AITA for not wanting to get involved in any wedding do-over after SIL’s wedding was ruined

Imagine your boyfriend’s 37-year-old sister’s potluck wedding imploding—guests bailed, the friend-DJ flubbed, and now she’s crushed, dreaming of a do-over. You’re 41, roped in to help by your 39-year-old boyfriend, but your sister-in-law’s a picky nightmare with no budget, and you’re dreading the clash.

You suggest a photo redo in their rented gear, they want a full bash, and your offer of shop dresses (for sale, not free) sparks a fight—boyfriend snaps you’re kicking family when they’re down. Asshole for bowing out, or just dodging a redo disaster? She’s weeping, he’s guilting, and you’re stuck. Let’s sift through this wedding wreckage.

‘AITA for not wanting to get involved in any wedding do-over after SIL’s wedding was ruined?’

Planning a wedding redo after a flop is like trying to reheat a soggy soufflé—it rarely works. Our redditor’s caught in a tug-of-war: her boyfriend wants family support, while she’s guarding her peace (and dresses). SIL’s chasing a redo, but her track record screams trouble.

The original plan imploded because guests balked at potluck duties—fair, since most expect to eat, not cater. SIL’s dissatisfaction and tight budget clash with her grand vision, leaving OP wary. Meanwhile, her boyfriend’s loyalty blinds him to her valid boundaries. Dr. Terri Orbuch, a relationship expert, notes, “Healthy relationships balance individual needs with mutual support” (from Psychology Today). Here, OP’s need for distance is drowned out.

Weddings often expose bigger truths. A 2023 WeddingWire report says 40% of couples face guest RSVP stress—SIL’s hit that hard. Solution? Skip the redo party. Suggest a photo shoot in those rented outfits—cheap, chic, and drama-free. Readers, what’s your take?

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit’s peanut gallery brought the sass and wisdom, serving up opinions spicier than a potluck hot dish. Here’s the scoop from the crowd—unfiltered and ready to stir the pot.

These quips hit hard, but do they cut to the core? The crowd’s split between “flee the scene” and “offer a tissue, not a redo.” It’s a lively debate worth digging into.

So, our redditor’s dodging a wedding encore like it’s a bad dance move. SIL’s heartbreak is real, but a redo might just double the disappointment. Maybe a quiet photo session beats a shaky second act. Our heroine’s balancing empathy, a pushy boyfriend, and her own limits—talk about a tightrope! What would you do—jump in to save the day or politely bow out? Ever faced a family favor that felt like a setup? Drop your thoughts below and let’s chat!