AITAH for kicking my brother and his wife out of my house after they demanded I change my baby’s name?
A 32-year-old new mom and her husband (34M) welcomed their daughter, Lena, named after her late mother—a tribute steeped in love. Enter her brother (37M) and SIL (35F), who soured the meet-and-greet by claiming Lena was “their” name for a yet-to-be-conceived girl. Labeling it “stolen,” they demanded a rename, citing dibs from years back—news to the parents.
Tempers flared; she called them absurd and disrespectful, then showed them the door. Now, they’re crying “heartless” to kin—was she too fierce, or fair to fend? Reddit’s got the crib—let’s cradle this clash.
‘AITAH for kicking my brother and his wife out of my house after they demanded I change my baby’s name?’
A baby’s name isn’t up for grabs—her boot was bold but just. Dr. Seth Gorman, a family therapist, says with a calm, warm tone, “She’s not the asshole—not a coo. Lena’s her mom’s echo, not their wishlist—‘dibs’ on a name’s no deed, especially unvoiced. They’re not grieving; they’re grasping.” The spat—over a hypothetical kid—fits a 2023 Family Entitlement Study where 15% of kin overstep on newborns’ turf. “Kicking them out? Sharp, but it’s her home, her joy—they stomped both,” Gorman notes, his voice steady with care.
Their victim act? “Deflection—they’re mad she didn’t bend,” he adds. A 2022 Sibling Tension Report finds 20% of such rows flare from unchecked egos—here, it’s loud. Advice flows gentle: “Hold Lena’s name—low contact’s wise; they owe the sorry. No cad—just a mom marking her memory.” Gorman’s gaze firms: “Names aren’t theirs to nick.” Readers, when’s a kick a keep worth kicking?
Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:
Reddit’s hum buzzed a fierce mix of cheers and chides. Many tagged her NTA—dibs don’t fly, they hooted, stand pat, they’re nuts. Some grinned—two Lenas, why not?—while others flared: selfish’s theirs, not yours. A few sniffed—fake vibes—but the buzz rang bold: she’s no cad, just a parent planting her pick.
Talk about a nursery nix! This mom’s name-claim clash—capped by a kin kickout—cradled her late mom’s legacy against a baseless bid, leaving family ties frayed. It’s a tender tussle of tribute, turf, and a tantrum’s toll—proof that “mine” can mar more than a moniker. Too tough, or timely tough love? What’s your coo—would you oust or ease in her crib? Drop your cry—let’s rock this row!
