AITA for telling my sister she’s destroying her relationship with her oldest daughter?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a 12-year-old girl, caught in a family storm, clinging to her truth: her stepdad isn’t her dad, and her younger siblings are half, not whole. Her mother, desperate to stitch a blended family together, responds with groundings, school changes, and a ban on her best friend, escalating a battle that’s tearing them apart. Enter her sibling, who steps in with a blunt warning: this parenting path is paving the way for estrangement. Was this tough love a wake-up call, or an overstep into a mother’s domain?

This Reddit tale peels back the layers of a blended family fraying at the seams. The OP’s confrontation with their sister, who’s hell-bent on forcing her daughter to embrace a family structure she rejects, sparks a debate about respect, autonomy, and the cost of control. It’s a story of good intentions gone awry, with a child’s voice caught in the crossfire.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘AITA for telling my sister she’s destroying her relationship with her oldest daughter?’

My sister has three kids and she's expecting her fourth. Her oldest (12f) isn't her husband's bio kid. They started dating when she was 5 and married when she was 8. Her other two are 4 and 2.5. My sister's oldest doesn't see her stepdad as her dad even though she has no relationship with her bio dad or his family.

It was just my sister and her oldest for the first five years, first 7 if you count the years before her husband moved in. The oldest has stated she doesn't have a specific reason for feeling like her stepdad isn't her dad. But that's bow she sees it.

She's said more than once she will never call him dad and that she hates when people act like she should. That she can make up her own mind on that. My sister has a hard time with that but she was willing to let it go. But from the time my sister got pregnant again there has been a HUGE dispute over the oldest saying half sibling.

ADVERTISEMENT

She never calls the other kids her siblings. It's always half. And she was never very excited about them. My sister blamed her daughter's BBF. The BFF had a very blended family and used half and step and only saw her full sibling as a sibling-sibling and the others were meh according to the BFF.

My sister and her daughter started fighting about the whole thing from that point onward. They fought it at home and in therapy. My sister chose to cut her daughter off from the BFF. She got her moved to a different class and refused to let them hang out after school and when that wasn't enough she moved her daughter's school.

But the girls still found a way to contact each other and my sister hates it. My sister has also grounded her daughter, taken away all TV, phone and computer privileges. She has told her she is not okay with her making her siblings less than.

ADVERTISEMENT

My niece has said the truth is they're not siblings who have the same parents, they only have her the same and she can't change that. Which brought in the whole 'Your stepdad has raised you for years now and you should accept him' as well as 'Siblings are siblings regardless of how many parents they share or don't share'.

My sister told me recently she found out the girls were meeting up secretly and my sister wanted to rage at the BFFs parents to make them get involved too. She said 'that girl' has been a horrendous influence on her daughter and how much it's driving her crazy.

I told my sister I love her, I hate seeing her stressed and frustrated, but she's not making things better by acting like this. My sister asked what I meant and I told her she's destroying her relationship with her oldest and if she continues she'll be explaining to the other kids while their big sister is never around and never speaks to any of them.

ADVERTISEMENT

I said she might just need to accept that to her oldest the kids are her half siblings and her stepdad isn't her dad. I said maybe she'd get closer to them if she backed off and if not, then at least there'd be less fighting and they could be in a better place in the future.

My sister told me I didn't understand the relationship between a parent and their child if I felt she was destroying the relationship. She said she's parenting and trying to get more of a positive influence for her oldest.. AITA?

Parenting a blended family is like navigating a maze with moving walls, and the sister’s approach is hitting dead ends. Her daughter’s refusal to call her stepdad “dad” or her siblings “full” isn’t rebellion—it’s her asserting her reality. The sister’s reaction, from isolating her daughter to punishing her for terminology, screams control, not care. By blaming the best friend and escalating punishments, she’s alienating a child already grappling with a shifting family dynamic.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, writes in Psychology Today, “Forcing step-relationships often backfires, creating resentment.” The daughter’s stance reflects this, with a 2021 study in the Journal of Family Issues noting that 60% of stepchildren resist imposed parental roles when their autonomy is ignored. The sister’s tactics—grounding, school switches—mirror coercive parenting, which Dr. Papernow warns can fracture trust.

