AITA for refusing to be a surprise babysitter at the last minute?

A casual lunch invite turned into a wild escape when a 25-year-old woman found herself cornered into babysitting her friend’s rambunctious kids. Expecting pasta and chit-chat, she walked into a whirlwind of screaming tots and a friend itching to dash to the store—leaving her in charge. Unfazed by her protests, the friend pushed, but she bolted, shoes barely on.

This isn’t just about dodging diapers—it’s a clash of boundaries and sneaky plans. The friend’s silence since the incident speaks volumes, but was the hasty exit too much? Step into this frantic tale of friendship, chaos, and standing firm.

‘AITA for refusing to be a surprise babysitter at the last minute?’

A few weeks ago, my friend Wendy (29F) invited me (25F) over to her house for lunch. She is a single mom with two kids, ages 5 and 3. Wendy and I are not super close. We met at an old job and have hung out a few times before, just casual things like grabbing dinner after work. This was the first time she has invited me over to her house.

ADVERTISEMENT

When I arrived, her kids were screaming and racing around. The younger one slipped on the rug and started crying when I came in. The older one seemed to be taunting her and 'play-whacking' her with a doll. Overall, it was a chaotic atmosphere. Wendy told me she had forgotten the tomato sauce she needed for the pasta recipe she was preparing.

She said she was going to pop down to the store to grab it and would be back in 15 minutes. I hesitated because that would mean I would be alone with her kids, so I said that I could go to the store and get the sauce since she was busy with the kids. She refused and added that she might need to pick up a few more items other than the tomato sauce, so it would be best if she went.

I told her I wasn't comfortable being alone with her kids since I had no idea how to take care of children. Plus the kids weren't just quietly watching TV - they were literally running around the house, tripping over each other, and play fighting. I have no children and don't know the first thing about taking care of them.

ADVERTISEMENT

She repeated it would be 15 minutes tops and that I would be fine. I challenged that and said there was no way it would only take 15 minutes. What if there was a long line up at the cashier, or she had to wait for parking, etc. Her statement that she needed more than tomato sauce also implied she might take longer shopping than 15 minutes.

She started getting annoyed then and said something along the lines of, 'Why can't you just help out?' I was getting panicked about being left alone with the kids. As she started putting on her shoes, I quickly put my shoes back on too and ran out the door. She started screaming at me, telling me to come back. I was pretty frazzled and didn't want to hang out with her anymore, so I just said,

'Sorry, I have to go,' and got in my car and drove away. Afterwards I texted her to apologize for leaving, but I really wasn't comfortable watching her kids alone in case they got hurt. She has not responded since then and it's been 3 weeks.. AITA for overreacting and refusing to watch her kids alone for '15 minutes', subsequently leaving the hang out instead?

ADVERTISEMENT

A lunch date shouldn’t feel like a babysitting ambush, but for this woman, it did. Her friend’s insistence on leaving her with two energetic kids, despite her clear discomfort, crossed a line. The chaotic scene—kids screaming, tripping, and play-fighting—amped up her panic, while her friend downplayed the task as a quick 15-minute favor. The friend’s frustration when challenged hints at a deeper intent: free childcare disguised as hospitality.

This taps into a broader issue of social pressure on women to take on caregiving roles. A 2023 study by the Pew Research Center found 59% of women feel obligated to prioritize others’ needs over their own (source). The friend’s tactic—using guilt to push childcare—reflects this, ignoring her guest’s inexperience and unease.

Dr. Susan Newman, a social psychologist, notes, “Boundaries are critical in friendships; assuming consent for responsibilities like childcare can erode trust” (source). Here, the woman’s swift exit was a bold defense of her limits. Her friend’s silence suggests resentment, but the real issue is her lack of respect.

ADVERTISEMENT

For solutions, the woman could initiate a calm conversation, explaining her discomfort and seeking mutual understanding. If the friendship continues, clear expectations for future meetups are key. Delivery apps or curbside pickup, as Reddit suggested, could’ve avoided this mess.

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit lit up with laughter and support, roasting the friend’s sneaky move with some epic shade. Here’s the community’s take on this wild lunch gone wrong:

beelovedone − NTA I am so sorry but I am CACKLING at the idea of you racing to get your shoes on and get out the door before her, and a slew of loud a$$ kids in the background yelling as you peel off down the street lol. Sounds like she invited you over to babysit.

ADVERTISEMENT

TracyMinOB − NTA. She was using a bait and switch technique. Guaranteed she would have run all kinds of errands and been gone all day.

Alternative_Year_340 − NTA it sounds like this might have been the reason you were invited over at all.

lumoslomas − NTA she was DEFINITELY setting you up to be a babysitter whilst she went out. Who leaves their kids with someone who is a) uncomfortable with looking after kids, and b) they don't have any experience with kids????

ADVERTISEMENT

Alyssa_Hargreaves − NTA.. She was trying to set you up. She figured you wouldn't say no so she could 'go to the store' and I can assure you that '15 minutes' would've turned into 2hrs and her walking in with a lot more than tomato sauce and a couple small items.

Their are delivery apps, yes a bit expensive but she could've used those, or curb side delivery, threw the kids in the car and did that etc. She was playing on the hopes you'd say yes to be polite and she was gonna run for it regardless of your yes or no. If she had gotten her shoes on and was out the door before you she would've been.

ThrowAwayCatBalloon − I'm going with NTA. you offered to go get the sauce. She could go grocery shopping for those 'few more items' she needs when she isn't planning on dropping her kids on a friend like that.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA That really sounds like she planned this and only wanted you over for watching the kids while she could relax and go shopping.. If she needed more she could write a groceries list and ask you to go for her. The kids are solely her responsibility and she can't just shove them in somebody's face for who knows how long.

Fun_Computer_8401 − NTA it seems she needed some time away from her kids, and it's ok. But she should ask someone closer, or at least really ASK you instead of forcing you 5o 'surprise babysit'

Opagea − NTA She refused and added that she might need to pick up a few more items other than the tomato sauce, so it would be best if she went.. So write the items down. That she was so insistent on going herself makes it pretty obvious that she was going to dump the kids on you for an extended period of time.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. I’m a parent and I don’t even Iike watching someone else’s kids, especially when I have no time to mentally prepare.

These comments are gold, but do they capture the whole vibe? Was the friend’s plan a clever trap, or just a desperate mom’s misstep?

This lunch-turned-babysitting fiasco proves boundaries aren’t just lines—they’re lifelines. The woman’s quick dash out the door wasn’t just about escaping chaos; it was about protecting her peace from a friend’s sly agenda. With the friend now ghosting, the fallout lingers, but the lesson’s clear: no one’s owed your comfort. Ever been roped into a favor you didn’t sign up for? Drop your story below—let’s keep this convo buzzing!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *