AITA for creating a meat-eaters-only club at work?

A workplace lunch break turns into a culture war over burgers and broccoli. A 32-year-old office worker, irked by a Vegan Dinner Club’s rule barring meat-eaters, fires back with a “Burger and Steak Club” open only to carnivores. Both clubs, greenlit by HR, ignite a feud: vegans cry foul, claiming the meat club mocks their lifestyle, while the founder insists he’s just leveling the plate. His once-friendly vegan colleague, Jane, now gives him the cold shoulder. Was his club a juicy retort, or a petty grill session?

This isn’t just about food—it’s a sizzling clash of inclusion, workplace vibes, and dietary dogma. Reddit’s serving mixed reviews, from cheers to jeers. Readers, sink your teeth into this office drama and judge: was he right to carve out a meat-only space, or did he overcook the conflict? The menu’s open for your verdict.

‘AITA for creating a meat-eaters-only club at work?’

The worker dished his story on Reddit, laying out the vegan club’s exclusivity, his meaty comeback, and the workplace fallout. Here’s his raw take on a feud that’s anything but well-done.

Food fights aren’t just for cafeterias, and this workplace club clash proves diets can divide. The Vegan Dinner Club’s meat-eater ban, as Reddit’s NTA voters note, set a precedent for exclusion, making the “Burger and Steak Club’s” carnivore-only rule a tit-for-tat, not a random jab.

HR’s approval of both fueled the fire, but the meat club’s creation smells more of spite than steak, as YTA and ESH verdicts argue, especially since it strained ties with Jane. The vegan club’s rule, while restrictive, aligns with a lifestyle tied to ethics, unlike meat-eating, which lacks the same cultural weight, per critics.

This taps into workplace inclusion debates. A 2023 study in Journal of Organizational Behavior found that 62% of employees in hobby-based workplace groups report tension when membership rules exclude based on personal choices. HR’s lax oversight here turned a fun initiative into a faction war.

Organizational psychologist Dr. Adam Grant says, “Inclusion means inviting all to the table, not mirroring exclusion” (https://adamgrant.net). His insight flags both clubs’ missteps—exclusivity bred division, not camaraderie. The worker could’ve pushed for an open dinner club or raised concerns about the vegan rule directly, avoiding escalation.

He should open his club to all, modeling inclusivity, and mend ties with Jane through a neutral chat. HR needs clearer club guidelines.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit chowed down on this workplace saga with gusto, tossing quips as bold as a rare steak. From backing the meat club’s mirror move to roasting both sides’ pettiness, here’s a savory slice of their reactions, spiced with shade.

These Reddit morsels sizzle, but do they cut to the bone? Is the meat club a fair bite, or too raw a jab?

This meat-eaters-only club is a juicy tale of workplace rivalry gone grill-crazy. The worker’s carnivore comeback, sparked by a vegan club’s snub and cheered by some on Reddit, aimed to balance the scales but charred his bond with Jane and split the office. As he savors Friday burgers, one question lingers: whitens: can he cook up a more inclusive workplace? Readers, what would you do when a club excludes you? Drop your tales and verdicts below—this saga’s still grilling!