Dr. Papernow advises, “Validate a child’s feelings to build connection.” The sister could ease tensions by accepting her daughter’s terms, fostering closeness through respect rather than ultimatums. Therapy focused on the daughter’s perspective, not compliance, might help. The OP’s warning was a necessary jolt, urging a course correction before the daughter bolts at 18. Supporting the niece’s autonomy now could salvage the family’s future.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit rolled in like a concerned family reunion, dishing out support with a side of tough love. They backed the OP’s warning, predicting the daughter’s inevitable no-contact future if the sister doesn’t change course. From calls to support the niece to sharp critiques of the sister’s parenting, the comments were a lively mix of empathy and alarm. Here’s the unfiltered Reddit buzz:

ADVERTISEMENT

ed_lv − NTA. Once her daughter turns 18 she's gone, never to speak to your sister again, and she only has herself to thank. She needs to leave the poor kid alone and stop pressuring her. She might be trying to parent, but you are 100% right, she is completely destroying her relationship.

lady-scorpio-45 − Um, trying to be a positive influence? How?? Switching classes, switching schools, banning contact, grounding, taking away anything possible etc etc. Yeah, she’ll be no contact the day she turns 18.

miyuki_m − NTA. Your sister is not seeing her oldest as a full human being with her own mind, feelings, and opinions. Your sister expects her to think the way your sister thinks and is punishing her because she doesn't.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is about respect. Your sister doesn't respect her daughter, and her daughter knows it. That's why your sister is going to lose. And she's not just going to lose this battle. She's going to lose her daughter. Your sister needs to look at this from her daughter's perspective.

Her mother was her only family for five to seven years until her mother fell in love with her new husband. Her daughter didn't fall in love with him. She had no choice in the matter. Now, she's expected to accept him as her new dad. She's not saying that her siblings are half siblings only to reject them.

She's clarifying what their relationship is because they don't share a father, and she doesn't claim their dad as hers. Her daughter is now being punished because she doesn't believe what her mother wants her to believe. Her mother chose this. She didn't.

ADVERTISEMENT

I absolutely despise parents who don't see their kids as individuals who think and feel independently of their parents. They think their job is to teach them to be just like they are instead of teaching them to be who they want to be. A parent's job is not to indoctrinate their kids into the life they choose for them.

Their job is to raise good human beings who are able to live independently, choose a life path that makes them happy, and hopefully thrive as contributing members of society.. Be there for your niece. She's going to need help when she cuts your sister out of her life.

Thin-District8266 − NTA. I'd even add that she's pushing her daughter away and out the door as soon as she can. If the mum continues this I guess that girl will leave home as soon as possible and not look back. And the mum will say 'I do not understand what I did wrong'.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ok_Childhood_9774 − NTA, and you're right, your sister is going to destroy whatever is left of her relationship with her oldest. It may be frustrating for your sister to hear, but those other children *are* her step and half-siblings.

For whatever reason (and I suspect there are many), your niece does not like her stepfather and doesn't see his children as connected to her. Grounding her and isolating her from her friends might be the final nail in the coffin. Trying to force the issue is just going to make things worse for everyone.

No-Doubt9679 − My mom remarried when I was 12. I felt the same and only called my step father by his name. He was an amazing man who never tried to replace my dad but was always there for me. He passed away from a heart attack when I was 26.

ADVERTISEMENT

I cried so much because I realized how much of a father he was to me without me actually calling him that. To this day in the way I rise my kids his influence can be seen.. Your sister needs to realize that it’s not the title but the relationship that matters the most.

lostinthought1997 − NTA. Your sister has been treating her oldest this way for FOUR YEARS? Holy crap. That relationship isn't being destroyed. It's been hit with a nuclear weapon and buried a mile underground... that relationship is OVER, and your sister only has herself to blame. I hope your niece knows you have her back, she needs an adult who understands and supports her.

Emergency-Leg1636 − NTA let your niece know you will always be there for her, and your sister is going to learn the hard way about trying to force her to do things she doesn't want to do.

ADVERTISEMENT

nemesis72988 − NTA. I won’t be surprised if the oldest goes no contact with your sister once she’s older and financially able to.

Zestyclose-Height-36 − Please point out to sister that she is about to face the teen years with a girl who resents being forced to adopt a vocabulary she doesn’t feel. That is not going to go well.

Talk to sister about what should happen when girl wants out of the house, does she want the girl to take off to you, bff, the streets? Because that will be coming at some point in teen rebellion. Half is the accurate description of the younger crowd, berating her kids for accurately describing is ridiculous.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors didn’t mince words, rallying for the daughter’s right to her truth. But do their dire predictions nail the full scope of this family fallout, or are they just sounding the alarm? One thing’s clear: this saga’s got everyone rooting for the kid.

The OP’s bold warning to their sister is a lifeline thrown into a sinking family dynamic. By highlighting the risk of estrangement, they’re not judging—they’re pleading for a child’s voice to be heard. The sister’s quest for a perfect blended family is blinding her to the damage of her control, but there’s still time to pivot toward respect and understanding. This story challenges us to weigh parental intent against a child’s autonomy. Have you ever seen a family rift widen over forced bonds? Share your thoughts—let’s keep the conversation going!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *