AITA For Doubting My Late Boyfriend’s Loyalty After Mysterious Discoveries?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 1 Comment

In a quiet room, a 29-year-old woman clutches a box marked with her initial, its contents a Pandora’s box of memories she’s too heartbroken to open. Just a month ago, her boyfriend of three years, the man she planned to build a life with, died tragically. Their love felt flawless, but now, a stranger’s tears at his grave and a box from his past threaten to unravel it all. Was he the man she thought, or did he hide a secret?

Grief is heavy enough, but suspicion adds a sharper edge. The woman, torn between cherishing his memory and fearing betrayal, faces an agonizing choice: dig for the truth or let the past rest. As she navigates this emotional minefield, her story pulls us into the fragile space where love, loss, and doubt collide. Readers, brace for a heart-wrenching tale of trust tested by tragedy.

‘AITA For Doubting My Late Boyfriend’s Loyalty After Mysterious Discoveries?’

 I was with my boyfriend for 3 years we had a beautiful and perfect relationship he was a wonderful man in every way and just a month ago he died tragically and unexpectedly, both his family and I have been devastated and inconsolable for this.

We were going to move in together and he was taken from me. About 2 weeks ago her mother approached me with a box that she found while cleaning his room he would occasionally visit her and he used to stay overnight so his room was kept intact like when he lived permanently there.

She had decided to tidy up and clean his room because she was in a better state and she found a box with the initial of my name she didn't open it but could see superficially that they were things like letters some dried roses among other things that she decided not to look at further because thought they were my things or about us so she thought it would be best to give it to me and I could review those things alone.

I thanked her but I didn't feel ready to see all these things so I put the box away. A couple of days ago I went to visit his grave as I got closer I could see a woman there I immediately stopped to see if I could recognize her but it was not a family member or friend she had brought flowers and I could see that she was crying I was afraid to approach since I didn't know who she was,

and I simply waited at a safe distance she left after a few minutes and didn't even turn to look at me. Well, it seemed obvious to me that I don't know her. That whole night I couldn't sleep thinking about this woman, who is she? Where did she know him from? I knew all his family, friends and people from his work and I didn't recognize her from anywhere.

I couldn't be calm or sleep those days because I thought of many possibilities and he was no longer there so I could ask him. I decided to go to his friends and tell them what happened. As soon as I described the woman, they looked at each other nervously and seemed to know who it was but they didn't say anything.

I insisted and cried a lot, I told them that I deserved to know if I had the wrong image of my boyfriend. Finally, they told me that it was his ex and one of them confessed to having informed her about his death and his resting place because he believed that he would have liked it she went to see him I felt like my heart fell to my feet I asked everything I could it turns out that they had studied together since elementary school,

and my boyfriend had been in love with her since then in high school they started a relationship that lasted approximately 4 years and then they were on and off until just 2 years before we started a relationship he told me that according to what they knew they had cut off all contact 5 years ago but they didn't know for sure if this was true I asked him for his name,

and his name begins with the same initial as mine so now I don't know what to think I don't know if I should contact her to ask if she was with my boyfriend at the same time as me I know that the first thing I should do is check that damn box and see if there are any of my things or things about her but I can't, I'm so afraid of destroying this image I had of my boyfriend of the man I thought he was.

I don't know what to do I was already devastated to lose him but now I could also lose all the beautiful memories I have of him if I finally found out that he was cheating on me. His friends tell me to leave the issue alone because he is no longer here to defend himself.

The OP’s dropped an update on the saga—curious? Click here to check it out!

Grief is a storm, and suspicion is its cruelest gust. This woman’s discovery of a box and a grieving ex at her boyfriend’s grave has cracked the pedestal she placed him on. Her hesitation to investigate reflects a natural fear: truth could shatter her cherished memories, but ignorance leaves her in torment.

Grief counselor Megan Devine explains, “Grief complicates everything, including how we process betrayal. Seeking truth can be healing, but it’s a deeply personal choice” (Refuge in Grief). Here, the boyfriend’s ex and the box suggest a past he didn’t fully share, but no evidence confirms infidelity. His friends’ silence and the ex’s delayed knowledge of his death lean against an active affair.

A 2021 study found 68% of bereaved individuals struggle with unresolved questions about their loved one (American Psychological Association). Her pain mirrors a universal dilemma: how to honor love while facing doubts. Devine suggests journaling to weigh whether truth-seeking will bring closure or more pain.

For solutions, she could ask her boyfriend’s mother to review the box’s contents neutrally, preserving her memories if it’s unrelated to cheating. A grief therapist could guide her through this turmoil.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s stepping into this emotional quagmire with empathy and tough love, offering perspectives that range from cautious to blunt. Here’s what the community had to say:

DearDorothy − This seems above reddits pay grade honestly. Have you thought of finding a therapist who has a lot of experience in grief? It sounds like you haven’t gone into the box so you don’t even know if they were in contact. It’s common to still grieve for your ex, even if you were no contact.

It’s also common to retain mementos from past relationships, especially young ones. My highschool partner died a couple years ago and even though I’ve been 0 contact for years I still went through some grieving.. Did he give you anything to be suspicious of when he was alive?

Choice-Intention-926 − If he was having an affair she would have known of his passing sooner. I don’t believe they were in touch. The box may be momentos of their time together. Lots of people keep those. When a relationship ends you pack up all of the sentimental stuff that would normally be on display during the relationship. I think your boyfriend was who you thought he was.

Glinda-The-Witch − Based on what you have said here, your boyfriend had a prior long-term girlfriend, and it’s entirely possible he kept some mementos from that relationship. Especially if they ended it on good terms. He may have forgotten about the box, but even if he didn’t, she was still a part of his life at one point.

Remember that everyone who crosses your path today, impacts who you are tomorrow. It’s very possible that he would have disposed of those items once you and he moved in together. I see no reason for you to contact her. Clearly, she didn’t know he had passed until his friends reached out to her.

If he was cheating with her, she probably would have known right away. Take a moment to think how you would feel if someone from your past died. You would probably feel sad and maybe even consider attending the funeral or visiting the gravesite.

Perhaps you could return the box to his mother and explain to her that you have not opened it, but you are concerned that it may be mementos from a previous relationship and you don’t feel like you could handle seeing those. Perhaps she could go through the box and do whatever she felt should be done with the contents.

If they are things from your relationship, then she can return them to you. It sounds as if your boyfriend was a good man, who touched the hearts of many of his current and former friends who are grieving his loss. Suggest you find a grief counselor to help you through this very difficult time. I’m sorry for your loss.

MaggieLuisa − There were people he dated in the past, he had a box of mementos from one relationship, and that person grieved after being told of his death.. None of that means he cheated on you.

GZA_top5 − Firstly, OP I’m very sorry for your loss. Losing a loved one is hard regardless of what they may or may not have done. Grief counseling is in order here. See a professional to help with the passing please. I would really advise against following any advice you get here on this matter. This is definitely a complicated issue and I would steer you towards a professional’s assistance and the love of your friends and family on this. You have my thoughts, and I really wish you the best OP <3

Comeback_321 − Give the box back to his mother. It’s not your box. Everyone has a history. That doesn’t mean he cheated on you. Don’t destroy yourself for no reason. Just tell her you think this is someone from his past and you would rather not go through it and preserve the love you have with him and for him.

Nothing else needs to be done. At this point it doesn’t matter because you don’t know and won’t know. So don’t ruin your memories with questions that can’t be answered. Talking to a grief counselor may help. I can’t see what you gain or how you would have better closure ripping up your memories. 

lozit93 − I'm so sorry this happened, but please - paragraphs and punctuation.

Particular_Song_229 − No. He’s dead. Investigating really serves no purpose and will likely hinder you’re moving on

mustang19671967 − See a therapist. What will. You accomplish by finding out

Not-nuts − Why cause yourself pain.

These Redditors grapple with her pain, but is letting go the only path, or does closure demand answers? What’s the right move in this haze of grief?

This woman’s story is a gut-punch: losing a partner is brutal, but doubting their love is a fresh wound. Whether she opens that box or buries her suspicions, her journey reminds us how grief can twist trust into torment. If you faced a loved one’s hidden past, would you dig deeper or hold tight to the good memories? Share your thoughts and experiences below—let’s explore how to navigate love’s shadows after loss.

For those who want to read the sequel: [UPDATE] AITA For Doubting My Late Boyfriend’s Loyalty After Mysterious Discoveries?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One Comment

  1. Pingback: [UPDATE] AITA For Doubting My Late Boyfriend’s Loyalty After Mysterious Discoveries? - Movies & TV update: News, Reviews and Trending