’s not true, I’ve always seen you as a friend”—could deflate J’s claims without escalating drama. Long-term, limiting contact with J or addressing her behavior as a group may prevent repeats. Therapy or open talks with G can rebuild trust, ensuring she feels prioritized.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s commenters didn’t mince words, with most labeling the man as wrong for not shutting J down. They saw his silence as a failure to defend G, potentially validating J’s claim and disrespecting their relationship. Many urged him to grow a backbone, suggesting quick retorts like denying the crush or redirecting the conversation.

Some called J a drama-seeking “pick me,” enabled by the group’s passivity, while others felt his inaction might hint at unspoken truths. A few offered sympathy, suggesting an apology to G could mend things, but the consensus leaned toward action over avoidance.

Motchiko − YTA grow a spine. She disrespected your girlfriend right in your face and all that for a pick me on a power trip. Fight for your relationship before your girlfriend decides that she won’t stay with someone, who doesn’t give a flip.

ADVERTISEMENT

redwoods2 − YTA. Why on EARTH would you not correct her?? How can you just stand by idly whilst someone says something about you that's just not true? Unless...?

Last_Emotion6890 − YTA. No woman wants a man that is going to allow someone to say/imply n**ty things right in front of her face and have him not say anything at all. No one cares about the drama. But by you not saying anything to J then you are in fact reinforcing what she's been saying making it true, whether it is or not. 

G would be within her rights to leave you just for being linguini spined. Get some balls and put J in her place. Either you care enough to defend G or you don't. Sack up. Jiminy Christmas, dude. SMH. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Mmm_Lychees −   “he used to like me”. You: No I didn’t.  “oh so you’re saying I’m not pretty?”. You: Not as pretty as G. YTA. You are almost 30 years old, use your words! . Shut her down asap then change the topic. Leave if needed.

Boobookittyfhk − That girl is a pick me and you and your group of friends are just enabling her. I think you all low-key like the attention you get from her and so you entertain it. But you’re doing it at an expense to your future partners. No self-respect would put up with this. You’re lucky that your partner has for this long.. What if this was a guy doing it to her?

SlappySlapsticker − 'I'm really sorry G, you're correct saying I could have confronted her at the time. I thought the better path would be not to, due to her history, however I see that wasn't fair to you. Again I'm sorry.'. A good apology that includes reasons without trying to justify them can go down a treat.. NAH (except J)

ADVERTISEMENT

ofthephoenixx − Y’all don’t correct her because she’s right…

FormSuccessful1122 − Why are you even friends with J? She sounds like an obnoxious, arrogant, drama queen. No one needs that. YTA

Puzzleheaded_Rule134 − YTA - for all the reasons your girlfriend is trying to tell you. Your friend is acting like a n**ty mother in law for gods sake. You can either shut J up, stop hanging around her or break up and find a gf who will put up with J’s snarkiness.

ADVERTISEMENT

kikibel15 − Bro grow a pair. YTA

This story lays bare the messiness of friendships that test romantic bonds. J’s bold claim and the man’s silence stirred hurt, but it’s a chance to reset boundaries and prioritize trust. His hesitation came from a desire to keep the peace, yet it left G feeling unprotected.

As he navigates this, a heartfelt apology and firm stance with J could pave the way for healing. Share your thoughts or experiences below—how do you handle friends who cross lines in your relationship? Let’s keep the conversation flowing.

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *