Woman Abandons Hinge Date at Nail Salon After Being Tricked Into Paying for Her $120 Pedicure

We all know that anxious, exciting flutter in our chests when we get ready for a promising first date. For one twenty-three-year-old woman in Chicago, her hope of finding a genuine connection turned into an absolute circus when she pulled up to what she thought was her date's apartment.

After carefully vetting a Hinge match who claimed to meet all of her non-negotiable criteria, she dressed up, styled her hair, and drove out to meet her. But instead of a cozy residential street, she found herself idling in a strip mall parking lot.

What started as an awkward mix-up quickly evolved into a jaw-dropping attempt at financial manipulation that left her questioning the absolute gall of modern dating culture. If you think you've heard every nightmare first-date story out there, brace yourself. This tale of high stakes, high-end pedicures, and a legendary getaway car will make you double-check your own boundaries before your next swipe. Curious how it all unfolded? The full story is right below.

Woman Abandons Hinge Date at Nail Salon After Being Tricked Into Paying for Her $120 Pedicure

Am I The Jerk for Ditching my Date?

Setting clear boundaries on dating apps is essential, but it also raises the stakes for every match.

So I went on a date last night and I need to know if I am the jerk, because truly, I've never experienced anything like this in my life before...

I've been taking Hinge a little bit more seriously, so I have my nonnegotiable on there: have their own apartment or a house, can't have kids, pretty simple. I've been...

Her message said, 'I checked all your boxes. ' At first I forgot what was on my profile, so I asked her, and she said, 'I don't have kids. I...

And we started talking from there for about a week, casual stuff like hobbies, common interests, etc. Conversation was fine, nothing was off, vibes were good. So she asked me...

She told me she didn't have a car (which normally would be a nonnegotiable) but we live in Chicago, and it's not that abnormal to not have a car. So...

I picked this Mexican place I've been meaning to go to, it's new and by the water and I've heard a lot about it from my coworkers and this seemed...

I’m actually super jazzed, like I tried this new Pinterest hairstyle I’ve been waiting for an occasion to wear and stuff, and get in my car. And I start heading...

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m confused because I'm not seeing any apartments or houses anywhere. I moved here just in March so I’ve never been here before. So I pull in, text her, tell...

An unexpected detour to a strip mall salon sets a bizarre stage for a first face-to-face introduction.

Lady replies and says yes, and so I message, 'Which one is your apartment? ' She goes, 'Oh, I'm actually in the nail salon just finishing up! Do you wanna...

ADVERTISEMENT

She texts me that she’s waving, and I find her, sitting there getting a pedicure. I walk up and say, 'Hey, nice to meet you. ' And Lady is like,...

' So while I’m waiting for her to finish we do some small talk, and she told me she's excited for dinner, how excited she is to meet me. And...

And as we were talking, she casually drops that it’s gonna be about $120. I just give her like a confused look. And she says, 'My pedicure is gonna be...

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m actually appalled by the gall of this woman. So I finally say like, 'Oh, you want me to cover it? ' and she goes, 'Yeah, I mean I'm getting...

When faced with blatant audacity, some choose to retreat, while others lean directly into the absurdity of the moment.

Now the nail salon lady is finishing scrubbing Lady’s feet, and I’m not trying to look at her feet (because I hate feet). So I turn around and go to...

ADVERTISEMENT

Most I’ve done are press-ons from Target and those were only for my college graduation.

But then I see their pricing menu/services thing on the wall and see the $120 package is the deluxe pedicure, with like wax and alkaline and callus peels, and I...

Krabs seeing money, I swear to god, and Lady is like, 'Oh my god, you’re amazing, thank you so much. ' And I say, 'If we’re gonna make you look...

ADVERTISEMENT

' And the employee gets started, and small talk kinda dies down so I wander around the salon a bit, watch the fish, then pull out my phone and cancel...

Then I go back over to her about 10 minutes later to see how it was going, and ask Lady if she likes how it looks so far, and she’s...

Then I'm like, 'Oh my god, I'll be right back. I left my wallet in my car! Give me five minutes. ' Lady looks genuinely happy and says no problem,...

ADVERTISEMENT

I left her in the nail salon because why did you think if I was offering to take you out to dinner, you thought I was gonna pay for a...

I haven't opened Hinge since to see if she's messaged me at all. I'm glad I didn't give her my number, but I also feel kind of bad.

Updates

TL;DR: I ditched my date because she tried to rope me into paying $120 for her pedicure. Am I the Jerk for ditching her?

ADVERTISEMENT

Leaving a date stranded at a salon might feel like a scene straight out of a reality TV show, but it points to a very real and growing conflict in modern romance. This specific dynamic represents what relationship experts call opportunistic entitlement, where one party attempts to extract material benefits under the guise of romantic preparation.

When Lady assumed her date would cover a high-end personal expense, she immediately disrupted the mutual respect required for a healthy connection. It shifted the date from a mutual exploration of compatibility into a transactional arrangement. According to licensed clinical psychologist Dr. Susan Albers, establishing clear boundaries early on prevents the development of resentment in relationships.

In the fast-paced world of digital dating etiquette, some individuals test boundaries early to see how much they can get away with. While OP’s elaborate escape was an undeniably satisfying act of poetic justice, relationship coaches generally recommend a more direct approach.

ADVERTISEMENT

Simply saying, ‘I’m not comfortable paying for your pedicure, but I’ll wait for you to finish so we can head to dinner,’ would have established a firm boundary without the need for a dramatic getaway. It would have saved her from the ethical gray area of agreeing to pay and then reneging.

Community Opinions

The community was overwhelmingly amused by the clever escape, though a few commenters questioned the execution of the prank.

u/Entire-Tonight-1463
LOL you’re a queen. So much respect for you right now. 👑
NTJ

ADVERTISEMENT

u/Maximum_Sky3233 absolutely not. That's something you'd do for someone you're in a long term relationship with when it becomes a thing to take care of each other - NOT something...

u/OpportunityMother104
NTJ
LOVE THIS.
Go off queen.
This was amazing and hilarious and I kinda hope you open hinge and post her responses.
Epic.

u/Unique-Ad-9316
She only had 10 to 15 more minutes to get to finish up, but she hadn't even picked out a color yet??? AI slop.

ADVERTISEMENT

u/EnvMarple
Ntj.
I don’t know if I’d have added the extras, but I sure as hell would have bailed on her.

u/Prudent_Border5060
I love it. She totally deserved this.
If she wants to try and use people, she gets what is coming to her
Not the jerk

u/MsE0
Her trying to trick you into paying for her pedicure is unhinged behavior 

ADVERTISEMENT

u/dromof
I’m a little bit confused.
If she already ordered the deluxe package, then why did the nail tech’s eyes go huge when you asked for the skin treatment, etc.?

u/That-Ad757
23 and they need to own apt or house?? Do u

ADVERTISEMENT

u/ConchVibes
She tried to play you and you beat her at her own game.
Respect! You’re not the jerk.
You’re awesome.

u/bryzztortello
I friggin love it! Only thing that could be better is it being recorded on camera

u/Techsupportvictim If this story is real then yes you were the jerk for that stunt. You could have and should have just said No to the notion of paying from...

ADVERTISEMENT

u/MajestaHazel
This didn’t happen 🤣 everyone knows they make you pick your color the second you walk in.

u/timmmarkIII
I say it's all BS. It doesn't add up.

u/AITAfooddate LOL. But....... I do have to say yes you were the jerk because you did say you were going to pay. Though, I can't really blame you because she...

ADVERTISEMENT

A handful of skeptical users even questioned the authenticity of the story, pointing out the unusual salon logistics.

Dating in the modern era is already a minefield of mismatched expectations, but being asked to finance a luxury pedicure before even sharing an appetizer takes things to a whole new level. While some might argue that leaving her stranded was a harsh response, others feel it was a perfectly tailored lesson in mutual respect.

This experience serves as a wild reminder that clear communication is always key, even when facing absolute audacity. Do you think OP was completely justified in pulling the rug out from under her date, or should she have handled the boundary violation with a simple, direct refusal? How would you have reacted if your date handed you a hundred-dollar salon bill? Share your hot take below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *