AITA for telling my child’s father’s new wife that she can’t come with us on our son’s college tours?

How much say should a teenager have in who joins important milestones like college tours? Families often navigate blended dynamics during big life steps, balancing new relationships with existing bonds.

This social media post details a co-parenting disagreement over including a new stepmother in out-of-state college visits. The son’s clear discomfort clashed with his father’s desire for inclusion. The situation underscores respecting a nearly adult child’s boundaries while managing evolving family structures.

‘AITA for telling my child’s father’s new wife that she can’t come with us on our son’s college tours?’

The story centers on coordinating college tours for a high school senior in a blended co-parenting setup.

My son will be a senior in high school this fall and we have been touring colleges. We toured a few this spring and plan to tour several out of...

The plan was for myself, my husband, and his father to do the tours together. We’ll be touring 4 schools, and he’s coming to 3 of them.

Some background: my son’s father and I split up before our son was 6 months old. Soon after our relationship ended, I met my now husband and we got married...

My ex has been supportive of our relationship and thinks my husband is a great stepfather. Our coparenting relationship has been challenging at times but we’ve done just fine for...

Last year, my ex eloped with this woman, Shelly (not her real name). They dated for only a year or so before marrying. I don’t know her too well since...

My son dislikes her. He thinks Shelly is mentally unhinged, is way too involved in his personal business, and he blames her for being the reason he hasn’t been able...

An unexpected addition to the plans sparks conflict.

Earlier this week, I was coordinating with my ex about the details of our next tour. Everything was great until he mentioned that Shelly would be coming along on all...

ADVERTISEMENT

He said that she just wanted to be supportive. I asked him if her daughter was looking at these schools too, since she’s also going to be a senior, and...

I told him that our son should get a say in who comes to the tours and that I would ask him what he thought about Shelly joining us. After...

He immediately replied no and that he wasn’t comfortable with her coming. I told our son that he should speak with his father and let him know about what he...

ADVERTISEMENT

Fast forward to last night, my ex calls and is furious that I would “get our son involved in this matter.” I replied that our son is the one touring...

Not to mention, our son is almost an adult and at his age is more than capable of deciding who he wants in his life and to what extent. Son...

He accepts that his father loves her but he doesn’t see her as family. So I told my ex that if he loves his son and wants to continue having...

ADVERTISEMENT

End of story. Ex replies that I’m an AH, Shelly cares about our son, and that he should be allowed to bring his wife with him whenever he chooses.. Was...

An update provides resolution and further context.

UPDATE: First of all, thanks for the validation and the kind words some left. I’ve read nearly everything you all have left so thank you. I’d like to emphasize for...

ADVERTISEMENT

My son is 17 and more than capable of setting and enforcing his own boundaries. Also, since some expressed that it’s hypocritical for my husband to be there but not...

And ex is fine with him being there and it was never an issue in the first place. There’s also a lot more to the story behind why my son...

If it was up to me, I’d like him to get to know her better but, I understand his reasons, and I honor them. I’m certainly not pitting him against...

ADVERTISEMENT

I told him that I fully respected his choice and reminded him that he can share this experience with whomever he wants. I encouraged him to talk to his dad...

I also added that if he ultimately decided that he wanted to go on these tours alone or with just one parent to avoid drama (which I communicated might be...

It’s his tours, and his decisions. So he called his dad this morning and calmly told him that he didn’t want Shelly coming along on any of the tours and...

ADVERTISEMENT

and him not wanting an “entourage” accompanying him on his tours. “Five is a crowd, dad.” (I lol’d when he said that.) This time my ex was more receptive and...

But then he put son on the spot and told him he should to talk to Shelly directly about her not coming. He was not comfortable with that and requested...

So I got on the phone and repeated that this was our son’s decision. I didn’t say anything about son disliking Shelly or feeling uncomfortable around her, because that is...

ADVERTISEMENT

Shelly was clearly disappointed, and said she understood and only wanted an opportunity to bond with her new stepson. I replied that it was sweet of her to want to...

Overall, she seemed to be okay with it. We spoke for another minute or two and then she left the conversation and I talked to ex for a little while.

I reiterated to him that ever since Shelly came into the picture, our son feels like he doesn’t get as much quality time with his dad anymore because either she’s...

ADVERTISEMENT

(son doesn’t have an issue with his step-siblings but also I want to make sure ex makes time for his own kid). I also explained to him that if Shelly...

He said he understood where I was coming from and apologized for calling me an AH. I asked him if it was Shelly who was pushing this issue or if...

Based on his response, I got the sense that Shelly expressed an interest in going, was okay not going if that was really son’s decision,

ADVERTISEMENT

but my ex just really wants her to feel more like a part of his family so it’s a mix of him appeasing her but also wanting his son to...

So I gave him two choices: either he comes without Shelly and uses those opportunities to have special time with his son,

or he doesn’t come to the tours and we find a weekend for him and son to spend one-on-one time but either way, Shelly isn’t going to be there because...

ADVERTISEMENT

He said he’d think about his choices. So all good there! I hope he decides to leave Shelly at home and come to whatever tours he can because I know...

The primary issue revolves around a teenager’s boundaries during college tours in a blended family. The son’s discomfort with his new stepmother clashed with his father’s wish for inclusion. Co-parents navigated differing views on involvement, prioritizing the child’s comfort.

The mother supported her son’s autonomy. The father sought family unity. The stepmother aimed to bond. Open communication ultimately clarified needs, highlighting respect for the teen’s voice.

ADVERTISEMENT

Family therapist Dr. John Gray observes that “Blended families thrive when new relationships develop at the child’s pace, not forced timelines” (adapted from principles in “Children of the Self-Absorbed,” 2008). This emphasizes gradual integration over mandatory participation.

Encouraging direct expression from the teen builds confidence. Co-parents aligning on child-centered decisions prevents triangulation. Fathers carving one-on-one time strengthens bonds. Flexibility in plans accommodates evolving dynamics, fostering long-term harmony.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

The community largely supported the mother and son, stressing the teenager’s right to decide while critiquing the father’s initial push.

Most users affirmed the son’s authority over his college tours.

emohelelwhy − NTA, your son is the only person who gets any say here.

ADVERTISEMENT

Admirable_Scale_5075 − NTA. If your ex is more concerned about Shelly's feelings than his son's then maybe he should stay home with her.

poeadam − NTA You are correct that your son should have a say in the matter. Ex-husband needs to realize this is about his son, not about his new wife.

Owl_plantain − NTA. Your son should get to decide. However, he shouldn’t blame Shelly for his father’s choice to spend less time with him. Completely fair to dislike Shelly for...

ADVERTISEMENT

rak1882 − NTA Your son has the final say here. But honestly, your Ex- needs to hear himself. If Shelly cared about your son, Son should never have to say...

Shelly should be telling Ex-, hey you need to make sure that just cuz we're married and there are 3 more kids in the house that you aren't skipping time...

These college tours aren't a family bonding experience for Ex-, Shelly and Son and they aren't a chance for a romantic weekend away for Shelly and Ex-. They're about Son...

ADVERTISEMENT

eternal_casserole − NTA. Shelly hasn't been in your son's life long enough to have any impact on his college choices. There's no reason for her to be there stressing him...

chuckinhoutex − NTA- I'd just tell him one last time- dude- you are making your son super unhappy. If she actually cares about him, then she should respect his wishes...

The fact that she refuses says that this is about her, not him. Respecting your son's wishes does not make me an A. H. You cramming your wife, who already...

Just remember we had this conversation in a few years when you come to me asking me why he won't speak to you anymore.

[Reddit User] − Your ex needa to grow the f__k up, he has a child, the time to stop acting like a child himself was the second he became a...

AdOne8433 − NTA. This is another case of a parent trying to shove a step-parent down his poor child's throat. Your ex has no concern at all for his son.

He and his mama wannabe should both stay home because, if poor little wife doesn't get her way, he'll be making the trip all about her hurt feelings. It's a...

A minority saw hypocrisy or suggested compromise.

ten-year-old − Why would 3-4 adults need to go to each college tour with him? Just choose 1 for each tour and leave Shelly out of it since son doesn't...

teresajs − NTA No student needs four "parents" with them on their college tour. Shelly will most likely be bored and make everyone else miserable. I recommend you make future...

Also, have you discussed/arranged the split of college costs with your Ex yet? It's possible that Shelly could cause trouble when it comes to paying for college, especially if she...

If you don't already have clear plans regarding your son's college expenses, you might want to discuss this with your Family Attorney.

In some states that favor college support from divorced parents, the filing for amended support orders could possibly need to be filed before the student turns 18.

auntynell − I'm going to go against the general opinion here and say this isn't a hill to die on. I was in the same position as you; the ex...

I had nothing against her; didn't know her very well, and also knew my son could be a pain when he wanted to. I suggested to my ex it wasn't...

It went fine, the new wife came along but didn't interfere and many years later we are friends, and my son considers her part of the family, as do I....

Magdalina15 − So your husband can come cause you remarried sooner than your ex, and Shelly can't. Your son loves his stepdad cause he grew up with him,

but he hates Shelley because he is a moody teenager who thinks the evil witch is taking his dad away from him. And you are loving this because you have...

[Reddit User] − ESH. Your husband needs to read the room. You are clearly opposed to this woman and pushing your son to dislike her. Just book the tour with...

SummerJSmith − YTA / ESH. If step parent isn’t a valid title to tour with then it’s not a valid title period. Not step dad is okay but step mom...

One of four adults shouldn’t be singled out, three adults is also too many anyway. Take your son alone, let dad do the same, or just do mom and dad...

No kid wants a bunch of adults whole he’s trying to picture himself as an adult on a college campus alone, much less three or four of them with varying...

This was an insanely bias way to ask the son, and no one is actually realizing this trip revolves around him not the marriage. The relationship in question is him...

Let him focus on that, not parental relationships. The less adults the better. One tour with mom and dad together or separate and he’ll have both your perspectives ok questions...

This account shows the value of centering a teenager’s voice during major transitions in blended families. Respecting boundaries prevents resentment and models healthy relationships. The resolution highlights communication’s power in co-parenting.

Prioritizing the child’s comfort strengthens ties long-term. Should stepparents automatically join milestones, or wait for invitation? How can co-parents balance new spouses with quality time for biological kids?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *