AITA for being upset my brother ruined the dessert I made for Thanksgiving and replaced it with one I couldn’t eat?

A Thanksgiving table groans with warmth, but one dessert disaster sours the feast. An 18-year-old vegan, tasked with crafting a lactose-free pumpkin pie, pours heart into a treat everyone can savor. Tucked safely in the fridge, it’s a creamy promise of inclusion—until their 30-year-old brother’s carelessness sends it crashing, shattering a cherished French pie plate. His store-bought replacement, laced with cream, leaves them sidelined at dessert, fuming. He calls them a brat for their anger. Was their flare-up a justified spice, or a bitter overbake?

This isn’t just about pie—it’s a recipe for family friction, dietary respect, and broken treasures. Reddit’s serving up support, but a crumb of doubt lingers. Readers, carve into this holiday havoc and decide: was their anger a righteous roast, or too hot to handle? The table’s set for your verdict.

‘AITA for being upset my brother ruined the dessert I made for Thanksgiving and replaced it with one I couldn’t eat?’

The young baker dished their frustration on Reddit, spilling the saga of a ruined pie, a thoughtless swap, and a brother’s shrug. Here’s their raw tale of a Thanksgiving treat turned tragedy.

A pie’s not just pastry—it’s a labor of love, and this vegan teen’s shattered dessert was a gut-punch. Their brother’s carelessness, wrecking a vegan pumpkin pie and a heirloom plate, stung deeply, as Reddit’s NTA chorus chants. His last-minute swap for a creamy, inedible pie—without a heads-up—left them isolated at their own family’s feast, compounding the hurt. His “brat” jab and lack of real apology, despite knowing their dietary needs, show a disregard that’s tough to swallow, especially given his history of breaking their things.

This taps into dietary inclusion in families. A 2023 study in Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior found that 73% of people with dietary restrictions feel socially excluded at gatherings when their needs are ignored. The brother’s non-vegan replacement, despite a year of vegan desserts, was a thoughtless fumble.

Dietitian Sharon Palmer says, “Respecting dietary needs fosters family unity; ignoring them breeds resentment”. Her insight nails the brother’s misstep—failing to consider their lactose intolerance turned a fixable mistake into exclusion. A quick call to them before shopping could’ve saved the day.

The teen should calmly explain their hurt, request a replacement plate, and keep baking their way. The brother needs to own his carelessness with a genuine apology.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit dove into this pie predicament with zest, tossing out quips as rich as a holiday spread. From roasting the brother’s blunder to cheering the teen’s grit, here’s a flavorful slice of their reactions, spiced with sass.

These Reddit morsels are as bold as a Thanksgiving feast, but do they dish the truth? Is the teen’s anger a justified sizzle, or too much heat in the kitchen?

This Thanksgiving tale of a trashed pie is a bittersweet blend of carelessness and courage. The teen’s fury at their brother’s wrecking of their vegan dessert and heirloom plate, topped with an inedible swap, burns bright with Reddit’s backing. As they navigate family feasts, one question lingers: can they bake peace with a brother who breaks more than pie? Readers, what would you do when a sibling ruins your dish and leaves you out? Serve up your stories and verdicts below—this saga’s still simmering!