AITA for disowning my maid of honor after her behavior at my wedding?

A dream wedding turned sour when the maid of honor, Carly, stole the spotlight with her selfish antics. The OP, a quiet introvert, endured Carly’s domineering behavior for years, but her disruptive actions at the bachelorette party and wedding day—plus an underwhelming gift—pushed the bride to her limit.

Now, the OP wants to cut ties, wary of Carly’s defensive blowups. This Reddit tale unpacks friendship, loyalty, and tough choices—was the OP right to consider disowning her friend, or should she try to mend things?

‘AITA for disowning my maid of honor after her behavior at my wedding?’

Friendships can fray like a worn dress when one friend’s dominance overshadows mutual respect. Carly’s behavior—arguing at the bachelorette, demanding extra services on the wedding day, and giving a thoughtless gift—reveals a pattern of self-centeredness that clashed with the OP’s quieter nature. The OP’s urge to disown Carly stems from exhaustion, but her hesitation reflects care for their nine-year bond.

Relationship expert Dr. Irene Levine, author of Best Friends Forever, notes, “Unbalanced friendships drain when one person consistently prioritizes themselves.” Studies show 60% of friendships end due to mismatched expectations, especially when one friend avoids accountability, as Carly does. The OP’s introversion makes confrontation tough, amplifying the strain.

This highlights a broader issue: navigating draining friendships. The OP could try a firm but kind talk, outlining specific grievances, though Carly’s defensiveness may derail it. A slow fade—less contact, fewer plans—might be less explosive. Therapy could help the OP process guilt and set boundaries.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit’s crew didn’t hold back, slamming Carly’s antics with a mix of outrage and witty shade while debating the OP’s role in letting it slide. From calls to cut ties to advice on tough talks, the comments are a lively clash. Here’s what the community tossed out:

These Reddit quips are sharp, but do they hit the mark? Is the OP justified in dropping Carly, or partly to blame for not confronting her sooner?

This wedding drama shows that even close friendships can unravel when respect runs dry. Carly’s selfish stunts at the OP’s wedding, paired with years of overbearing behavior, justify the OP’s desire to move on, though her guilt hints at lingering care. A clear talk or gradual distance could free the OP without a blowout, letting her focus on uplifting bonds. What would you do if a friend hijacked your special day? Drop your stories and tips below!