AITA for telling my SIL that I don’t care that her baby died and to leave me alone?

Imagine this: two high school besties, thick as thieves for 15 years, navigating life’s twists together—until the road gets bumpy, and one veers off entirely. That’s me and Daisy, my sister-in-law turned stranger. She’s been chasing a baby dream for a decade, while I’ve been her rock through every heartbreak. But when my own life flipped upside down—pregnancy, then losing my husband Dan, her brother—she bolted. Now, she’s back, desperate, and I’ve slammed the door shut with some brutal words. Am I the bad guy here?

It’s a tale drenched in loyalty, loss, and a friendship that crumbled under pressure. Daisy’s fertility struggles were a marathon of pain, and I ran alongside her, footing bills and mopping tears. But when my joy and grief collided, she couldn’t handle it—and left me stranded at my darkest hour. Fast forward: she’s in crisis, and I’m done caring. Let’s unpack this mess.

‘ AITA for telling my SIL that I don’t care that her baby died and to leave me alone?’

Oof, talk about a friendship hitting the skids! This story’s a gut-punch—years of support swapped for silence when the tables turned. Daisy’s exit during the Redditor’s pregnancy and Dan’s death? That’s not just distance; it’s abandonment with a capital A.

Grief expert David Kessler nails it: “Grief is not a one-size-fits-all experience; it’s deeply personal, and so is how we support each other through it” (Kessler’s site). Daisy’s jealousy over the pregnancy and refusal to face Dan’s funeral scream unresolved pain—but it’s no excuse. The Redditor held her up for years; Daisy couldn’t spare a single day. That’s a loyalty gap wider than the Grand Canyon.

This taps into a bigger vibe: toxic friendships often unravel under stress. Research shows 84% of women cite emotional exhaustion as a reason to ditch draining pals (source: Psychology Today). Daisy’s “take, take, take” vibe left the Redditor burned out. Her harsh “I don’t care” comeback? A trauma-fueled line in the sand.

Advice? Keep that boundary firm—Daisy’s mess isn’t your cleanup duty. Kessler suggests focusing on “who’s in your corner now.” For the Redditor, that’s her daughter and a fresh start. Let Daisy figure her own path; you’ve carried enough.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s crew chimed in with fire—and a sprinkle of shade. Here’s the rundown, hot and unfiltered.

These takes are a rollercoaster—some cheer the Redditor’s spine, others flinch at her venom. “Harsh but fair” seems the vibe, though a few reckon she kicked Daisy when she was down. Real talk: does the crowd’s split reflect life’s messy gray zones, or are they just tossing popcorn at the drama?

So, where’s the landing? The Redditor’s words were a verbal sledgehammer—cold, sharp, and unapologetic. Maybe “I don’t care your baby died” was the match that lit the bridge ablaze, but Daisy handed her the torch years ago. This isn’t about who’s the saint; it’s about who’s left standing after the fallout—and the Redditor’s choosing peace over pity.

What’s your take? Was she too brutal, or just done being the doormat? Ever had to cut a toxic tie with a zinger? Spill it below—let’s hash out this tangle of hurt and healing together!