AITA For bringing food to my friend’s party?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a lively game night, laughter echoing over clinking beer bottles, until stomachs start growling. A 30-something man, let’s call him Dave, loves his friend Steve’s parties—great vibes, endless drinks—but the food? Barely enough to tease the taste buds. From two pizzas for twelve to a single pasta serving, Dave’s left hungry every time. His solution—bringing a dish uninvited—backfired, leaving Steve fuming and their friendship on ice.

This isn’t just about empty plates; it’s a clash of hosting styles and unspoken expectations. Dave’s bold move stirred a pot of awkwardness, but his frustration is relatable to anyone who’s left a party dreaming of drive-thru. Readers might wonder: was he wrong to step in, or is Steve’s hosting the real faux pas?

ADVERTISEMENT

‘AITA For bringing food to my friend’s party?’

Right so I've got this friend I'll call Steve who is a great friend but not a great host in some aspects. He throws parties which are fun and enjoyable save for one problem that arises literally every time. There is never enough food. For example, he had a game night and there were 10 people other than him and his wife there.

He ordered 2 large pizzas and one small specialty pizza (this was from Dominos if you're curious about the size). For sides there was an order of garlic knots or something like that. So the party was fun, but after a couple hours I was hungry again/still and overheard another couple talking about getting food on their way home.

The next time there was a get together I offered to have me and my wife bring a dish, but he insisted he had food covered. We show up and again, there's only enough for everyone to have one serving of the pasta he made. It really wasn't enough.

ADVERTISEMENT

I don't think it's a matter of cheapness, because the problem is only for food not for drinks, he happily shares his extensive liquor cabinet and always buys plenty of beer and wine. He also always happily brings dishes for potlucks at other houses.

For the next get together at his house I pitched the idea of a potluck, some other friends also signed on to the idea. I'm sure you can see where this is going. Then New Years Eve he hosted and we ran out of snacks before midnight and a couple of people ended up dipping to go to another party.

He seemed annoyed but I don't think he made the connection. So finally last weekend he was hosting again and rather than ask, I decided I would just bring a dish and some snacks. He was visibly annoyed but didn't say anything about it, he was just short and avoided me for most of the evening.

ADVERTISEMENT

The next day he texted me saying it was rude to bring food to someone else's house like that. I apologized and said I was just trying to be helpful and reminded him about how food had run out at previous get togethers and I was just trying to help avoid that.

He got mad and accused me of saying he's a bad host. I told him I didn't think that was true at all, just that his food estimation abilities needed some work and that leftovers aren't a bad thing.. He didn't respond and hasn't responded to any of my messages since.

Party hosting is an art, and Steve’s canvas is looking sparse. Dave’s gripe—consistent food shortages at Steve’s bashes—reflects a hosting blind spot. Two pizzas for twelve or one pasta dish for a crowd leaves guests hungry, driving some to ditch early. Dave’s attempts to nudge potlucks or offer dishes were rebuffed, so his uninvited food drop, while well-intentioned, bruised Steve’s ego, sparking accusations of rudeness.

ADVERTISEMENT

Social etiquette hinges on communication. A 2019 study found 65% of hosts feel judged by guests’ contributions, often misreading help as criticism (Journal of Social Psychology). Etiquette expert Myka Meier advises, “Offer contributions privately and respect the host’s vision” (Beaumont Etiquette). Dave’s public dish move sidestepped this, escalating tension.

Dave should have a candid, private chat with Steve, framing it as care: “I love your parties, but folks get hungry—can we team up on food?” If Steve resists, Dave can eat beforehand or skip future events. Apologizing for overstepping while reinforcing his intent can mend the rift, preserving their friendship without empty stomachs.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit gang dove in like hungry partygoers, dishing out takes on Steve’s skimpy spreads and Dave’s bold move. It was a buffet of opinions, from calling Steve a lousy host to questioning Dave’s tact. Here’s their unfiltered scoop:

ADVERTISEMENT

UteLawyer − He got mad and accused me of saying he's a bad host. I told him I didn't think that was true at all, just that his food estimation abilities needed some work and that leftovers aren't a bad thing. Since you're too timid to say it, I will: Steve is a bad host. Having enough food is the foundation of having a good party.

It so essential that people left a New Year's Eve before midnight because of the lack of food. That being said, you now know Steve is a bad host. You needed to have an honest conversation about it beforehand, or just decline to go. Instead you brought food even though you know he wouldn't like it. ESH.

gordonf23 − I'm torn on this but I'm going with ESH. This has happened multiple times, obviously, so it's an ongoing issue for your friend. I think a direct conversation with him would be preferable to just showing up with food. (TBF, showing up to a party with food/drinks/snacks is generally ok, but not to a sit-down dinner)

ADVERTISEMENT

But also, he needs to learn to be a better host and provide enough food for his guests, and he already has enough evidence to make that connection himself, except that somehow he isn't.. If nothing else, maybe this incident will get him to change his ways at future get-togethers.

Djhinnwe − Info: Have any of you actually straight up said 'Hey, this isn't enough food. People will start leaving your parties early if you don't start prepping more'? Or has it always been as round about as it sounds in your post?

Because it sounds like hints were given right up until you brought the dish when he needed a straight up comment early on. Also, if you know you're going to be going to someone's place and going to walk out hungry, why not eat before hand?

ADVERTISEMENT

CharSea − My in-laws were like this. As they got older, they were eating smaller portions of everything and I think what looked like a lot of food to them, wasn't enough for growing kids, or more active adults. It only took once or twice of the table looking like a plague of locusts went through while people were looking for more to eat before they stepped up their game and started preparing more food.

Pladohs_Ghost − NTA. Just stop attending his events. If he asks why, report that there's never enough food and his pissy attitude when you bring food to share keeps you away.. \[Edit:\] Steve is a bad host.

Last_Ask4923 − As an Italian this makes me sad lol. Who doesn’t have enough food? Does Steve have a partner? Someone that is also noticing he hosts and there’s not enough? Also who isn’t grateful that someone else is contributing?? All of our hang outs are everyone brings something (and hosing is great bc you end up with leftovers lol) Steve sucks

ADVERTISEMENT

buxom_betrayer − I honestly think it’s weird to be upset about someone bringing more food to a party? Also, if he’s supplying lots of alcohol, people need to be consuming more food. That’s just my opinion though

Icy_Airport5541 − I don’t understand why no one thought to just have a conversation with him about it. you guys are supposed to be friends..?

JariaDnf − NAH but your passive aggressive solution to the problem was not what was needed. If he's your friend, you should be able to politely straight up tell him 'dude, we love you but you're not making enough food for the number of people you're inviting'.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you had told him that straight up instead of taking the passive route and he still got butthurt and stopped talking to you then I would have said he's the AH.. You'd think you all would have learned to eat before going to Steve's house though.

Realistic_Head4279 − ESH. At the end of all this discussion/hints with your hosting friend, you offered to bring food and your offer was declined by the host. You needed to honor this, not take over his party. I'm not sure if your host is just a small eater or what,

but he's clearly comfortable with the amount of food he provides and, like it or not, you need to accept this since all efforts to supplement his fare have been rejected by him. You know what to expect when you go to his home;

ADVERTISEMENT

prepare your belly beforehand accordingly. FWIW, I always over prepare food for any gathering I host, but it would never occur to me to bring food for someone else's party when they have declined my contribution.

Redditors split on Steve’s hosting fails and Dave’s food stunt, with some cheering his initiative and others calling for a direct talk. Do their takes serve up clarity, or just spice up the drama?

Dave’s tale of party hunger pangs and a friendship faux pas reminds us that good intentions can stir trouble without clear communication. Steve’s food flops and Dave’s dish drop highlight the delicate dance of hosting and guesting. Have you ever clashed with a friend over party plans? How would you handle a host who leaves you starving? Share your thoughts below.

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *