AITA for agreeing to go on a family vacation in place of our honeymoon?

The poster explained that he agreed to join a long-standing annual family vacation just weeks after his wedding, even though it would effectively replace his honeymoon plans. The decision sparked serious conflict with his fiancée, who felt blindsided and deprioritized.

As details emerged, it became clear that the disagreement was less about travel logistics and more about boundaries, communication, and where a future spouse fits within existing family traditions. The poster questioned whether his compromise made sense, while the online community reacted strongly to his choice.

‘AITA for agreeing to go on a family vacation in place of our honeymoon?’

The poster began by explaining his family’s long-standing vacation tradition.

My family and family friends of ours go on vacation together every year. This has been a tradition since I was maybe eleven years old and I'm now 27.

Each year, my parents and the other family's parents alternate who plans and pays for the vacation. This year is our family friends' turn.

He then described his upcoming wedding and uncertain honeymoon plans.

I'm getting married in just a few weeks. We were planning on going on our honeymoon towards the end of the year but haven't put specific plans in place yet.

I work for my dad and can pretty much get off whenever I'd like but she only has so much PTO, so we're trying to be strategic with our plans.

I told everyone I would likely have to skip the vacation this year because of my fiancée's work situation and our honeymoon.

A surprise offer led to a decision that angered his fiancée.

Last week, my "bonus dad" came to me and told me he had booked a room for me and my girlfriend was more than welcome to come along too if...

ADVERTISEMENT

Honestly, there's nothing that can beat the vacations we take. The places are great and the company is even greater. My sister is so busy these days and lives out...

The family we travel with has three sons who are some of my closest friends. Beyond all of that, you can't really beat an all expenses paid holiday.

I told my fiancée about this and she's very angry I didn't immediately shut it down. I told her that we weren't required to constantly do family activities and this...

ADVERTISEMENT

We haven't started planning so there's no real plans to derail, and we can have our actual honeymoon as a first anniversary celebration since we weren't planning on going right...

A honeymoon often represents the first major decision a couple makes as a married unit, setting expectations for partnership and mutual prioritization. In this case, the poster viewed the family vacation as flexible and practical, while his fiancée likely saw it as a signal that her needs ranked below established family routines.

Opposing views might argue that postponing a honeymoon is reasonable, especially when finances, work schedules, and timing are uncertain. From that angle, combining trips could appear efficient and harmless. However, efficiency does not always translate to emotional fairness, particularly when one partner has limited time off and no input in the decision.

ADVERTISEMENT

From a broader social perspective, this story reflects the tension many couples face when transitioning from their family of origin to a new marriage. Failing to clearly shift priorities can leave one partner feeling secondary, even if no harm was intended. Communication and shared decision-making remain critical during this transition.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Many users criticized the poster, emphasizing that he failed to prioritize his future spouse.

AceyAceyAcey − YTA The correct response was “I don’t know, let me check with my fiancée first, since we haven’t set a date for the the honeymoon yet. ”

ADVERTISEMENT

You need to pick your fiancée (who IS your family now) over your natal family. If you can’t do that, don’t marry her, for her sake.

morgaine125 − YTA. If you can’t figure out that you should be including your fiancé in the honeymoon plans and that it should be something you decide together, then you’re...

Repulsive-Positive30 − YTA. And so is your bonus dad. He actually had the audacity of inviting your FIANCÉ to join the families on HER honeymoon lol Grow up. Or marry...

ADVERTISEMENT

angiehome2023 − YTA. You are saying to your fiancee that your family and your personal happiness is more important than your marriage.

painted_unicorn − YTA for what everyone's saying: you shouldn't have agreed, you didn't let your finacee have a say,

you just assumed her PTO time was better spent on a family vacation for you, you can go one year without this trip to do something romantic with your **new**...

ADVERTISEMENT

But also: it's kind of odd that your bonus dad was totally okay with her not coming but 'insisting' that you come. That's a weird thing for a family member...

Some comments expanded on the reasoning while reinforcing the criticism.

Fifty_Shades_of_Nay − YTA. My dude. What part of you thought that (1) there was any appropriate response to this other than "let me check with my soon-to-be wife" or.

ADVERTISEMENT

(2) your soon-to-be wife would be even remotely cool with turning your HONEYMOON into a family vacation with only your family? These are not rhetorical questions.

I actually want you to verbalize that thought process for Reddit because I can't imagine that a lightbulb wouldn't go off in your head with a Bart Simpson "D'OH! "...

dwotw − YTA and a lot. A honeymoon is supposed to be you and your new spouse getting to enjoy each other's company only.

ADVERTISEMENT

You went and ruined that experience with your family vacation. You made a once in a lifetime experience second to your family's wishes.

A few commenters used blunt humor to underscore their disbelief.

BentBent12 − YTA. What is wrong with you? ?? I hope she dumps you. Go on vacation with your sister. Your wife can do better.

ADVERTISEMENT

CrystalQueen3000 − YTA because you know she has limited PTO and you agreeing to go on this trip means she’ll either have to skip it or have a shorter honeymoon....

dremasterflax − I mean why get married if you want to go on a family vacation instead of with new wife

This story shows how even well-intentioned decisions can cause serious conflict when one partner feels excluded from major milestones. The disagreement wasn’t only about a trip, but about priorities and partnership at the start of a marriage.

ADVERTISEMENT

Should honeymoons always take priority over family traditions? When does compromise become a red flag? Readers are encouraged to share their thoughts and experiences.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *