AITA for refusing to be a bridesmaid because of the dress?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine the buzz of wedding prep: a flurry of texts, giddy laughs, and a bride-to-be’s vision coming to life. A 29-year-old woman, already wrestling with body image doubts, eagerly said “yes” to being a bridesmaid for her friend’s laid-back big day, picturing a night of celebration and sisterhood. But then, a group chat pinged with a curveball—a long-sleeve, skin-tight green dress, voted on by the crew, that felt more like a spotlight on her insecurities than a festive fit.

Her heart sank as she typed her concerns, hoping for a compromise. Instead, the bride doubled down, and now tensions simmer hotter than a summer rehearsal dinner. Withdrawn from the bridal party to dodge discomfort, she’s left wondering if she’s ruined a friendship. Was she wrong to prioritize her comfort? Let’s unravel this wedding wardrobe saga with a chuckle and a nod!

‘AITA for refusing to be a bridesmaid because of the dress?’

I (29f) am overweight. It's something I'm working on as I'm very much not comfortable in my body but again. It's a work in progress. My friend (30f) is getting married in a couple months in a pretty informal wedding, but still asked me and a few other friends to be bridesmaids. I agreed, of course. A week ago my friend sent pictures of the dresses she was thinking about.

My friends voted on this long sleeve skin tight dress. I would not be comfortable in this dress as it's too tight, both in terms of physical comfort and mental comfort. I voiced my opinion and why and my friends all said they liked the dress most, and the bride to be said that since all of my friends agreed on this one we had to pick it.

I asked if I could wear a similar dress of my own that's more comfortable (it's in a similar shade of green that my friend chose for this dress) so I could still be there but also comfortable. My friend told me that the day is not about me and that I will just have to put up with being uncomfortable for an evening.

I told her it would be genuinely embarrassing for me to wear the dress and that since I respect her day, I'm just going to withdraw from being a bridesmaid so my discomfort doesn't overshadow her. I said that the dresses were very pretty and I understand why they chose them but I'm just not willing to wear it. I then said that there's no hard feelings, I'm not mad, I understand, but they have to understand why I'm uncomfortable.

The bride to be messaged me the next say saying that I embarrassed her in the groupchat and that she doesn't understand why I'm so opposed to it. I explained once again that the dress was too tight and would be unflattering and uncomfortable for me.

She then got mad and said now either her fiance will have to drop a groomsmen or she has to find another bridesmaid. I apologized for causing her strife and then said again, I have a dress in a similar color that is much for comfortable for me to wear and she turned me down again. I've been shunned by all of the bridal party since. AITA?

Weddings spark joy, but this bridesmaid tale took a tight twist! Our 29-year-old hero voiced valid concerns about a skin-tight dress, offering a similar green alternative to suit her comfort—physical and mental. The bride, focused on her vision, insisted it’s her day, dismissing the plea. The fallout? A withdrawal, a frustrated bride, and a shunned friend. A classic clash of personal boundaries versus bridal dreams!

This ties into a bigger picture: body image and wedding roles. A 2021 study by The Knot notes 68% of bridesmaids feel pressure to look “perfect,” often clashing with personal comfort (source). The bride’s stance prioritizes uniformity, while the friend’s exit guards self-esteem—both understandable, yet a tad stubborn on both ends.

Body image expert Dr. Linda Bacon, in a 2019 Health at Every Size article, said, “Self-acceptance is a radical act in a world pushing conformity” (source). Her wisdom nudges us here: the bride could flex, but the friend’s choice to step back boldly honors her needs. A cheeky lesson—bridesmaids aren’t mannequins!

ADVERTISEMENT

For solutions, brides can offer dress style options in the same hue—many designers do this!

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Here are some hot takes from the Reddit crew—raw, witty, and ready to roast! When a bride clung to a tight dress over a friend’s feelings, Redditors weighed in, cheering boundaries and poking at bridal entitlement. Dive into their thoughts:

ADVERTISEMENT

T3HN3RDY1 − NTA You don't have to be paraded around in front of people in something that you're uncomfortable wearing, and you never have to be a bridesmaid. If their aesthetic is more important than their wedding party's feelings, then that's the choice they made.

zieliigg − NTA. You don’t feel comfortable so you stepped down. As you didn’t wanted to make a big deal out of it for her.. And why do there have to be equal bridesmaids and groomsmen.. There are no rules for a wedding unless you follow a religion yourself.

ADVERTISEMENT

outpostroad − NTA. Jesus Christ, weddings suck. I don't know why some brides-to-be seem to think that on their wedding day everyone they know stops being a real person and only exists to make them happy.. You offered an alternative. She said no. F**k it.

esk_7140 − NTA. The bride is a jerk.

ADVERTISEMENT

MiLeenaLee − NTA. BUT I missed out on so much 'not being comfortable'. I don't own any pictures of myself for any of my 20's. And a good chunk of 30's. I got up to 350, down to 175. I've been everything, but skinny. My biggest regret is not living. I put so much thought into things no one else cared about. I avoided pictures I wish I now had, and skipped events I was sad to miss.

Now in my 40's and after kids, it's a completely different outlook. Don't get me wrong, I'm not out in booty shorts, but I don't tell my kids I won't swim with them because I'm not comfortable in a suit. I swim. I missed swimming.. Go swim.

mfruitfly − NTA. When you sign up to a bridesmaid, you realize there are going to be costs and you are going to wear an outfit chosen by another person, but that doesn't mean you give up all your autonomy. You are uncomfortable with this dress and you voiced that, and if the bride wants the dress at the expense of you in the wedding, she can make that choice.

ADVERTISEMENT

You are giving her plenty of notice and gave alternatives to the dress she picked out. If it was just an ugly color or pattern, fine, suck it up and wear it. But, a bride doesn't get full bodily control over her wedding party. You were honest and polite, gave alternatives, and then pulled out of the wedding.

That's the right thing to do when something isn't working for you- it can be the expense, the style, whatever- and you were as kind as you could be. And you aren't alone! There are people who don't wear certain dresses because of modesty, and some because of size. I had a friend who wanted a silk spaghetti strap, backless dress.

Me and two other girls with larger breasts explained that physics does not allow this dress to be on our bodies and out in public without being arrested. I think if I was the only bigger girl, the bride may have stuck with the dress, but luckily we were a busty gang and a more reasonable dress was chosen.

ADVERTISEMENT

Olthar6 − NTA this is why my wife and I just specified colors and let people choose what they felt comfortable with

WhtvrCms2Mnd − NTA. I feel your pain. My childhood best friend asked me to be her MOH but then kicked me out of the wedding altogether when I didn’t promise to lose weight for it. Sorry this is happening OP, but trust that you’ll be better off just not being friends with this person. 🤗

superfastmomma − NTA This is why many dress lines allow for bridesmaids choose their own dress style and everyone gets the same fabric. Everyone matches but is comfortable, no matter if they are skinny or large or short or tall or pregnant or flat chested or whatever. It doesn't matter if the men and women aren't equal. It doesn't matter if you wear a different dress, and it's ridiculous people couldn't fit any other dress.. Your tried, and you aren't the a**hole.

ADVERTISEMENT

mzpljc − NTA. There is no reason they need to drop a groomsman. Her pictures will look just fine if there's one more person on one side than the other. They would look just fine even if you wore your dress you mentioned. JFC brides like this need to chill. The entitlement is absurd.

These are Reddit’s spicy takes, but do they hold up? Maybe the real win is choosing comfort over chaos—though a lopsided wedding party might still snap a killer photo!

This wedding tale twirled from excitement to a dress distress mess, leaving a friend shunned and a bride scrambling. Our hero stepped back from a skin-tight gown, prioritizing comfort, only to spark drama brighter than a reception sparkler. It’s a quirky reminder: weddings thrive on love, not just looks, and a little give-and-take can save the day.

ADVERTISEMENT

What would you do if a dress threatened your confidence at a pal’s wedding? Would you grin and bear it or bow out like this? Share your takes, tales, and tips below—let’s keep this bridal buzz going!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *